Saturday, June 24, 2017

Master 7 thumping and then channel dies

On my 70 foot coax connection to the Tact, and AES after that, the Audio GD Master 7 Singularity sometimes makes thumps up to -20dB, but more typically only up to -60dB, when tracks change, when the Oppo is turned off, etc.  I suspected this what happens when the digital signal clock from the source gets off the beat in some way and the PLL servo follows for a while before deciding there is no PLL lock and then it cuts off entirely.  Before cutting off entirely, the thump occurs.

DVD-Audio discs are the worst for this kind of thing.  HRx discs seemed less affected.

I played a great HRx disc over and over, and zero thumping at all.  The spectrum of the input to the DAC (shown on one DEQ) was matching the spectrum of the output of the DAC (shown on another DEQ).

Then, the next day, it appeared on the DEQ spectrum display that over 20 hours there had been a -20dB thump from the Master 7 going down to very low frequencies, while the Oppo had been turned off.  I turned on the Oppo and now it seemed the Master 7 was not picking up 24/96 originating from the Oppo at all.  I cycled through inputs on the Tact, and sometimes it would pick it up, and sometimes not.  This was the first clear sign of a serious problem from the Master 7 since I had hooked it up using AES.

Checking it out on my Fluke 8060 meter, I noticed that the left channel, still working, did make "thumps" up to 0.2V when I was changing sources on the Tact, though usually only 40mV.  And when those thumps occur, they only slowly, over seconds, return to 0V.  The DC servo is set to a very low frequency.  For practical reasons, I'd prefer a faster return to 0V, otherwise DC is being pumped out into my speakers.

But the left channel was no longer working at all, no longer putting out signal, though it was still thumping.  Perhaps it got 'locked up' somehow.

I've taken it offline.  I need something extremely reliable.  Will retest later.  Now I'm thinking the whole episode since Master 7 arrived has been enormously frustrating.  Now I'm again beginning to worry it was behind other problems like the shutdowns, though I actually don't have any clear evidence, other than the thumping, and now the apparently dead channel, that it had been doing anything wrong after I connected the DAC itself using AES.  I'm don't know what I'm going to do with the Master 7, can I get it fixed, can I get as much as half of my money out of it???

Hooked up my Denon DVD-9000 as DAC.  It is very sweet sounding, but I fear not as magically transparent as the Master 7.  I suspect the Denon could be much better with a better analog output stage and balanced outputs.

Back when I ordered Master 7, I was thinking of Kingwa as a sort of latter day James Bongiorno, a charismatic and uncompromising designer making legendary products.  But Kingwa is apparently doing much better, as it seemed James left company after company and finally his two signature companies GAS and Sumo failed, whereas Audio GD has continued for more than a decade now.  So maybe Kingwa got it right.

There was a downside I know of.  GAS equipment was not the most reliable.  I 'failed' a Grandson amp once merely by power cycling it too fast, it was killed by its own servo loop.  Later I had endless RFI issues with my own Son of Ampzilla, which I was never able to fix (I still have it in storage many decades later).  Seeing the way it was built with lots of plug-in boards made me wonder how robust it was.

Perhaps what was missing was better production engineering.  Perhaps Bongiorno had taken on and/or delegated too many things to people who were not qualified.  There is something to be said about a company with more than one good engineer, good enough not to always be a yes man.

Now I'm wondering if Audio GD doesn't indeed follow suit.

A friend of mine, reading about the Master 7 Singularity, thought it might better to use the standard SPDIF receiver chips, custom receiver programming is work for a team of engineers, checking each other out, beta testing, and so on.  I told him custom digital receivers were nothing new, Levinson and others were doing that long ago, the Levinson 360S also uses a custom programmed receiver.  Recently I've been wishing I had bought one of those instead, I'm thinking it wouldn't have issues like I've seen, and it was fully tested and looked fantastic in test by John Atkinson.

Update: I connected the Denon DVD-9000, which never had a hitch reading the signal through all my digital stuff from the Kitchen Oppo.

But it has a large latency, over 300 ms, that I can't correct for with my DEQ.  I'll need another DEQ, that still seems to be the best option.  That will give me more parametric filters too...

I learned to like the sound of the 9000 after some changes.  But the latency makes it useless.  I heard the latency right off, but I didn't measure it until much later, after coming to think for awhile it wasn't there anymore--but on speaker pop it was like two separate sounds, bouncing back and forth.  But for some of the day before learning to like the 9000 I had been listening to the DAC 19 again.

I found the SpeakerPop sound to be a good way of setting the alignment by ear.  I think I can do that within 0.2 ms or so, though I actually set it to 3.79ms, a little lower than before.  I need to measure it of course but that requires either the Tact setup or REW or a scope.  I tried a new scope app and it wasn't much use for lack of triggering.

But there was a problem doing the 88 kHz with the Dac 19 again.  But I then found I could fix it by re-tightening the F connector that connects to the cross attic RG6.  Perhaps that was why the Master 7 hadn't been picking up the Oppo signal well, though that didn't explain the channel dropout: I'm thinking that was caused by me flipping through the Tact selector a few times, making those little thumps I described before (and if they stayed little, I could live with that, and it was seeming that normal DVD-Audio track changes and that sort of thing were only -60dB or so LF thumps.  But when I got home, possibly some noise on the line had caused the -20dB thump clearly visible on the peak hold spectrum, and then the Oppo connection wasn't working on the Master 7 reliably, possibly explaining that.

BTW both the Dac 19 anniversary and the Denon are completely thump free.  On the Denon there seem to be endless relays clicking for this and that.  But there is never a thump.  The Dac 19 has no relays but is still thump free, even when I was messing with the F connector aformentioned getting 88kHz to play, it was a live line going in and out until I finally got it tighened correctly but no thumping--a very difficult case (the very case that had probably caused the -20dB thump on the Master 7).


I'm now hoping Master 7 "fixes itself" like the Krell did simply by being powered off long enough.  We'll see.  Otherwise, I'll have to see if I can get warranty repair before trying to sell it.

At it's best, the Denon DVD-9000 is nearly there, and it clearly has more resolution than the Dac 19, but more closed sound which is actually quite nice and sweet and helps you enjoy the music.  I'd be playing it right now, overall I consider it better than the DAC 19, except the midrange delay muddies up everything, and even 300 + 3.79 ms adjustment isn't quite enough to fix it, and that's more important than anything.

I realize now the Denon DVD-5000 on the super tweeters probably has a similar delay, meaning that I would be better simply delaying the bass line.

But if I can get the Master 7 going again, and weird problems don't come back, I could put the Dac 19 on the tweeters, which had been the plan (though, when the Oppo line wasn't working, I was thinking of putting the Dac 19 into my analog resampling group).

I've been listening to straight through digital, and I think because of finally getting the polarity correct, after who know how long, loving it more than ever.  I even made it through the 2017 Grammy collection just now.











Friday, June 23, 2017

Klipsch vs Altec

Just surfing around, I found this very interesting discussion of Klipsch vs Altec, two major (and very long lived) manufacturers who have made well regarded horn based speakers.

In a 1965 test, the Altecs are said to have originally sounded colder than Klipsch, but got better with certain improvements in the 1970's, and now some posters prefer them (notably, the Model 19).

Klipsch has also gotten better, it seems the K55 midrange driver sounded bad above it's range and was not crossed over steeply enough, a later revision added steeper crossover which improved sound considerably.  Many Klipsch owners had been using Altec midranges to get away from the K55.  Similarly a crossover revision added steeper crossover for the K77 tweeter, which didn't sound good low in its range.


Thursday, June 22, 2017

Rebooting the Krell

Every owner of a FPB 300, FPB 600, or subsequent Krell amplifier should know this.  I don't see it in my owners manual, so either you have to figure it out (as I have done...though I think I read about it somewhere but can't find the original discussion now) or, contact Krell (using form on website) with a problem, and they may tell you to try this first.

Manually flipping the breaker at the back of the amp, and/or unplugging from the wall for awhile, is one way which can fix certain kinds of problems, notably the problem I had been having for the last 3 weeks in which I blamed virtually every other component first (I should have thought of testing the Krell back during the first panicky week, but since it just came back from service, since I know it can output well in excess of the 5 amps required to blow Acoustat fuses, and I didn't want to believe the Krell was at fault, perhaps only input/output cables, AC power, the speakers, etc).  The amplifier was shutting down after less and less time, first time it shut down after several hours, then almost an hour, and finally it took a mere 5 minutes to get to shutdown.  (It was not blowing the breaker in back, that is serious stuff and you must contact Krell then.  My FPB 300 was shutting down with the power light still illuminated, and no other lights, and the manual says that means either inadequate AC power, or shorted speaker or cables.)

Finally, just as I was about to contact Krell, since it had finally seemed I had proven the amplifier was at fault because the problem stayed in the same amplifier channel even after I changed both the inputs and outputs to the ones normally used by the other channel, using a now dedicated 20a line, it occurred to me I should try the unplugging trick.  So I did, on Wednesday night, 3 weeks after I started having problems.

Most recently it seemed that using the right channel of the Krell would cause a shutdown within 5 minutes.  But after unplugging the Krell for a few hours, I played 90 minutes full tilt without a problem.

This is pretty good evidence this makes a difference, perhaps less that I have finally fixed the problem, but I really hope so of course.

I think what happens is that the Krell while still AC powered saves information about the bias voltages required to reach different plateau levels.  This enables the plateau thing to work as advertised.  But if the Krell is subjected to a catastrophic situation, one in which fuses blow, for example, it can store bad info, and this bad info leads to future misbehavior.

Now, this could simply be a bug in the original plateau bias system (which is managed by a chip I've seen on the schematic, I haven't looked closely but I usually call this "the Krell computer").  Maybe later amps fixed this "bug."  But it's also a kind of feature.  If a user is doing bad stuff, such as running against AC power limits as I think I may have been sometimes doing (until I moved the subs to a different circuit this month) the company wants you to contact them so they can advise you to do things differently.

Also, take this as a correction or addition to the stream of posts I was making this month while trying to track down this problem.  After I had given up trying to tweak my way around the shutdowns, I "determined" (incompletely and falsely, apparently) that the Acoustat speakers were at fault.  I had seem the Acoustat MK-121-C interface fail before--that happened to me in 2009.  That time, instead of the amplifier shutting down without any sign of distress, it blew fuses.  It blew fuses more and more often, and the problem quickly went away when I replaced that interface unit with a New Old Stock replacement interface unit I purchased on eBay for $75 more than I had paid for the pair of speakers with two interfaces.  It seemed like a bit of a ripoff then (it wasn't at all, such things are unobtanium and only a distant dream now, I was simply amazing lucky, as if the heaven of Acoustat lovers wanted to keep me in the fold) but I thought it was well worth it, now that I had fallen in love with Acoustats.

Let me add, though there has been some great fear at times, mostly this month has been lots and lots of fun....trying stuff, seeing what different things do, and being forced to play more music because I had to do more tests.  (Sometimes, quite often actually, I don't play music because I'm feeling down and I don't want to take the trouble to figure out what to play--that's the hardest part for me.  But when I've got to figure something out, I have GOT to play something.)

My biggest fear actually was that I'd be stuck with a somewhat malfunctioning new $2500 dac which the factory wouldn't fix (because they aren't responsible for complex SPDIF setups or something) and couldn't unload either because it was customized and when I told any potential buyer of the problem I was having (that is always my policy btw, full disclosure) they'd move on too.

So when it finally appeared that the DAC was not the source of the problem (because problem went away when I disconnected the right speaker) I was inclined to immediately go with the new idea that the speaker was at fault, even though I did not check to see whether it was the right speaker OR the right amplifier channel that was doing this.  I should have tried the right speaker on the left channel.  An obvious thing to do to a thinking audiophile, but I wasn't thinking too clearly.  Also, I strongly didn't want to blame the amp because though it has been fully repairable by the factory so far, it's also costly and huge amount of effort to pack and ship the amplifier back.

I finally did do the required test this week, and found the problem always remained in the right amplifier channel even driven by the left DAC channel and playing the left speaker.  For a day, I had been planning my message to Krell.  But when writing a friend about the problem, the reboot idea came back to me.  I did try that last year before contacting Krell, but it didn't help last year, the amplifier truly needed the Capacitor Service it got, it was 18 years old after all, and came back operating better than it ever had before in my 9 year experience (leading me to believe now it was actually a bit off when I bought it).

This time, rebooting fixed the Krell, I hope, and problems will disappear for long enough to consider it a perfect repair.

Update: Further investigation has revealed the Krell does indeed have an 8Mhz microprocessor in each channel to control the plateau bias, monitor DC offset and other bad situations, and prevent using the amplifier in different world region than intended.  This is discussed at DIYAudio.

The microcontroller in FPB 300/600 is a 68HC711E9.  The generic form of this now discontinued microcontroller has 512 bytes of ram, 512 bytes of EEPROM, and 12kbytes of EPROM, along with 8 channels of 8 bit A/D conversion.  The specific 711E9 version seems to more like 10 channels of A/D conversion, or so it seems from the schematic.   They connect to various sensors and circuits in the amplifier.  Other than this microcontroller, in some ways the FPB is simpler than other amplifiers, because it does not have specific protection circuits of various kinds like typical amplifiers do--where often most of the complexity is.  The microcontroller handles all the protection issues, and can shut down the amplifier with various combinations of lights lit.  I wonder if this microcontroller isn't a descendent of the Motorola 68000 series originally used in Mac and Amiga and the earliest Sun computers.  The first Amigas also ran at  8 Mhz.

I don't know this as a fact, but it has seemed like that 512 bytes (or more) of ram inside the microcontroller could get corrupted by certain situations, requiring the power cycling I have described.

One thing I might have done to corrupt it was this.  I was changing cables and for some reason I had to get underneath the power cord.  So I flipped the back breaker and temporarily removed and replaced the power cord, then flipped the breaker back on.  This would not have been a problem EXCEPT for one thing: the amplifier was already hot when I did this, and I went back to full power operation immediately after restarting.  If the amplifier does some sort of calibration when AC power is started (as I am guessing) if you reset the breaker when the amplifier is warm it might get the bias calibration wrong.  Krell advises using the soft touch power button to go into standby instead, but of course you can't do that if you are removing the power cord.

From now on, if for any reason I remove power or flip the breaker on the back, I will wait until the amp cools before restarting.  If this is the actual cause of the shutdown issues I was seeing, it's a real hoot because I had so many other ideas.

Now I remember a similar situation occurred just before I put the amplifer in my air conditioned storage building in 2011 for 2.5 years.  That time I was trying to reduce "clinking" by moving the amplifier to the left side of the room.  So I flipped breaker, unplugged and replugged in the new location a couple minutes later.  Then I turned on amplifier while still hot, and it shut down within a few minutes.  Fearing a major problem, I put the amp away.

When I took the amp out of storage I had the nerve to try it again.  And then, except for the right channel always getting much hotter (a problem fixed during capacitor service in February 2017) it ran fine for almost a year.









Sunday, June 18, 2017

Peterson Information Theory

(Named after me, of course.)

In Peterson Information Theory, the composition of a composite signal is the important thing, not what can, under some circumstances, be reliably detected later.   In other words, the information is what goes in.  A fairly intuitive notion, actually, until about 1900, when the importance of the observer became paramount in many fields.

So this is similar to how many subjectophiles believe that analog has infinite resolution, whereas digital has finite resolution.  However, that intuitive believe, in the full context of PIT becomes very qualified.

For one thing, at worst, properly implemented digital has incredibly fine resolution, about 100 times finer the the apparent quantization, for various reasons, which in the case of 24 bit digital is pretty mind boggling and probably adequate to be considered "infinite."

For another analog itself is limited at many levels, even if you discount "noise" as PIT tends to do.  Noise does not "obscure" simply because PIT doesn't involve itself with "obcuring," there is a kind of belief that in the infinitude of listenings, all the obscuring will be seen around in one way or another, freak unrepeatable occurances perhaps but important to the evolution of feeling.

One obvious level of limitation of the supposedly unlimited resolution is the quantum level, though that is quite far away.  But any reduction in voltage, say, does actually reduce information in that way, and it turns out, in others.

Many aspects of circuits we deal with actually do not involve fully continous phenomenon.  For example, both magentic tape and analog recordings do not slice at quantum levels, even at best they slice at molecular levels.  So now we are up quite aways from "infinity" or even the 10e-33 of quantum levels.  Infinite resolution there never is.

But I'm not claiming infinity, just a different way of scoring.

And so it matter that the DAC actually attempts to do 24 bits, or just fakes it.  No question about it, true PCM chips like 1704 "attempt" to do 24 bits in that there are resistors that get switched in and out to do that.  The attempt falls far short (perhaps 20 bits or so actually accuracy) because thermal effects and others cause everything not to be as perfectly calibrated as when the manufacturing was done.  But in PIT, that doesn't matter as much as the information not being there, for that lack of 24 bit performance is caused by an "obscuring," not by a lack of doing.

But all kinds of Sigma Delta systems never ever try to "do" high accuracy.  They fake it by doing low accuracy lots of times with feedback so they ultimately achieve something like high accuracy.  But that is what PIT views as not actually doing it, but faking it.

When things are so faked, they lack their attachment to reality, they become unreal in one way or another.  So Sigma Delta reproduction is cleaner than clean, cleaner than the real thing itself, because it is built on repeated self cleaning, rather than just doing things right, or as best as possible, in the first place, with maybe a little crud added here or there in the process.

When we demand that each layer of a system be truly crud free, we cannot achieve what we set out to do, the crud creeps back in some other way.  Best to create processes which create only very little crud in the first place.  So we have balanced circuits, cascodes, Class A operation, differential, etc.  Those are all low crud.  Feedback is only a way of taking errors in one domain and shifting them to another domain.  It may be needed in some cases, but best be low crud in the first place.

Anyway, that's my unscientific irrationality spelled out, and why I like no feedback (or non-global at least) and true PCM such as R2R type DACs.

That's why I wanted a Master 7 Singularity, not because I wanted to experiment with NOS or I2S.

The Master 7 has a highly sophisticated non-feedback direct coupled semiconductor circuitry, combined with dual differntial 1704's--a configuration which really helps pull out more of the true 24 bit "doings" going on in there.

Mind you, op amps are so small, feedback around them is probably ok, not unlike local degeneration. The only op amp that should be used is the best, OPA 211.

Tubes are mostly used as coloring agents, not to make things more transparent but to add tint or bloom.  Tubes can in some cases be done at the state of the art, but that is exceedingly rare.  I know of some almost unique tubes and designs up there.  Allen Wright's balanced RTP3D preamp looks pretty good, that's the least obscure, then there are some ultra rare high current microwave tubes, rarely done (but never to state of the art, which would include full balanced) an extremely tricky to work with,  and balanced OPA 211 with passive EQ between amps (no product that I know of does that).

Oversampling is not bad because that's not feedback, at most it's feed forward, or more technically, I see it as the ultimate end-procedure of the digital process, which helps enable the full potential dynamic range.  It's not endlessly overloading tail catching feedback.

Strangely 1 bit may be sort of ok (at DSD128 rates) because it is actually doing what it is doing, one bit is a perfect 1 bit.  Any multibits until full multibit is only an approximation, which must endlessly dither to serve the present physical world, and therefore strangulate the past with the present, rather than letting the past flow freely in.

*****

Thinking about the above, I wonder if I haven't become something like a Schitt salesman.  They are also in the anti-delta-sigma camp.  I don't think ANY true audio objectivists I know (about) would consider this anything but the usual subjectivist crap.  To a fully died Objectophile, all that matters is the (measured) distortion and noise, and getting there the cheapest way possible, which is delta sigma.  Delta sigma dacs became popular when they could approach and then ultimately exceed the performance (S/N, dynamic range, linearity, and distortion) of the R2R chips.  And that became the big commercial end of the Burr Brown PCM 1704, though it appears they were still making a few as late as 2010 or so still being under intense demand by high end companies.

There is a growing list of High End audio companies that have embraced the pro-PCM and anti-Delta-Sigma ideas like I have presented, including:

Schiit (their statement DACs are all PCM and they strongly defend this)

Audio GD (they had their feet in both waters, but are seem to have more fully embraced PCM solutions now, if nothing else to own the low cost cult market)

MSB (they make multichip PCM converters from high to super high prices)

CH Precision (with their megabuck products, you can have it either way)

At the end of the day, I won't disagree with the idea that speakers and room acoustics are more important.  If there is a there here, it probably isn't that big.

But somehow I've fallen into the trap, and I don't necessarily feel good that it has distracted me from the more important speaker adjustment and EQ work.

But it has also been a learning, it's a little bug to make you keep listening, and I've had lots of fun exploring my edge of the world.

At the same time, there is nothing really Objectively wrong about the PCM 1704 chip, it has adequate measured performance, anything that seems to have Even better performance (like the latest ESS chips for example) isn't really necessary.

It seems to me that once you attain "adequate" objective performance, you ought to be free to explore your own angles without too much sneering.

Many people feel that they ought to be able to explore their own angles no matter what, and measurements don't matter, etc.  This is where I do not go myself, but if other people want to go that way, it's their hobby.



The zero jitter synchronous DAC

Just to show a fully synchronous (as I think I like) DAC can be made to have zero jitter, along with the usual full information preservation of fully synchronous, consider the "memory dac."

In the worst case, it could simply store entire songs to memory, then play them out.  That's the proof that this is possible.  However an open line that just stays running digital audio for hours...you wouldn't want to wait until the next day to play your audio would you?  So, while it's possible to to have a simple spdif DAC with an absolutely perfect (or at least from the stanpoint of the 'better' DAC) clock, at minimum you have to change the clock speed in the dac to match the source over any reasonably long amount of time.

But it wouldn't be hard not to have it that hard.  Or just the obvious thing to do is keep a sort of clock quality whenever a digital SPDIF/AES line is locked up, a notion of how much the clock has moved around, so how much needs to be allowed for.

The quality analysis is used in figuring the size of a buffer needed to keep up with changes.  Then there may be some lag when any playback is started, because of allowances for small irregularities.

Now in this scheme, you can't have a perfectly on-time clock, you need to set the ultimate clock based on the analysis of the line as well.

And in worst cases, you may need to make slow changes to the clock rate to keep things going.  But that's very small changes, and very slow changes.

OK, so maybe not exactly zero jitter.  But it can be zero above some very low frequencies where it is even more inaudible than other frequencies.  (Remember, digital jitter being important in audio is just hype, it isn't really, though the hardware obsessed audiophile just wants to make everything perfect just because, I draw the line at two way digital interfaces because that's a loss of flexibility for me.)

Now this quality thing could be remembered, perhaps until you give some kind of reset, or when the cables are changed.  So after the first time out it has pretty good knowledge of the source clock.



Friday, June 16, 2017

AES/SPDIF Forever!

I am deeply philosophically (as well as somewhat economically) opposed to the use of 2-way interfaces, including USB and I2S, as a means of audio interconnection.

First, it must be said that AES/SPDIF are perfectly fine.  Under the normally specified limits (is it 30M for coax, 200M for AES ?) these can be shown to produce typically 200 pS jitter (my complex system does that), and that is 50 times below demonstrated audible limits in pure sine waves, and 100 times demonstrated audible limits in best case music on headphones only (famous AES publication).

In my system a typical input goes through 4 digital interconnections, 3-4 of them AES and the other SPDIF.  I could add a few more AES layers, and it would still be 200 pS.

I banished Toslink only a couple years ago (and I had actual glass Toslink cables) because Toslink transmission is measureably worse, above 500 pS, but not because it actually makes a difference.  I tried an unbalanced coax into my dac, which I was afraid might cause ground loops, but it didn't anyway, so I went wired all the way, wired is demonstrably better, and no sacrifice in this case.  Complex systems like mine (which uses some prosumer equipment) generally work best with AES, thought, technically, there's a small loss in bandwidth that comes with the signal isolation, but much less so than toslink.  But coax seemed fine with the Audio GD Dac 19 (I had coax muting issues with the Master 7 Singularity, though I haven't retested since enabling the PLL), and the Onkyo and Denon DACs I have used.

Anyway, this transmission jitter, produced by a dumb detector, is nothing in the final analysis.  Any decent receiving system using PLL or Asynchronous reception can in principal reduce effective jitter to zero, so whatever jitter ultimately appears in the output could have been avoided (personally I prefer PLL which I think of as good enough, and it uniquely preserves the original data, which somehow I think is important, I  will admit though I'm not an expert on what Asynchronous can do).  Most jitter that we have seen has been highly avoidable with AES and SPDIF.  And down below 200 pS, it wouldn't matter anyway if the DAC manufacturer did nothing about it.  But certainly high frequency jitter can be reduced to zero, the only frequency variation being the comparatively slow changes of the source clock, which may have to be accomodated, but that very low frequency (much less than 1 Hz)  jitter is even less audible, within the typical bounds.

[There is acutally a matter of trust here.  We trust that the source of the transmission has a very stable clock, since in the end that is what is driving things, the other end has to follow in the long run, and it's best not to be snapped around.  In the beginning CD players and the like may have been among the most expensive things in an audio system, and have the best clocks.  Nowadays, it's typically to have inexpensive front ends, and have all the expense in the DAC system, so the DAC manufacturer would like to have it their way in the clocking...I think that may be possible with with USB and I2S...but personally I'm fine with trusting the front end, I always attend to that, in my AES/SPDIF practice.  Or I trust another one of them...  Rolling sources is my fun, you see.  You who use cheap sources typically use USB or I2S now anyway, so keep on with your mega expensive dac clocks and so on, and never mind me, though I suspect that any non-super-cheap device is going to be OK, have long term clock drift at essentially undetectable levels anyway, so good for those who don't feel the need to bother with the fancy back end anyway.]

I2S itself is a two wire interface when computer systems have been going one wire.  I2S was designed for doing communication within one box.  It requires setting up a master-slave relationship, which in an interconnect system really requires software negotiation.  Now you're talking proprietary software of all kinds, drivers, stuff you will endless have to buy and to mess with.  And USB has already proven itself to be that way manifoldly.

AES/SPDIF has been plug and play since the beginning, it is an open system and easy to understand, and philosophically there's something I like about the free flowing nature of it.  Easily divided, endlessly rerouted, distributed, switched, split,  (not combined).  That's the kind of flexibility anyone who is messing with a complex system wants.

But as always, the industry would prefer to sell top to bottom systems, wipe out all that complexity, and the drive to systems like USB and especially I2S exactly does that.  Getting to any kind of distribution beyond 1 to 1 with I2S...isn't that pretty difficult?

In my view, that's back to being the victim of industry, rather than the beneficiary of it.

AES/SPDIF is good enough!  Let's stick with that!

More Rational Audiophile Hobby

I strongly agree with Archimago's comments here.

As per my comment there, I will try to avoid using the term The High End.  However, I think it's reasonable to use a term like 'serious' audio.  Even a $39 streamer can be 'serious' audio, it's not a matter of price, it's a matter of being oriented to technical quality vs low price and marketing sheen.

I very much like that Archimago thinks digital at 24/96 may be worth a bit more than 44.1/16, but beyond that is a fools errand.  That's were I stand.

Also that he thinks DSD128 is possibly worthwhile, but DSD256 and beyond becomes a waste of bits (as an end product, I might add).

A lot of what I do is solidly in the "rational" audio camp, such as my embrace of DSP for speaker and room correction, and even sonic euphanization.  Culty subjectivists won't step near these things, and I get criticized for "over-complexity" when I'm simply doing the rational things which must be done.

But why oh why do I bother with a $2500 DAC?  Does that show me to be strongly irrational?  Why do I bother with collecting particular spinning disc players (that used the best R2R chips)?

Let me first say this is a new thing for me.  I didn't even use any component level DACs until about 3 years ago.  I'd been an audiophile for 44 years before without having anything like that.  Most recently, I had simply used the DACs built in to the Behringer DCX 2496 crossover I was using, which used fine chips but had analog circuitry not at the highest level of performance, and not at all suited to the gain structure of my system, putting out 10V RMS at 0dB.

So buying my first component DAC was a means to respectable technical performance, since now 0dB would correspond to 2V, giving me lower noise and distortion always.

It's true that the particular DAC I chose would be more difficult to specifically justify (the Audio GD Dac 19 anniversary) as many similar products had equal measured performance.  I could have gotten something of similar objective performance for a bit less (though, not much).

But it strongly appealed to a certain iconoclastic side I must have.  I've taken on the R2R or 'true PCM' religion, somehow, perhaps for no good reason, just because it sounds good to my thinking.

I'm not saying everyone should do this, but I have chosen to.  BTW, the ideas also sound good to many audiophiles I know.  I think it's ok for me to nurture a few ideas out of the mainstream.

One think I won't do, however, is step too far beyond things that could be objectively seen as having audibly inferior performance.  I won't use high noise or distortion products, like SET amplifiers, or NOS DACs.

So when I figured the ultimate requirement for the gain structure in my system, and I was still able to get a DAC with AES input, balanced outputs, DC coupling with servo, and (my little iconoclasm) dual differential 1704's, I decided to go for it.

And I still like it very much, as I hope to for decades to come, because I indeed think it is good enough just as it is.

I  dislike being scolded by people who say money shouldn't be spent on such things, people like the commenter who calls himself Blog in the posting linked above.

As I've pointed out before, looking closely at what such people actually do, THEY have their little irrationalities also, and some of them even have far more expensive audio systems than I do, despite the scolding being dished out to others.