Saturday, November 5, 2011

(unconfirmed) Aragon Bias Adj Instructions

Here are the Aragon bias adjustment instructions, from some unconfirmed tech support document.  See my very important (of course) comments below:

2000 & 3000               4-6 mV EACH CHANNEL
SERIES                      


8008ST & BB             INNER CHANNEL-12mV             
and MKII                   OUTER CHANNEL-  8mV                  

8008X3 & X3B    8-10mV EACH CHANNEL                   

8002                            8-10mV EACH CHANNEL                   

PALLADIUM        II            INNER CHANNEL-25mV             
& 1K                          OUTER CHANNEL-20mV               
                                    W/ TOP COVERS ON-HEATSINK TEMP-118 DEG. F.



4004                            6-8mV EACH CHANNEL                
2004                            4-6mV EACH CHANNEL    




A100,A100X3
A200,A200X3
DIA150,A125X5       6mV EACH CHANNEL                

IMPORTANT NOTE:  RUN AMPS UNDER LOAD UNTIL HEATSINKS REACH OPERATING TEMPERATURE.  REMOVE SIGNAL AND LET AMP TO IDLE AT LEAST 2 MINUTES TO STABILIZE.  RESET BIAS TO INDICATED VALUES

I realize now this is a very ambiguous document.  What exactly does "run amps under load" mean, how much power output, continuous sine or music test, and into what load or efficiency speakers?  And what is the "operating temperature" ?

This is far more important that a reader might assume.  The heatsinks in the 8008 and Palladium series amplifier have very large thermal mass.  If they are heated up sufficiently, 2 minutes is no where near long enough to cool down enough to approach the stable bias level.

An hour or more  might be required.  While I determined my outer channel emitter resistor voltage approaches 26mV in a long term idle warmup, when I run my amp for 30 minutes at moderate level into killer load (Acoustat !+1's) it gets hot enough to roll the voltage to 14mV for a many minutes; I watched it for 15 minutes or so and it hadn't significantly moved upwards.  This is because high heatsink temperature causes the bias compensation transistor to cut back the idle current to some minimum level.  Only when the heatsinks have cooled down sufficiently is the normal idling bias restored.

So if you start out with heasinks at a relatively high temperature, and allow only two minutes, what you may be setting is actually the minimum bias level, not the long term level.

Friday, November 4, 2011

Up and down and up with Aragon 8008 bias level

I've now watched the Aragon bias level over more than an hour.  It may be on the high side of normal for this amplifier, possibly due to long term drift of some kind, but the bias circuit seems to be working and the high bias may be part of why the amp sounds so good.

Within a minute, the outer channel bias is at 21 mv (NOTE: I mean the voltage measured across the 0.33 ohm emitter resistors, I use the term "bias" for that measurement in this post.)  20mv is specified for a Palladium amp, which has the same size heatsinks; 8mv is specified for the 8008 by Klipsch tech support, but I'm wondering if these specifications aren't deliberately conservative.  At two minutes, it's roughly up to 25mV.   At that time, there is about 160 watts total quiescent power draw, same as I measured after leaving on overnight (though, based on later data, I believe that corresponds to 26mV long term average bias).  24mV is the specified value for the inner channel on a Palladium, so it can't be too bad, if actually being used the amp will dissipate much more power than that.

From there, the bias keeps rising until it reaches a peak of 30.3mV at 6 minutes, with total power draw of 192 watts.  It slowly starts falling, reaching 29.8 at 10 minutes with 187 watt draw.  At 20 minutes, it'd down to 26.45 with 168 watt draw.  At 30 minutes, it's down to 26.1 with 158 watt draw.  Here my notes stopped, but I recall it got down to about 24mV (140W or so) and started rising again, peaking just over 26mV and falling again.

Apparently there is some oscillation caused by the thermal mass of the heatsink between the power transistors and the bias regulator transistor.  Over many hours, as every part of the amp rises to its long term most uniform temperature, the oscillations should largely damp out, theough I recall still seeing a few watts fluctuation around roughly 160 watts quiescent after 10 hours of idling.  There may also be some effect caused by airflow from my HVAC system cycling on and off.

When the amp is actually operated, as I discovered last night, the bias cuts back.  I observed 14 mV bias after playing music at moderately high level for 30 minutes, at which point quiescent power draw was below 140 watts.  That must help the heatsinks from getting too hot.

All in al, I think this is about right for me, about the highest bias possible for this amp, but probably enough downward bias regulation and heatsink capacity to handle any loads I will actually throw at it.

If it becomes a problem, say if I can't party all weekend without tripping thermal cutout, I can adjust bias downward to the specs suggested by tech support, which must have been intended to handle exactly that sort of situation.  I do have an above average line voltage and far below average efficiency speaker.  But I don't tend to listen with average levels above 90dB, and even continuous use on my part is not likely to cause rise to cutout temperatures, especially because I run the bass below 84 Hz on my subwoofers and not the panels.  (When, years ago, I caused my Parasound HCA-1000A to thermally shut down, I was not only running the bass on the panels I was attempting to increase the highs with some equalization.)

Clearly the amp should not be left on all the time, it wastes a lot of power, shortens lifespan of parts, and serves little purpose because the amp warms up to full bias anyway within 2 minutes.  But my fear that amp still hadn't reached full bias after 30 minutes of operation yesterday, would rise to 160W overnight, and then just keep on going upward relentlessly were unfounded.  Actually, the amp reaches full bias after about 2 minutes of operation, overshoots by 25%, and then has some damped oscillation staying within 10% of full (26mV) bias, and cuts back bias by 50% under heavy use until the heat sinks cool down.  These are indications of well thought out design, not failing circuitry.

Now I can also calculate the amount of linear Class A operation.  26mV across 0.33 ohms is 0.0788 amps.  The total current across 6 pairs of transistors is 0.473 amps.  Twice that can be delivered to speaker in Class A: 0.946.  Peak power into 8 ohms is 7.16.  RMS is 3.58.  While the amp is playing, it heats up and the bias, and therefore the Class A power, drops a bit.  If I cut the bias back to tech support specs, I'd get less than a watt in Class A.



Wednesday, November 2, 2011

Class A Watts

Everybody seems to get this wrong.  Nelson Pass explains a hypothetical case very clearly, but when it comes to his own amp, he is wrong too (OK, just very slightly wrong, you could call it rounding error compared with the liberties most manufacturers take).

I think what's happening is there are two definitions of Class A.  The textbook definition (linear operation...to his credit Nelson Pass uses that one), and the stretched to cutoff definition, and most people use that.

Start with my Aragon 8008BB idling at 160W, with heatsink temperature at 132 degrees F (I'm sure it shouldn't be hotter than that).  First of all, since this is a stereo amplifier, that means the idle is 80W per channel.

The RMS output maxes around 45V, which means the rails must be about 67V, about right for a 250W into 8 ohms amplifier (which it is, the 200W spec into 8 ohms is conservative in order to allow the doubling into 4 ohms).  Update: the PS schematic says 70 volts, I will correct the following analysis for that.

Assuming that all the quiescent power is dissipated in the output transistors (which would be a limiting case maximizing bias current and therefore Class A operation), this means the current running through from the top rail to the bottom rail for each channel is 80W / 140V or 0.57 amps.  If you simply summed all the transistor currents, you'd get 1.14 amps, but I don't think that's a helpful way to think about this, since half are in series with the other half.

In Class A operation one side goes from 0.57 amps to 1.14 amps while the other goes to zero.  So the peak output current in class A is 1.14 amps.  That makes the Class A peak to peak power 1.14 * 1.14 * 8 or 10.4 watts peak to peak, or 5.2 watts RMS.  Very far from the 26wpc Aragon claims.

I suspect this is because cutoff to zero doesn't actually happen on one rail side until the other side is conducting considerably more than 2x the standing bias current.  So Aragon/Mondial/Klipsch hooked up scope, and observed the level where cutoff to zero was happening on one side.  But this is non-linear operation to cutoff, and wouldn't work without a push-pull feedback amplifier design.

But it gets worse.  Not all power is dissipated in the output transistors.  The actual bias specified for the amp (in an unconfirmed memo at DIYAudio) is 12 mv across 0.33 ohm resistors on the inner channel, 8mv across 0.33 ohms on the outer.  That would mean, for the inner channel, the bias current per transistor is 0.036 amp, or 0.22 for all six on one side.  That would mean 0.44 amp peak class A current, or 1.6 peak to peak class A watts, or 0.8 RMS Class A watts.  BTW, the power transistor dissipation for that channel would be 30.8 watts, with 20.5 watts for the other channel, for a total consumption (not including other circuitry) of 51 watts.  It is hard to imagine the remaining 109 watts dissipated elsewhere, so I'm sure my amplifier must be drawing more bias current than that!

My amp bias seems may be similar to the  Palladium II according to the memo, which is specified as 25mV for the inner channel, which would correspond to bias per rail side of .456 amp, and therefore (assuming +/- 70V rails) per-channel dissipation of 64 watts in the power transistors of that channel, and 51 watts in the outer channel having specified bias voltage of 20mV.

Update: it looks like my amp is indeed close to the Palladium specification.  In the outer channel I noticed bias voltage around 22 mV after 5-10 minutes of warm up when the total power dissipated was 166 watts.  Unfortunately, not thinking them important, I didn't write these numbers down, so this might be a somewhat inaccurate recollection.  Later, after playing the amp for a half hour, and 20 minutes of stabilization, the recorded bias voltage was 14mV with power of 132 watts.  I didn't measure the 6 hour warm up bias, where the quiescent dissipation reaches 160W, and possibly having the cover off for measurement affected the results, but 20mV +/- 2mV would be consistent with these findings.  The palladium specifications would account for 115w of quiescent power, the where does the remaining 45w go?  Power supply transformers and filter caps, and two large driver boards could easily account for that.  Solid state preamps can use as much as that.  Also I may have larger rail voltage than spec, since my AC power is around 123V.

I'm thinking that the memo from Tech Support does not necessarily reflect what the factory did.  Tech support was possibly giving out more conservative bias setting numbers than required for two reasons: (a) concern that repair shops wouldn't do the proper days long burn-in as done at the factory, and (b) those people who have already had trouble with their amps, which is likely why they would need servicing, should probably use lower bias to increase the safe operating area of the amp.  In short, Aragon didn't want to have to see those amplifiers again.  On the other hand, they want the amps at the local audio salon to blow away everything else with superior high bias sound quality.

What I'm seeing could also be a result of bias drift or failure of some kind.  Drift seems more likely than failure.  Looking at the bias circuit in the 8008 schematic, there do not appear to be any electrolytic capacitors which would otherwise be a potential source of partial failure.  The bias seems to be mainly controlled by semiconductors, which would either work or be broken and not work at all.




For Nelson's hypothetical amp rail to rail bias of 0.75a which is 100W dissipation across a rail to rail voltage of 130 (+/- 65V), I get the same 18W pp or 9Wrms he does.  He gets this exactly correct in the hypothetical example, though he doesn't mention that this hypothetical example must be a mono amplifier, or that his X250 is a stereo amplifier and therefore dissipates only a bit more per channel.

Now lets think about the X250 amplifier which idles at 270W, which means 135 per channel, assuming 65V rails (which is possibly too low).  That means 1.04 amp from rail to rail.  Peak to peak power is therefore 2.08 * 2.08 * 8 or 35 watts, and RMS power is 17.5 watts.  Not far from the 40/20 he claims.
But the rail voltage is probably higher and the rest of the circuitry dissipates enough to make it more inaccurate.

Perhaps he meant the X250.5 amplifier (but forgot to say so).  It idles at 350W, which means 175 per channel, which means 1.35 amps from rail to rail, which means 58W peak to peak and 29W RMS, assuming the rails weren't also bumped up a bit from +/-65V.  Accounting for higher rails and the rest of the circuitry would bring this right in line with 40/20.  But this amplifier wasn't sold until several years after the post I linked above.

One other thing to notice is that because a square law applies, Class A power goes up as the square of the bias current.  A 1 amp bias current would produce 4 times as much class A power as a 0.5 amp bias current.

To be scientific, I should re-test the amplifiers

Now I realize that most likely I had the Parasound attenuated by 6dB by its volume controls.  Since at the time, the Behringer digital gain was set to +0.4dB, and since the Aragon has 1.5dB less gain, the new exactly equivalent digital gain setting would be -4.1dB.

While I was listening to We Want To Be Loved and Imaginary Day, I actually had the gain set to -6.9dB.  In other words, I had dialed in a relative 2.8dB of subwoofer boost.  No wonder the lows sounded so spectacular.  Later, while listening to Hotel California, I changed the setting to -6.5, which would correspond to 2.4dB of relative subwoofer boost.

I do not want to give this boost up, I think it needs at least that much.  I hadn't adjusted the sub for a long time, and with changes in EQ and listening position, clearly the new bass level is better.

So to be scientific and fair to the Parasound, I should hook it up again, adjusted with the same relative bass levels I am using now.  I'm not sure I'll bother with that.  To be really scientific, I'd use my ABX comparator.


Re-setting the panel level

I've been agonizing over finding the correct level setting for the Aragon which drives my acoustats.  I could have just used the level I had been using for the Parasound (+0.4 dB) adjusted upwards for reduced amp gain of the Aragon (+1.5dB) except I had been attenuating the Parasound by some unrecorded level, and I made the big mistake of twiddling the Parasound gain adjust knobs to maximum for frequency response testing before testing their previously set level.

Yesterday I had figured I set the Parasound gain to somewhere between -6 and -12dB.  I figured I wouldn't have done 6dB, because I know that is a maximum series resistance condition.  So 12dB?  That sounded too high.  I was beginning to think I had used 10dB.  But that's an odd one, the infinite repeating decimal of 3.33.  I wouldn't have done that, would I?

Meanwhile, I was listening to various music, and readjusting the level to suit each one.  Last night I decided Hotel California didn't sound clear enough in the mids, so I increased the level from 6.9 to 6.5 (neither of which made much sense thinking about how I might have attenuated the Parasound, so I worried about that.)

For 6dB previous attenuation level on the Parasound, the new level would be 4.1dB.  (I tried that for awhile but thought it too thin.)

For 9dB attenuation, the new level would be 7.1dB (close to the 6.9dB level I had been using for Imaginary Day).

For 12dB attenuation, the new level would be 10.1dB.  Thinking I might have chosen 10dB attenuation (despite the numerical difficulty), I listened to Fleetwood Mac Rumours DVD-Audio (which sounded better than I'd ever heard it) at 8.1dB.

Mind you in making these adjustments what I'm really doing is setting the relative bass level, because that is saying constant.  At present, the supertweeter is not connected (and its level hardly matters anyway).  The subs cross over at 85 Hz.  There is no simple way to set sub level, the response below 300 is highly muddled due to room modes and there are peaks and dips as large as 20dB, so you can't just set a matching level at some particular frequency or pair of frequencies.

Of course, there's no guarantee that I set the level of the Parasound correctly, it's just that over time you readjust until it's about right and sooner or later forget to make any further adjustments until something like this happens.

The last thing I listened to last night was the Rebecca Pidgin Spanish Harlem track with acoustic bass.  A famous mastering engineer said he always used that to set bass levels; you want the acoustic bass notes equal in level.  At the 6.5dB level I had gravitated toward, the third (highest) bass note sounded too loud, way too loud.  So then I dialed in 8.1, which sounded considerably more natural.  Of course I may also be fighting room nodes at the high bass note, I have often noticed it sounds loudest in the living room, so this is hardly a perfect test.  Also, the third note sounds like an open string, which inherently sounds louder and different.  But I didn't think it should sound like what I heard at 6.5.

Now this morning I thought I'd go back through this website and find out if I had ever recorded the Parasound attenuation level.  I had set it when experimenting with attenuating all amplifiers to reduce noise from the Behringer, which was most noticeable on the supertweeter but measureable elsewhere.

Indeed, after experimenting with 3dB Harrison Labs attenuator, which I thought made the midrange sound funny due to excess loading on the Behringer, I ultimately set the level via the Parasound level controls to 6dB, and that now seems to be the last and only documented case of setting the Behringer level control.  At the time, I opined that 9dB would be the max level for attenuation, to keep the Behringer from getting into its more distorted upper output level range.

So now it appears that if I wanted to duplicate the previous situation exactly, I'd now set the level to -4.1.  But that sounds thin, and I may like 8.1 better.  Effectively, I'm adding 4dB boost to the subs compared to previously.



Quiescent Power: 158W Max Heatsink Temp: 133 degrees F

Those are the measurements this morning.  Last night I hooked up Kill A Watt meter to Aragon.  When turned on without playing, the wattage started around 90, quickly rose above 100, and then slowly up to 170 or so.  Finally, as the amp warmed up, the wattage fell to just above 150.

The heatsinks seem a bit warmer than yesterday morning, with a maximum around 133, the average is around 132, dropping to 128 at the sides.


Tuesday, November 1, 2011

Aragon 8008 BB...A Groovy Class A Amplifier



On Halloween 2011, after all the kids had come and gone, I finally finished measuring and then hooking up my newly acquired Aragon 8008 BB amp.  At first, it seemed a trifle less detailed than the Parasound HCA-1500A I had been using.  And I had considerable difficulty setting the proper level, as during the set up process I turned the volume controls on the Parasound so had no proper measurement of the previous as-adjusted gain level.  I guessed I had the Parasound attenuated by 6 or 12dB, or somewhere in between.

It didn't take long, however, to realize how wonderful this amp sounded.  Like the Krell FPB 300 (which is sitting in the corner waiting to be repaired) it has a wonderful 3-dimensional deeply layered soundstage.  The soundstage is also wider to the left and right than the Parasound, and phase tricks in the recording (as done frequently on the first album I listened to, We Want To Be Loved by Grouse) became mind-blowing.  The mids and lows are palpably real, percussion impact is incredible.  I can feel whacked back into my chair.  Deep bass was surreal.  And this despite the fact I cross over the Acoustat 1+1's at 85 Hz to self-amplifying SVS PB13 subs, so you wouldn't think the amplifier for the panels would make that much difference on deep bass.  But the improved bass seemed to be there at any levels I set the Behringer digital gain adjustment to.  Finally, while listening to Hotel California on DVD-Audio I made the last gain adjustment, to get the highs in proper balance to the subwoofer bass, but I only raised (?) the mid level by 1dB.  In between Grouse and Eagles I listened to Imaginary Day by Pat Metheny on DVD-Audio.  This amp sounded so good I just couldn't quit listening until 4am.



I left the amp turned on overnight, and found the heatsinks to be 130 degrees F in the morning, measured with my IR probe set to "max".  That surprised me at first, but would be about right for an amp biased up to 26 watts class A, as Klipsch technical support said.  Nelson Pass designs his amplifiers to have 55 C temperature at the heatsink fins.  He says that is 60 C at the transistor itself, and you can run hotter, but he prefers not to.  55 C is 131 degrees F.  It looks like whoever last set the bias on this amp, either at the factory or elsewhere, knew what they were doing.

I didn't mean to suggest that this is an engineer's idea of a true Class A amplifier, but 26 watts of Class A power is a lot compared with most Class AB amplifiers which have just a few watts of Class A power.  Even Nelson's Class A amplifiers don't stay in Class A up to maximum output.  Only my Krell comes anywhere near this.   The Krell plateau biasing maintains class A operation up to full rated output, 600W per channel, into 4 ohm loads.

Stereophile also uses the Class A designation to describe the best audio products.  Actually, I think they only rated the 8008 ST as Class B, but IMO the 8008 BB deserves a Class A.

*****

Before the amp was delivered last week, I had reason to worry I wasn't actually being sent an 8008 BB.  UPS indicated the shipping weight was only 68 pounds.  The 8008 ST is said to weigh 67 pounds and the 8008 BB is said to weigh 76 pounds.  The ebay seller told me he would take the amplifier back if it proved to be the wrong model.  The first thing I did when the amp arrived was try to weigh it by the "net" method, standing on scale either holding the packaged amplfier or not.  This was not easy, as you might imagine.  But I tried this in both front entry hall and the kitchen and both times I came to a net packaged weight of 81 pounds.  That would be perfectly consistent with a 77 pound amplifier, in double (but light) boxes with bubble wrap and styrofoam pellet cushioning.  (Those pellets are a pain to deal with, and I don't blame Krell for charging an "environmental disposal fee" if people incorrectly ship an amp to them that way.)  Despite somewhat flimsy boxing, neither the boxes nor the amp was damaged during shipping.  UPS must be getting better about that.  And don't tell them about the scale error they apparently made.  I think the box must have been resting slightly on the sides of the scale.




Then after unboxing I counted the transistors while observing through ventilation holes in the bottom.  I counted 12 large (very chunky looking) Toshiba transistors per channel, just as the BB version is supposed to have.  Then I took the cover off, and verified that there are two separate power transformers, and 4 x 35,000 microfarad capacitors.  Very nice big Cornell Dublier capacitors, mounted to PCB with 4 diode bridges.  I had already seen from the eBay photos that the amp has XLR and RCA inputs.  So there is no doubt it is either the BB version or equivalent in every way.  The circuit boards look to be a nicer material than typically seen in electronic equipment.  All in all, the amplifier looks first class on the inside.  It looks fine on the outside too, though fairly basic except for nice 1/3" thick faceplate.




The top cover (which covers the transformer and capacitors) has some damping material applied.  Fortunately that part doesn't get very hot, but the damping material should be examined once and awhile; it was probably added by previous owner.  Also, the factory feet had been replaced with single felt pads.  I felt that didn't allow enough ventilation underneath, so I added 3 more felt pads to each foot.



Before moving the amp into place, I measured power output into an 8 ohm load using Tektronix scope and B&K sine generator.  I connected scope probe to hot side but didn't connect ground, expecting amp to be grounded through common grounds.  However I was wrong about that, though I was able to do clipping measurements as intended the lack of ground connection meant that high frequencies were very rolled off and therefore at lower levels in the scope display.  I found the amplifier put out 45 volts from 20 - 20khz.  But I was still concerned about high frequency roll off in the amp itself.

A couple days later when I set the amp into place, it's only a little wider than the Parasound, I did a dedicated frequency response measurement measuring both the input and output of the amplifier at 20, 200, 2k, and 20khz.  I also did the same tests on the Parasound.  I still detected more HF loss than expected, at -0.13dB.  The curve posted at Stereophile shows only about that much loss at 50kHz.  However, the Parasound measured even more loss, at -0.15dB.  Then I realized that my B&K oscillator has about 3% distortion, probably mostly third harmonic, and what is happening is that it is the harmonics that are getting rolled off more than the fundamental.  To do this measurement properly, one needs to use a very low distortion oscillator or a good filter to prevent the harmonics from contributing differentially to the response measurements.  I do have such an oscillator, my ST1410A, but it's hard to move because of all the junk in my computer room at the moment.  I suspect the rolloff at 20kHz is far less than 0.13dB, and even if it were 0.13dB, that would be less than any 44.1kHz sampled digital sources.

At 2kHz, the Parasound with volume controls turned fully up had 1.5dB more gain (8 ohms,  about 5v output).  Usefully, the Aragon takes larger input voltages to achieve the same output level, though not by much.  Unfortunately I didn't measure the Parasound before turning the volume controls up, I could only guess they had been turned down 6-12dB.  So I had to set the crossover level controls by guess and ear.  I also played pink noise and did a 1/3 octave measurement, which was looking flatter than I remembered.



During testing, I made the amp mute relay shut off output when I inadvertently inserted DC levels of about 2V.  The B&K generator has a DC offset adjustment, and when the upper output level is chosen, the offset increases by 10x.  I previously had misadjusted the DC level to 200mV in the lower level.  With no input, the Aragon servo loop maintains very low DC offset, about 1mV.  But if significant DC is applied to the input, the amp quickly mutes.  When the DC is removed, the amp takes a few seconds to unmute.  This is actually a very useful protection feature.