Friday, May 29, 2015

KSA-150 and KSA-250

It is unclear whether the KSA-150 and KSA-250 used a managed variable bias system.  Reading the manuals carefully, it sounds as if there may be some kind of bias management, but not as sophisticated as Sustained Plateau Bias which officially appeared with the KSA "S" models.

If KSA-250 has multiple bias levels, John Atkinson's famous calculation of the Class A power of a KSA-250 is only true for the lowest bias level, not the higher ones.   (In the first version of this post, I was sure KSA-250 had multiple bias levels.  Now not at all sure.)  I'm guessing the relatively cool running 250 had variable bias whereas the much hotter idling 150 might not have.

The Mark Levinson amplifiers like 331, 332, and 333 definitely use some kind of managed bias system to provide more Class A power on demand.  It says clearly says so in their manuals but only calls it "proprietary" and "developed by Madrigal Labs" and doesn't give it a fancy marketing name.

The KSA-250 and KSA-300S were much larger than the FPB 300 and approaching the FPB 600 in transformer capacity and weight.  The FBP 300 chassis actually seems like the successor to the KSA-200S chassis.  So the successive models appear to be in two groups (though within each group, models do get slightly heavier and certainly more sophisticated over time):

KSA-150
KSA-200S
FPB 300
FPB 400cx
(this group always had something like 3kW transformer)

and

KSA-250
KSA-300S
FPB 600
FPB 700cx
(this group always had something like 6kW transformer)

As time went on, Krell was either getting or at least advertising more power from almost the same amount of iron and aluminum.  The old 150 could double down all the way to 1 ohm and get 1200W.  The FPB 300 doubles down to 2 ohms…where it gets 1200W.  Actually the FPB is said to get more power into 1 ohm, but the 1 ohm power is not rated and it is certainly not doubling down to 2400W into 1 ohm.  I think I've heard that something like 1600W may be available into 1 ohm.  Ultimately, the FBP 300 and FBP 400cx have the same transformer, output transistor assembly, and chassis and the 400cx is rated at 1600W into 2 ohms.

If Krell ever advertised Sustained Plateau Bias for the Evolution models..they don't seem to do so any more.  I thought they did at first, perhaps when Dan was still with the company.  It doesn't seem like they were doing full rail regulation anymore, just a fancy kind of filtering.

I think the sustained plateau bias on my FPB 300 is great, though it could be smarter still and I'd still like a manual indication and control as with the "S" models.  The S models lacked the sophisticated rail voltage regulation, and I think they had slightly higher levels of distortion than FPB, but I like the ability to control bias levels.  If I could preset/hold the lowest bias level, I wouldn't need a second "summer or background music" amplifier.




200 degrees C

The schematic for the Krell 200S indicates MJ15024 and MJ15025 power transistors, although I have read that for best results you need the custom versions Krell actually ordered from Motorola which are only similar to MJ15024/25 but better.

The specs say the 15024 has a maximum Normal Operating Temperature of 200 degrees C.  (That is like 2.4 times higher than any temperature I've actually measured on the heatsinks.)

Device dissipation is 250W per device, and 16 amps.  The derating for power is 1.43 watts per degrees C, so at 80 degrees C the max dissipation would be 171 watts.

I suspect the transistors used in my FPB 300 are at least this good, and I believe there are at least 10 transistors per channel (and maybe 20 or more).  Therefore, even at 80 degrees C, one channel could be dissipating at least 1700W (and that's not counting the power consumed in regulated power supplies, drivers, etc).  and there are 20 outputs devices in each channel.  Therefore, even at 80 degrees C, each channel is capable of dissipating more power than the power supply could possibly deliver, 3400 watts.  And that's not counting the power supply and driver transistors, etc.

Bottom line is that this amplifier is safe to operate at the full maximum temperature of 80 degrees C, which is about 180 degrees F, and still deliver full power.

In my most recent testing, it does not seem like the left channel is rising to the next plateau.  Instead, it looks like it is simply drifting high.  The plateau bias starts it at the right level, but then it slowly drifts up, more like 50-100W than 150W.  Of course if it ultimately drifts up to 80 degrees C, plateau bias computer puts it back down again.  After an hour of idling with inputs connected to the Audio GD Dac, I was seeing about 500W consumption, with one channel being about 145F and the cool one being 115F.  Actually, the hotter channel is probably in a better temperature range for good sound.  After a few hours of playing the amp was happily consuming about 600W, which is perfectly fine, with  155F/135F temperatures, also fine, once again, the drifty hot channel actually being more linear.  Transistors tend to get more linear when they are hotter and/or run with greater current.

If the amp is kept playing music, it might cycle through the 180F max but then settle down to 155/135F with about 600-700W continuous consumption, which is about optimal.

If I could set the bias level to level 2 (600W) that would be nice, but I'm effectively getting about the same thing, just with an occasional higher reach that warms the amp up quicker.




Thursday, May 28, 2015

That Class A Feeling

I've been getting that feeling.  That same feeling I got when, as a kid, I wandered into Mel Shillings' fabled Music and Sound, which had relocated…into my neighborhood in Southern California!  They had the huge amps, the planar speakers that created extraordinary stereo images (about the first decent stereo I had ever heard), and something else I forgot about until just now…

Air Conditioning!  Running my Krell with typical power consumption in the 600-900W range is generating a lot of heat.  And, since my listening room is the living room, which happens to have the thermostat, almost as soon as I turn the amp on the Air Conditioning comes and and pretty much stays on as long as the Krell is running.

Well I'm sure the Krell loves being the center of attention again, right in the center of the room, getting the main blast of cooled air from the ceiling vent on the other side of the room.  But while it's bracing to sit down into the stream of cold air, and brings back memories, it's also expensive and it even seems to make me a little sick.  And when I'm done listening the rest of the house has been chilled about 3 degrees below normal.

The problem here that I hadn't quite solved when I tried moving the Krell into the corner--shielded from cold air by the couch and then thought it was overheating--is that the thermostat is right on the opposite side of the same room, and the fully air conditioned air hits the Krell and practically bounces right back to the thermostat.

Back then I did get a new thermostat installed…but it never quite satisfied me wrt programming (it was basically impossible to program on the wall, that's another story for my Computer Critical blog).  What I really wanted then, and now, was a portable "personal" thermostat I could locate to another room.  The perfect other room would be my bedroom, which often doesn't get warm enough in winter, but isn't much bothered by heat from the Krell.

Well they do make such a thermostat system now, the Prestige IAQ 2.0 System, which has a portable thermostat called the Portable Comfort Control.

OK, I could just turn the thermostat up, but I hate it when I forget to do that.  And what if I'm running the Krell all day???  I think thermostat in the master bedroom is the perfect place…I could just leave it there always except during parties I'll put in back in the living room.  Or if a friend is doing lots of baking in the kitchen.

When the AC isn't running, the Krell could still use some air movement, so I just bought the Econo-Cooler from Cool Components (these aren't sold by many online stores btw).  I've generally hate fans in equipment.  But I'm OK with fans I can dial down to the lowest speed myself…and if it's noisy I'll try something else.  I only wanted to start with one Econo-Cooler (CP-EC) but it didn't seem like I could order just one and get the full ps-300 power supply which has many possible voltage levels.  They also have control modules with digital temp readout, thermostatic control, and triggers, but I'm worried about the difficulty of getting the thermostatic control to work properly.  I don't want to put it directly on the Krell--that might fry it (the thermostat).

Another thing is to have connections for my "backup" amplifier, the Aragon 8008 BB.  It doesn't generate quite as much heat in operation (about 1/2 the amount of idle heat) and it has now been moved into the corner where it probably won't affect the thermostat as much.  I'm thinking that in the long run I want to have it hooked up through my QSC ABX box (but not directly) so I can actually do ABX tests.  But I don't trust the speaker relays in the ABX box (nor the connectors, nor the box itself) so what I'd do is use the box to switch a DC current which would then control a pair of 300V 40A DBDT relays right behind each speaker.  For decent ABX tests, I might eventually have to have my own computer control that "works" the relays a bunch of times so you can't figure out A/B just on the relay sound (even the QSC ABX box itself has this problem a bit…with some practice you can hear the difference in the relay sound).

Well I looked at lots of things, starting with pins that could be directly inserted into the cheap 5-way binding posts at the back of the Acoustats (still one of the best options).  Finally I decided to use a familiar old solution--banana plugs.  I'll "stack" the plugs (plug one plug into the holes on the other) to connect the speaker to the A amplifier or the B amplifier.  The Acoustats will remain connected with bare wire that goes to one plug, and so will the Krell.

(BTW, no use in plugging bananas directly into the 5 way posts on the Acoustats.  Heavy banana plugs don't take long to fall out of those cheap posts, and are often hanging part way out.)

The only local Radio Shack had hardly anything anymore (sad!!!) so I ordered these from Parts Express.

Monday, May 25, 2015

OK Class, how much Class A Power ?

I've mentioned before in this blog how manufacturers routinely inflate Class A power claims by various technically correct but misleading means.  I've also discussed the correct calculation, which is 2RII where I is actual idle bias and R is the load.

The Krell FPB 300 has different idle bias depending on situation.  Temporarily I have seen it consume about 1200W continuously for 30 minutes or so after turn on.  But over a whole day, it can't sustain much more than 700W, which seems to rest on an second bias plateau around 600W.  The bias circuit kicks everything down when the heatsinks start getting above 180F.

For 600W idle, that's 300W per channel, and about 2 amps across the 170V maximum peak-to-peak voltage.  So 2RII gives us 32W into 8 ohms and 16W into 4 ohms.

An amplifier with 1/2 the voltage swing but dissipating the same power would be running 4 amps in consuming that 300W, and therefore have 4 times as much Class A power.  The price for having more maximum power on tap given the same dissipating capacity is that you cannot have as much Class A power.  People would like to ignore this but it is basic math.  If you want more peak watts from the same quiescent consumption, you have to give up the Class A Watts.  Also, Class A Watts do not easily double down as they are limited by current in most amplifiers.  So Class A Watts will halve into each halving of impedance.  The famous Mark Levinson ML2 did not do this because the amplifier was voltage limited at each lower impedance down to 2 ohms--so it did indeed "double down."  But it was not practical for many people, and especially me, because the maximum power into 4 ohms was 50 watts (25 watts at 8 ohms).  And you get that 50W from a single channel mono block about as big and heavy as my Krell.

Here are the Pass Labs .8 specifications.  My Krell can continuously dissipate about the same as Pair of Pass Labs XA60.8's, which have a combined ship weight of 214 pounds.

Sunday, May 24, 2015

Cook that Krell

I was all worried that one channel of my FPB 300 was running hotter than the other.  I shouldn't have been, my Krell, which was sitting in the corner of the living room for 4 years (during my recent building boom) waiting for me to get around to prepare for getting fixed, was operating normally.

The FPB *has* to heat up to the normal max temperature to trigger something like recalibration.  It then sets itself back down to lower, usually in the 600W bias plateau, but if the amp has been driven hard enough it will get set back to the 300W minimum bias plateau.  (My wattages are the actual amplifier power consumption…what is available as Class A power is different and will require a long explanation later.  What has revolutionized my understanding of the FPB amplifier is watching it's power consumption from moment to moment over hours of listening.  Now I think I understand it.  It makes very good use of the ultimate limited resource--the heatsink area of the amplifier.  You could say it "optimizes" the resource for the requirements of the situation.  I am happy to be even more a fan of Sustained Plateau Bias.  It's a way to approximate a much larger non-adjusting Class A amplifier, compare my FPB 300 with the metal of a pair of Pass Labs XS300's, which have similar power into 2 ohms, but use about 6 times as much metal.)

As you are driving the amp hard, it will hit the top normal temperature, which appears to be about 165 degrees F, then get set back, and this may happen over and over.  Ultimately, when driven hard enough, the amplifier becomes a high bias Class AB, with 300W minimum bias, and there is no more setback, consumption just falls immediately after every peak.  Many people may not drive the amp that hard--I have the least sensitive loudspeakers ever sold, and with the most difficult to drive load.

Once both channels have hit max temperature once or twice and been set back, they begin to have fairly identically, so I am wondering if hitting max temperature is a necessary thing to keep the amp working right.  Moving the amplifier to a different location is going to cause differential air flows…which has a profound effect on passively cooled heatsinks, and a new recalibration--hitting max temperature--will be necessary before things are balanced again.

As I was using my amplifier for awhile, the left heatsink had it's bias setback, and before long it was the cool heat sink compared to the right, which took it's time to get to 165F, but after some harder playing it did too, and then the right channel got the bias setback.  The power consumption fell to no less than 600W, but during ever more brief pauses in the music it would ramp down to 300W.

I am just guessing that a recalibration occurs when the bias is set back.  It would make sense for the amp to do its recalibration on thermal setback, as then it is changing the bias in a big jump anyway.

165F is a fairly high temperature for audio amplifiers, but it is nothing in the world of power inverters, for example, which require similar parts.  The Krell was specifically designed to run this hot as part of it's normal behavior, and as a way to get more class A power from a limited amount of metal, even if it's not usually considered a limited amount of metal.

Update: I'm seeing 175F after a day of hard playing.  I think the ultimate setback point is 180F as it was for the KSA-x00s amplifiers.  It the sensors see that, the amp kicks down the bias.  When the heatsinks have been cooler, they don't measure the temperature as quickly as the sensors do, so the rise in setback point actually demonstrates the sensors read quicker than my measurement of heatsink temps, as well as the actual temperature being higher than I thought.

It's only to be expected that if there is a setback point, eventually things will hover around it.  So 180F is a normal Krell temperature.  If the amp shuts down, or if I see 200F, I should call Krell.

Power is in the 700's with more than a second silence dropping to 600W.  Still takes about 20 seconds to get pushed down to 300W, so the nominal bias level is 600W consumption now.  So this is a long term sustainable bias level.  Actual wattmeter readings are typically in the 700's.

That bias level is comparable to A pair of Pass Labs mono XA60.8's, each of which weighs about the same as the Krell, and continuously dissipates 375W per mono block chassis.  So Krell is made to cook at max temperature, Nelson Pass designs his amps to have a more moderate temperature--at the cost of twice as much metal for similar performance.  And of course the XA60.8 has no where near the voltage or current capability of the Krell either, even as a heavier pair of amps.

The first XA amp which beats the FPB voltage spec of 60V is the XA200.8, which has 62 volts.  Only the XA160.8 and XA200.8 (and XS300) have 50A current rating.  Krell doesn't give a current spec, but Martin Colloms measured the FPB 600 as having 117A and described it as arc welding.  The XA200.8 weighs 177 pounds (per mono block) and dissipates 750 watts per channel.  I pushed my FPB to 1400+ watts draw, but only for a dozen seconds as it was already warm.

Krell FPB amps are the poor man's Pass Labs…   The Eco-Freak Pass Labs…

People will say Pass Labs is fundamentally different, all about simplicity, etc.  The FPB amplifiers have a no-feedback output which is simply an array of emitter followers in parallel and differential push-pull.  That's simple and elegant. Stuff ahead of that is a bit complicated, of course, including but not limited to the bias system.  But nevertheless the FPB specs bandwidth at 240kHz and 0.1Hz.  The distortion is spec'd at 0.02% at 1kHz and 0.15% at 20kHz and that's for full power.  Pass typically specifies 100kHz and 1% distortion.  (Of course that means he's too indifferent to specs to bother to measure distortion just before it begins to rise near clipping.  But it won't out-do the Krell either.)

I keep forgetting this, but Krell specs the full output (300W) input level as 2.35V RMS, but I continue to believe that more input is possible to reach the full peak output implied by 60V, 450 watts into 8 ohms.

















Saturday, May 23, 2015

Thinking about Sustained Plateau Bias

I am a big fan of the Krell Amplifiers with Sustained Plateau Bias, especially the later models which implemented fully regulated power, such as my FPB 300 and on up.

But how useful is this SPB, really?  It's not clear how much this has been actually copied (of course, SPB and other acronyms are Krell trademarks, and different from the underlying patent, which might be licensed so long as it is not named the same…and could be in widespread use as far as I know).  It does seem possible that many big audiophile transistor amps use a managed bias scheme of some sort, not unlike how the FPB does it with a microprocessor, whether they fall within the claims of the patent or not.

It's incredible in my FPB 300!  Reasonably intelligent.  It gets standby and idle bias perfect from the get go.  It holds on to the 300W consumption idle for low background music.  Then the next bump up is at least 450…if both channels 600W consumption.  Then consumption seems to go up in about 100W increments as needed up to 1400.  I can't test any higher than 1400.  It jumps up quickly, takes longer to go back down.

If the amp is cold, it may hang on to 600W.  If amp is warm, it gets assertive about pushing consumption back down.  It amp gets too hot--above 165C--it pushes down consumption fast even if the loudness hasn't changed.  But in my testing, it has never pushed consumption down below 600 during loud passages for this reason…only during low levels or silence.  During silence when it wasn't too hot, bias lowers back to idle bias in less than a minute, how fast depending on how hot it was.

It is precisely during episodes of the amp pushing down bias due to high temp that it tends to make the chassis ping noise.  Or sometimes if amp is just left to cool off after hard playing.  But it has been quite quiet playing tonight.

So while it's not "adaptive" (so says Krell in owners manual) it is actually somewhat adaptive.  There are limits to what you get…and they are not necessarily preset limits such as buying a 30W Class A amplifier and having 30W into 8 ohms, 15W into 4 ohms, etc., of Class A power.  No with the KPB 300 you can get, momentarily, tons of Class A power.  But if it heats up too much, you get less and less Class A margin, and ultimately you may be forced to endure Class AB.

This is a pretty good deal, actually.  In fact it makes a lot of sense for the amp to work this way, it gives you all the Class A power the heat sinks can support, and all the Class AB power the transformer can support.

By letting the bias go lower during less demand, and at idle, heat sink margin is saved for the louder passages for the amplifier to remain in Class A.

It's a great idea I think.  It's only a disappointment if you believed every word of the hype, that you were getting 300W of Class A power into 8 ohms (and 1200W of Class A power into 2 ohms), and as much as you want at any time, always Class A power.

That would be impossible, without the actual old fashioned Class A amplifier that dissipates 3-4 times the Class A power and has no more power at all than that (because if it has more Class AB power above that, the 3-4 multiplier becomes even larger).

So 1200W in two channels is 2400W means the amplifier would have to dissipate at least 7200W to be this hype dream amplifier.

Actually the FPB 300 heatsinks seem pretty comfortable in my air conditioned room dissipating about 1000W continuously (with normal breaks).  Above that too much, and I get the thermal system cutting back the dissipation to 600W or so.  Then it would gradually climb back up to 1000 again.

So with the thermal setback…it actually is adaptive, and with many levels on tap, it adapts to any room conditions, giving you the maximum Class A power within the limits of the situation.  It doesn't happen to be close to 1200W per channel for sure…but it's not chopped liver either.

It will be interesting to do that calculation…what actual Class A power into 8 ohms (and half as much into 4 ohms) from the apparent comfortable maximum of 1000W continuous dissipation.

Earlier today, I was enjoying mine right now at about 305W AC consumption, FM radio station KPAC playing local artists, level set to 70 (-33.8dB but other reductions apply in home distribution), heat sinks r/l 113/116F.  At idle power consumption was 75W, heat sinks r/l 87/83, ambient 76 with AC running (blowing right over amp).  Basically now it's a high bias AB amp with likely less than 10W Class A power into 4 ohms, but if power exceeds something it rises to higher levels of class A power as much as it needs to and can sustain.  I'd be consuming more power with a pair of XA30's I believe, and though they have more Class A power than I do now continuously, I can have way more on demand, and way more power overall.  With a low level playing it can be very stable at 300W consumption.





Krell and it's bias

My Krell FBP 300 seemed to be approaching a stable 114 degrees F or so at idle in both channels over a couple hours.  That didn't seem to change playing KPAC at Tact level 60 (about -44dB).  When I cranked the level up to 80, one channel rose to about 122 but the left channel shot up above 150 degrees F.

I rolled the volume back but the hot channel didn't seem to cool down much.

I reversed both input connections and speaker connections.  The problem was same as before and in the same channel of the amplifier (left).  This time, when I turned the level down, at first the left seemed to get lower, down to about 140.  But then later it shot up to 155 at the hottest point.

This is probably wrong, there shouldn't be that imbalance.  But what is the correct temperature?   Apparently many Class A amps run their heatsinks around 120-130F.  IIRC Nelson Pass advises the low end of that for the homebuilder (45-50C…the F5 is designed to run 25 above ambient or typically 50C, while Pass Labs amps are spec'd to run at 53C, where obviously everything has been carefully engineered for that and higher).  My Aragon 8008 BB used to idle in around 132 until I put the Super feet on it, now it idles about 115F, and it's not even considered a Class A amplifier.

But lookee here!  The Krell KSA-100S manual describes Sustained Plateau Bias and says that if the heatsinks go above 80C (!) the amplifier cuts out the two highest bias levels until it falls back to "normal" temperature (not defined).

So that's saying in a way that 80C is a kind of "normal" condition that the amplifier adapts to (I believe many other amplifier would shut down at 80C or even lower).  Well we see at least one way Dan the Man demanded special versions of his power transistors from Motorola.

If a 100S can rock with 80C so can my 300 I believe.  So this isn't any reason to panic, but nor is it reason not to get the amp fixed asap.  The temperature difference shouldn't be there.  Actually the cold channel might even be better a bit hotter…but that was specifically the channel repaired last time (IIRC) for distortion.  It's probably optimized and so should the other channel be.  When optimal the FPB amplifiers have amazing low distortion at all levels and all audible frequencies.  The FPB 300 was measured by Martin Colloms as having a 300kHz power bandwidth.

On this blog here I was posting about the temperature imbalance in September 2010, after having had it repaired in 2009.   The same blog mentions microprocessors on each channel's main board, and how they need to be reset, and how the procedure is simple if only someone would reveal it.   The consensus seems to be Get the Amp Fixed!  I wasn't actually the original poster, but chimed in with my own similar problems.

On this blog here a person reports 79.6F in standby mode, idling/background music at 97F, 30 minutes serious listening as 132F for the FPB 300.  Lots of other interesting comments, including the guy who says the normal range for inverters is up to 80C, and the unit shuts down at 90C.