Monday, August 3, 2015

Fixing the SCD-1, SCD-777ES, or other transports

Advice on fixing SCD-1 or similar transport

General advice on fixing CD players from Lampizator, a celebrated audio modder.  Lampizator has spent more time noodling around with old CD players than anyone, and he says he has only once ever seen a bad laser, and that was caused by his boosting the laser drive signal.  Most of the time, CD problems are caused mechanical failures of various kinds, many due to accumulating grunge or hardening lubricants.   Lamizator curses the professional techs who make bucks by unnecessarily replacing lasers, therefore depleting the precious stock of factory parts.  He says that if you can hear the disc spinning at a controlled speed for 2-3 seconds when the disc is loaded, the laser is fine because in most players the disc won't even start spinning unless the laser detects a reflective surface.

It does now seem that the "fixed laser" transport (FPM) was Sony's most intense, and probably best, effort to remove transport vibration and jitter.  Sony had been making these transports back to the beginning of the CD era with the professional CDA-5000 Compact Disc Analyzer, and a series of high end CD-only models in the 90's also used a fixed laser transport, such as the CDP-XA7ES.  The last go around was for the SCD-1 and SCD-777ES models.

The Vintage Knob says:

FPM was intended to suppress vibrations where there are more in the first place (the spinning CD) rather than try to minimize those which have a much lower magnitude - in the laser pickup itself.
So the disc's spinning motor and rotor become the moving parts (one big moving part), and the laser block remains... fixed on its base.
But TVN also says that FPM was less expensive than Sony's other premium mechanism, the all aluminum BU-1 with magnetic rails.  And lower cost was a key motivation to bring it back in the mid 1990's.

The SCD-1 did achieve a lower jitter measurement in Stereophile than I remember for any other player, FWIW, playing CD's.  However I have not tried doing a systematic comparison and the jitter measurement techniques may have changed over the years.

While the original high end SCD players have many SACD loving fans (the consensus emerged almost right away that there were better Redbook players from Esoteric, Krell, Marantz, and others) many have had a love/hate relationship with the transport.  It is apparently somewhat unreliable, and by 2006 or so many owners were stocking up on lasers, sled motors, and spindle motors.  Sony tends not to offer service or even parts after 10 years or less, and they may have already used up all the spare parts before them in earlier repairs (sometimes unnecessary part replacements, according to Lampizator).

The general consensus now is that Esoteric makes the best mechanisms such as the VRDS which itself comes in several versions.  But if I want a "reference" player specifically for SACD, the SCD-1/SCD-777ES still represent a kind of reference benchmark.

Here are the 3 parts that some people were stocking up on:

1. Spindle motor: P# 1-763-254-11
2. Sled motor: P# X-4952-147-1 
3. Laser Pick up: P# A6062396A

Here's a thread with a guy fixing an SCD-1 which originally had pictures.

A friend has a boom box with cassette and CD player.  The CD player is often not working, though I got it to work a few days ago up to track 7 out of 10.  I think there is possibly something making laser movement difficult.  We agree it is worth fixing this because CD/Cassette boom boxes are basically not being made anymore, thanks to the kind of planned "markets" we have (planned by corporations to extract the maximum from us).

It's a CFD-S26.  Here is a similar model being repaired:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iEG_u0ogjZI

And here's a DIYAudio thread about fixing CD transports that starts (near the end) to discuss the adjustment of the sacred pots "track and gain" and "focus gain" that the service manual advises you not to adjust.  Well apparently lots of people with nothing to loose often try and win, for a few months anyway.  I once saw a friend adjusting those pots…and it looked just crazy.  After watching that you wonder how CD's mostly work at all, if just a hairs breadth of a turn of some pot inside is the difference between Perfect Sound Forever and junk.  But then again, I once calibrated a Sound Technology 1700 analyzer…and that's a similar experience.

And here's a more detained DIYAudio thread on CD player restoration and adjustment.




Sunday, August 2, 2015

Fixing the symptoms first

I heard Jesse J from Oregon in a live concert Saturday, bought the CD, got it signed by Jesse, played it at home, was wonderful.  Though I though a bit more wonderful when I lowered the TacT level (92.9=0dB) to 79.1 on cut three, that may have reduced some critical rattling in my living room.  This CD is no wimp when it comes to deep bass!   The next day, my friend thought it sounded a bit mechanical.  Right at that time, there were several rattles obvious to me, I've set about fixing them, which brings me to the title point.

As a general rule in such situations, it's better to fix the symptoms first.  By symptoms I mean the effects farthest from the original causation.  Why?  Because if you wait until after fixing the primary cause, you might not be able to find the symptoms again.  So I will fix the rattling before fixing the frequency response.  The frequency response doesn't require a non-linear failure like rattling to measure and can be fixed after the rattling is fixed.

But actually the frequency response is not bad.   I went through the test frequencies I have used to make adjustments before.  I have a series of tones recorded at something like -20dB, in Hz:  16,18,20,22,25,28,31.5,36,40,45,50 and up to 160.

Sitting at the Kitchen table listening casually, it seemed like 36Hz and 40Hz seemed a bit low.  But measured at the listing position, 22Hz-45Hz are within 1dB, which is pretty incredible and testimony to my hand-tuning of the EQ's, especially to fight the 10dB room mode at 45 Hz.

Playing the subwoofers alone makes it easy to find the rattles.  The bass is amazing tuneful considering the 80 Hz lowpass and everything.  I did think there was a kind of excessive bounce, excessively electronic sound in the bass, which I think is an unfortunate attribute of my system (I am not faulting the recording, which sounded just fine and natural on the bass on another audiophile's system which doesn't go quite as deep).  So, for that reason, and also because of booming and rattling all over, I dialed back a 20 Hz boost I had in one channel to zero.  Now there is no boosting below 31.5 Hz (at one time I had several boosts below 31.5Hz to enhance the lowest bass) and in fact there was a -3dB Q=1 cut at 20Hz, which I dialed back to -2dB after removing the 1dB Q=5 boost.  I can see the trick I was playing here (high Q boost combined with lower Q cut) but it's precisely that sort of tricky EQ that could add an artificial sound from extended reverberation.  Anyway, it's hardly any different from a 1dB change overall.

I only measured 20Hz after removing the 1dB boost, and it was actually 2-3dB below the 22-45Hz level.  But 20Hz is quite problematic, it causes a lot of wall flexing and rattles the kitchen range, among other things, which I can't fix.

The rattling wall clock was fixed by applying self-stick felt to the back, top and bottom.  Now this had an unintended effect of forcing the bottom of the clock away from the wall because of constraining the space for the wall hook on top.  At first it appeared as though the bottom was entirely away from the wall, but after some time, one side is almost touching the wall, the other side about 1/3 inch away.  I pound on the wall and it doesn't seem to rattle at all, so this is fixed for now, but may need to be monitored.

The rattling china cabinet was investigated, and finally the source of rattling was found: two vessels on the bottom shelf were touching.  That was it!  I was prepared to use felt, whatever, but that wasn't necessary.  Going one step further, I pounded on the shelves with my hand, and found one other potential rattle in the teapot and butter dish, with both have top and bottom parts.  I wedged pieces of paper in between top and bottom pieces and now they seem quiet.

The rattling in the range hood and back plate has eluded me for now.  Nothing I could hold with my hand changed it.  Anyway, this was not the rattle I heard on Jesse J's album, but something else that turned up playing spot frequencies up to 100 Hz.

The "cause" of lack of LF absorption will be a long time in fixing.




Friday, July 31, 2015

The Great Debate: Amir vs Arny

The Great Debate, Part 1110250, at AVSForum

The Great Debate, Part 1110251, at What is Best Forum (where Amir is a moderator).  Amir starts it by saying this thread was inspired by a thread at AVSForum, although he didn't link to it.*  The previous thread seemed to be the one…but I'm not sure because there were many others!  And, note that the threads I have linked are a hundred pages or more.  Are audiophiles obsessed with their arguments or what?  We are (yes me included) apparently argumentophiles also.

(*Sadly, typical of how Amir argues, without linking back to demonstrations of crucial points.  In contrast Arny's arguments are almost always backed up with a plethora of links, though not always of the highest quality and many are now dead, including his sadly long gone website pcabx.  For the service he has rendered to society, yes simply by being a gadfly and contrarian to the mainstream high end audio industry, I think Arny should have the resources of a titan of industry himself, but I fear it's not like that at all...)

Technically these debates are about whether the potential improvements from "high resolution digital audio" (meaning it has greater than 16 bit resolution and/or greater sampling rate than 44.1kHz).  But it's also a debate about methods, results, and personalities in all aspects of The Great Debate between White Hats and Black Hats (the terms coined by Peter Aczel, a self declared White Hat who believes that most decent amplifiers sound the same, the classic White Hat position going back to the 1970's).  We've apparently even superseded the always shaky term "Audio Objectivist" (having nothing to do with, say, Ayn Rand) and "Audio Subjectivist" with Amir calling himself the Objectivist--so where does that put Arny?  The object/subject difference hardly gets at it either, since Black Hats (and especially Grey Hats, like John Atkinson--I respect him and his self identification, and myself) may be quite into certain kinds of measurements, or at least technical phenomena, real things happening, that just don't happen to tickle the White Hat sense of importance.  And a hidden argument which is never even touched is absolutely fundamental--must everything pass DBT immediately, and what if not?  Should technical criteria (say, Jitter) be ignored simply because there is no current DBT proof of their importance?  I strongly think not, however any person not an Amir or higher titan of industry has to prioritize, and I've been shaming myself for spending several years now far more on digital issues even at the fringe of the Grey Hat regime, when I sort of intended to have been working on room acoustic issues instead.  So Jitter should not be ignored, and let's have John Atkinson's and even better jitter tests developed.  But generally, we should probably move on to more important things.  We should be skeptical of all existing Black Hat claims, but not necessarily at the existence of to-be-found issues discovered by Black Hats, even as White Hats do, though the White Hats always often end up with the more minimal explanation.  So the world needs everyone, even as it needs everyone's mind to evolve.

Amir Majidimehr (principal of Madrona, formerly VP of Windows Digital Media at Microsoft) and Arny Kruger have been frequently sparring about what equipment differences are actually audible.  And this goes way back.  Though I'm not sure how long Amir has been involved in these debates, Arny has been involved since at least 1976, and he has recounted a history of the development of the ABX test method around that time and the ABX comparator in 1982.  He was one of the principles of the ABX company.  The very creation of the ABX test method over 30 years ago was precisely to answer the question of what equipment differences are audible.  Way back in the mid 1970's as an audio society member Arny was involved in these debates, and he's still at it now on a multitude of websites.

Reading Arny (who I've never met in person) I am very impressed with his arguments and generally the ways he makes them.  I'm also very impressed with his patience and dedication.  I think I take his side, mostly.

Reading Amir, it is clear he is very smart and is a very technically qualified professional audio designer.  I believe he is honest and not a shill.  However I think he makes poor and sometimes ugly arguments (often to authority, and sometimes to his own authority, and often discrediting the authority of others) far more often than Arny does.  He also seems to me much more to be a tireless bully.  Nevertheless, Amir may be right about some things.

Sadly, in these arguments, there isn't really a suitable technical qualification.  Certainly being an electrical engineer, as such, doesn't necessarily make you an audio scientist, and The Great Debate is not engineering it is Science.  Within Science "Audio Science" is too small to be particularly tractable.

The Audio Engineering Society (AES) is really an engineering organization, not a scientific one, but it does strive mightily (and perhaps too mightily) to retain respectability.  Therefore it is not surprising it cleaves tightly to Double Blind Testing results in its papers which are often written by academic scientists and not engineers.  Meanwhile, many audio engineers don't bother with DBT's.  Many have never done DBT's and never will, but nevertheless often are believed to speak with authority about such matters.

The truth is, right now, there is no authority.  And it is difficult to establish one given all the possible economic conflicts of interest, not to mention egos, etc.

Amir starts the second thread with a post showing a DBT result which confirms his ability to hear the benefit of high resolution.  At the beginning, Arny was not posting (and in fact Amir said that Arny had permanently retired from posting after Amir had posted some brilliant refutation--another unfortunate Amirism).  I have been unable to confirm that Arny ever quit posting anywhere, and in fact Arny posted to this exact thread some time later, as well as continuing to post at AVSForum and HydrogenAudio).

It happens I have seen at least one of Arny's argument which has has often made with regards to some DBT results.  He has argued that high frequency nonlinearity in amplifiers, speakers, or headphones can produce differences at audible frequencies, and that is what people are hearing.

As it turns out, at least in the first page or so of the second thread, Amir did not reveal the particular equipment he had gotten his positive test results with.  I had read up to the first point and which that question was asked an an answer still was not provided.

Now quite often subjectivist reviewers are quite clear about what equipment they have used to perform some test, and when they do so they go into great detail about every last cable involved, because of course they believe it is all of importance.

So it is more than a bit suspicious actually that Amir left out this detail.

I have not read all of either thread, though it looks somewhat worthwhile for someone like me who remains very interested in The Debate, despite going on for hundreds of pages.

One of the high points of the second thread is where Amir presents a very respectable paper published by AES (Convention Paper 9174 presented at the 137th convention of AES in 2014, by Helen Jackson, Michael Capp, and J. Robert Stuart) recently proving the audible differences of different kinds of digital filters.  That result does cleave very much away from the "all digital sounds perfect" position of the White Hats, including Arny.

(Similar experiments in the past with positive results have been shot down on the basis of sampling artifacts caused by equipment configuration.  In a earlier blog discussing that, Arny nails the best way of preparing test material.  It should start from the High Res material then be down sampled to the lower rate.  THEN it should be up sampled to the high rate again so as to avoid playback differences caused by switching sampling rates.)

Now one wouldn't think J. Robert Stuart (a Fellow of the Audio Engineering Society) would make such mistakes.  But it seems he may have padded this test in various ways, according to Arny and others at Hyrdogen audio.  It's clear from information available that Stuart used defective Rectangular Dither in this test.  He tries to justify this on the basis that "it is often used."  He knows it is not the best because he makes products that use the better method (some kind of triangular).  The question being addressed is not Rectangular dither.  The correct approach is to use the best reasonably available technology except for the item being tested.  So, sadly, this positive looking result is not acceptable and the Convention Paper now looks more like slanted advertising for Meridian.  AJ at Hydrogen Audio writes:

The BS test is a complete farce and fabrication of results in a desperate attempt to justify $$$ales of "Hi Rez" which of course nosed dived once people realized the scam, confirmed by M&Ms AES peer reviewed tests of actual audiophools, their hardware and purported "Hi Rez" media, the EXACT conditions they and the scam industry claimed to be able to "hear" differences.
The scam industry does not require the audiophool be "trained", the "Hi Rez" equipment/system to be certified, the room to have a specific noise floor, or the music content be cherry picked and doctored as in the BS test.
And he goes on…  But I believe he meant to say "the music content must be NOT be cherry picked and doctored."  That may be required for some official standards.  But if we are talking about the limits of audibility, cherry picking sample music that best illustrates the differences between system is fine, and even doctoring that music is fine (so long as this is described).  To say that we must prove limits of audible differences only on average hifi systems with average music is ludicrous.  I am fine with parts of the Meridian test methodology.  But the whole experiment sucks because it seems the control condition uses outdated technology that was not supposed to be under test.  It is that particular part that blew it.

I will say emphatically that a person's achievements in audio engineering do not necessarily qualify that person or any person to make an authoritative statement about The Great Debate.  Even very qualified, experienced, and successful audio engineers are not necessarily up to speed on this.  It requires a skeptical stance toward many things, which is not engendered in our society, and a broad view rather than a focused specialist one.  Such skepticism is not about making money, and these days the incentive exists to show that everything is audible, because that sells more stuff.  Nor is it about "proving" anything except to the fickle and superstitious marketplace.  Successful audio engineers can therefore not be expected to have explored finding The Truth very deeply as part of being successful.  They only have their personal truths, which work for their game.

So even what some experienced engineer says is not evidence.  The only admissible evidence is from actual double blind testing done to the highest standard, and every aspect of that testing is open to deep criticism.  Will progress be made?  Who knows!  Heat death of the Sun or the collapse of human civilization may well occur first.

My position remains that the audible differences that Black Hats obsess about and White Hats dismiss are likely very small, if they exist at all.  That idea is tangentially supported by a very sophisticated exploration of the meaning of p values in testing I have been reading:
Getting a big p-value is not, by itself, very informative; even getting a small p-value has uncomfortable ambiguity. My advice would be to always supplement a p-value with a confidence set, which would help you tell apart "I can measure this parameter very precisely, and if it's not exactly 0 then it's at least very small" from "I have no idea what this parameter might be".
OK, this doesn't appear to apply to the Great Debate at all, because it's concerning the situation even when you have small P values, whereas the problem with most DBT's in The Great Debate is the continuing lack of small P values generally.  But turn it around, and you see even if we were getting small P values consistently it still wouldn be The Proof many people want.  The fact that p values are related to effect size and sample size means it's not easy to tease these things apart.  The safest thing to assume when an effect that is expected isn't verified in DBT is that the effect is small, not that it does not exist.

But this is never what the blackest of Black Hats say.  They always trumpet their unproven differences as very important, because otherwise why would anyone spend the megabucks necessary for Black Hat tweaks such as cryogenically treated cables?

We cannot trust the most successful audio designers or retailers any more than we can the most successful lawyers.   We can have much more trust in the White Hats who have gained little and have nothing to sell.  Things are not proven until they agree also.  The whole history of high end audio is full of flimflam, lies, and half-truths.  Progress has been made, but more slowly because of that.







Monday, July 27, 2015

James's Charlie and SAE

The low serial Sumo Charlie with rack handles (indicating final alignment by James Bongiorno) is a remarkably nice sounding tuner.  As with the non-handled Charlie, there is reduction of ambience, but not nearly as much.  The quieting is just as good or better.  It is able to hold the weakest of my favorite stations, KSYM, in wide stereo.  That was just the trick, I thought.  Then I brought back the other Charlie and unlike the week before, it was now holding KSYM in wide stereo also.  Shows the need for quick A/B switching when testing tuners.  Even if you can remember the sound or reception objectively, it can differ from time to time.

If Charlie can't hold KSYM in wide, it has to be switched to the inferior narrow.  Actually I had no need to use the Narrow IF in my one day testing of the handled Charlie, and I forgot to do so, but it would be interesting to see if it sounded better too.

The handled Charlie has the punchy bass and clear highs that I associate with the Marantz 20B, which I think Bongiorno may have worked with when he was at Marantz in the mid 1960's.  I suspect that is where he learned the best way to align an IF, or at least the Marantz 10 and 20 way, and he carried this knowledge with him to SAE and Sumo.

And speaking of the Bongiorno sound, I unpacked the SAE MkVIII to check it out, and it had, fuzzily, a similar sound.  This was the first tuner whose design could be more or less fully credited to Bongiorno.  He had been hired to save the MkVI tuners, but he had to work with what SAE had already done.  On the MkVIII, he was given a free hand to make a cost-reduced tuner nearly as good (and it could actually be better).

Despite my belief that air capacitor front ends are better, I actually though the Charlie to have better sound than the SAE MkVIII.  The SAE was slightly noisier, though, and the punchy bass and clear highs were a tad less punchy and clear, respectively.  Perhaps it needs a front end alignment, which would be possible I think, or a refurb.  An IF alignment isn't possible because it uses potted IF modules.

Both these tuners have issues not revealed by the eBay sellers.  The Charlie has the thing I fear the most.  It has a serious smell problem, like the Marantz 2130 I now have in storage because I couldn't bear the smell inside my house.  A previous owner must have been a heavy cigarette smoker.  In all the equipment I've bought on eBay, I've only seen this problem with 2 different FM tuners.  I will not be able to keep this Charlie permanently in my house, though it seems OK now in the garage room which has the best ventilation.  But it sounds so good, I can't just return it or toss it either.  I have to continue with my Investigation of the Bongiorno-sound tuners!  My ultimate goal would be not just to determine how they differ among themselves and compared with other tuners, but why.  Just how exactly was the Charlie aligned by Bongiorno, and how did that differ from what Sumo did after Bongiorno left?  What did Bongiorno know about the IF alignment of the Marantz 10/20 and are they different fundamentally from other tuners?

The SAE has a problem with its numeric readout.  Not just the broken segment claimed by the seller, but an additional and far more bothersome problem right now.  It doesn't show the station frequencies accurately at all.  It is way, way, way off.  When tuned to 90.1 it shows 80.5, which isn't even a valid FM frequency.  When tuned to 88.3 it shows a number in the 70's.  But then once and awhile the number displayed will briefly snap to the correct number, and then back.

The numeric display on the SAE is utterly unlike that on the Charlie.  The SAE only shows the correct number (or whatever it shows) when you are actually tuned in to a station.  Until you are actually tuned into a new station, it shows the number of the station last tuned in.  So it's not as helpful as you might think.

Sadly the motorized Kenwood KT-413 isn't very good at all, and just as FMTunerInfo says.  But I'll add more.  The motor is very fast, even when switched to the "slow" position, and I think that is part of the problem.  Sometimes it actually skips over stations going one way, but finds it in the other.  One wonders how accurate the tuning is.  Anyway, the sound is noisy and wimpy and utterly unlike the Charlie.






Sunday, July 26, 2015

DAC output level measurements

Since this blog is my notebook, here are the measurements of my various DACs, with 10M DMM loading (sorry didn't bother with different), at about -26dB (whatever level, it was consistent):

Denon DVD-5000:
L: 41.6 mV
R: 41.5 mV

Onkyo RDV-1:
L: 48.8 mV
R: 48.0 mV

Audio GD DAC 19
L: 63.0 mV
R: 63.3 mV

The Onkyo does show the most inter channel difference at 0.14dB, which is just above the usual 0.1dB matching requirement.  The Denon is the most tightly matched at 0.02dB.

I suspect the Denon has comparatively low output because it is saving output range (which may actually peak above 3V) for HDCD boost, but this is just a guess.

This shocked me to calculate, but the Audio GD is 2.2dB (left) and 2.4dB (right) louder than the Onkyo.  I would expect the measurements with actual amplifier loading (22k ohms) to be 0.2dB or less different at most and probably below 0.1dB different.

While ABX testing sets a condition at 0.1dB matching, typical matching isn't that good.  Some preamps with steps won't let you set balance closer than 1dB, though 0.5dB is common on digitally controlled preamps.  Old fashioned potentiometer volume controls might have +/-3dB inter channel mismatching (a 6dB total range)--so you really needed to use the companion balance control.  (I was glad to dump those in my then-main bedroom system in 2005 or so with a Classe CDP-35 preamp with digital volume control in no small part for the sake of being rid of potentiometer balance variation, which I barely remember but when I do it is with great dread.  Even my Aragon 28k preamp had considerable channel variation at the very low position I had to use on it.

Friday, July 24, 2015

Audio Nirvana Speakers…Slam!

I listened to these at a friend's house, Audio Nirvana speakers (12 or 15) in large and tall cabinets, with the speakers just above ear level IIRC.

It was in many ways very impressive sound, dynamic, full of slam, powerful and deep bass, clear midrange and highs, excellent left to right imaging, stable but not too much pinpoint.  He said he was unimpressed by other speakers he had heard, often very expensive, in audiophile's homes.  I sympathized with that, and in some parameters (dynamics and slam, especially) I have only heard megabuck systems at audiophile shows, like the largest MBL demonstration, that actually bettered what he could do.  Even with all my complicated and intentially overwideband system, I actually can't quite do slam as well, maybe, except perhaps if you are sitting in a corner instead of the sweet spot...

But I wouldn't say it was the least colored sound, it had clear colorations, a slightly exaggerated mid bass, elevated mid highs, obviously absent highest highs.  They always say things like "most people can't hear above 15,000 Hz anyway" but it seems to me, if it's missing, I can sense that somehow.  Though I couldn't name any instrument or anything that was obviously missing except for possibly noise anyway.  The other colorations seemed apparent but not particularly annoying either.  Possibly the worst aspects of this speaker could be fixed with digital EQ, making it truly reference, save for the supra 15 kHz…And there, supra 15kHz super tweeters might do the trick, without much messing the actual imaging.  Though once we get into all these further approximations of the needed changes, we would likely end up with…less slam.  The apparent missing high frequencies could also probably be adjusted with speaker aiming (beam that center right at the ears) and replacing damping used in the room with dispersion.  Much of what I was hearing as missing highs might not have actually been the speaker limitations.

Distortion, I don't know, he was playing pretty loudly in a small room, and there didn't appear to be anything like rising distortion near clipping.

But there was not much depth, and I think that was the ultimate sign of a cone speaker distortion type*…which should be expected!  The dynamic speaker is driven from the near center, and the propagation of sound through the speaker cone is dependent on frequency.  And the propagation through the speaker cone creates delayed radiation of that frequency for as long as it takes to travel through the speaker cone to it's ultimate point.  It's very fast in a relatively stiff cone (compared to air, say) but not instantaneous.  So there is an irreducible amount of time-smearing, and there may be some distortion from traveling through the cone also.

(*other explanations are possible, say related to room acoustics and speaker placement.)

There is one single cone (or mostly single cone) speaker which gets around these issues, and that's the Walsh driver, where the contour of the cone exactly matches the delay for time alignment.  And it also does it with omnidirectionality.

Actually, a relatively flat and stiff but still contoured cone like the Audio Nirvana may already do that same sort of thing to a considerable extent.  If we want to understand just this angle, we have to do the kinds of measurements few people bother to publish.  The sound suggests good but not quite perfect.

Anyway, electrostatics have their limitations too, which may be more bothersome to many who like slam.  These can be overcome in a reference system, like the one I'm still working on, with additional time aligned drivers for deep base, super highs, and so on.  Without those complicated fixes, whether one prefers electrostatics or single cone Audio Nirvana is a matter of choice, neither is perfect really.

So the Audio Nirvana approach makes a truly excellent Value system (by Audiophile standards of Value…non-audiophiles would think you were already spending enough for Reference).  But it may not offer as much potential for improvement as a system based on electrostatic panels plus additional drivers like mine.  I imagine that Electrostat loving friends of mine might be horrified at the idea their speakers are lacking anything, but I think it's a mainstream perception anyway that you get maximum slam with a dynamic loudspeaker system.  People like me try to get the best of both, by mixing both.

It's kind of a miracle that they've made single dynamic drivers these good now.  Most people would not think it possible.  I didn't.



Wednesday, July 22, 2015

Updating the SACD player

In sorting out my junk for sale, I also retested my Sony DVP-NS500V dvd player.  This was in the second generation of SACD playing products (after the SCD-1/777ES), and it was the lowest priced single disc SACD player.  It was also a DVD player of pretty low credentials now.

It was a cult player, and favorite of modifiers because you could buy this player new for as little as $149 and then fill it up with $1000 or more of mods, and people would say it challenged the big dogs.  My audio-nut brother-in-law liked it pure stock as the best sounding SACD player, I think for the few days that he even considered SACD's worth listening to.  He had suggested that the second generation of SACD decoders from Sony was better than the first.

In scientifically useless sighted testing I preferred it in some ways to the Denon 5900, my living room player.  It had a more dynamic and expressive sound on SACD's.  The Denon sounded quieter, cleaner, as though it wasn't taking any chances.   On CD's I preferred the Denon 5900 and even the Denon 2900.

Now I don't take SACD or the equivalent (and I stress equivalent) digital file format DSD as the ultimate of anything other than hype.  In no way are these formats superior to PCM formats using the same amount of data, and my personal feeling remains that SACD's or PCM files are even inferior to Redbook CD….although it may be fooling at times since the SACD does have better midrange dynamic range.

So I don't obsess about SACD's or pure DSD signal paths.  But I feel it's worth having the best SACD playback, at least, as I can, for music that is only or best available that way.

I couldn't have pure DSD anyway because  the backbone of my system, from selection to level control and crossover and EQ are all done in PCM, and cannot be done in anything like DSD anyway.  I read SACD's by resampling them to 24/96 digital using a Lavry AD10.

I strongly reject the concept that DSD files have the potential to sound better than optical disc transports.  Highly tuned optical disc transports have the possibility of not only having the lowest jitter, but of having a particular kind of forward-motion timing much like idler wheel turntables.  Lack of motion is not a possible state, given the rotational inertia and forward drive force.  Whatever variation exists is forward running and not fed back into itself.  This is going to sound free as in freedom.  Meanwhile, most asynchronous digital systems like USB and Sonos operate on the principles of handshaking and full duplex communication.  This is going to have a different kind of time signature, one of deliberate action, give and take, action and reaction.  I know this sounds like magical thinking, and may be, but it seems to me that at the very finest of levels, these correlations (or something similar to what I'm describing) are what actually exists…whether we can detect them or not.  Clocks are never exactly perfect, etc., and furthermore in real systems all the imperfections have ample force to be correlated through sharing space, grounding, and connections.  When you have multiple stages of time varying devices which are intended to reject the incoming time variations, they can never do it perfectly.  Basically, everything is awash in tiny variations, with relationships that produce actual if not statistically verifiable correlations.  The mere fact that you have "buffering" or whatever doesn't mean the problem is completely solved…at least at the level of the tiniest actual particles and wavelengths, variations continue to go on at the tiniest of levels, and everything within an electromagnetic sphere of influence has some contribution to the proceedings.  Best is to make everything, at every level and every way, as stable, simple, uncorrelated (free), forward running, and close to the next amplifier as possible (distance is loss too), that's the best linear system for music.  That's what you get with a very high end packaged SACD player, as compared with a network of interacting devices which ultimately decodes DSD files.  And timing is more critical to DSD.

(Audibility?  There is no reason to believe such effects would be remotely audible (DSD 1x files vs SACD players).  Jitter becomes audible many orders of magnitude better than the worst but correctly performing digital equipment, according to published research.  But remember, proven audibility is not what I am concerned about.  What I am concerned about is not the verifiable, but the potential for difference, a difference that ultimately might make a difference within the infinite possibilities of the future.  Anyway nobody who claims an audible difference can back that up with scientifically respectable research at this point.  It's all just hand waving.  So if I can point to what actually has better potential, not just someone's current opinion based on biases, I win.)

So I believe it's worth having an SACD optical player, and maybe even play CD's this way too, by resampling them to digital rather than using the digital output or digital files.  I am thinking now that this  works precisely because both the player and the ultimate digital signal are decoupled in time.  Digital sampling is measurably so close to perfect as to be as good as any analog preamp, so there is no penalty for using it in this way, and anything can be resampled to anything else with nearly perfect dithering.

And now I find out that generally the first generation DAC chips Sony used in its statement SACD players, the SCD-1 and SCD-777es and also the cheaper DVP-9000ES, the "V24" series, is considered superior to the second generation chipset in my NS500V player…which was intended for AV products and not audiophile products.

I'd always lusted over the cool looking SCD-1 with a top loading drive with weight, which I think in general is a superior configuration (though the specific unit in the SCD-1 may not be as good as transports in other units such as Esoteric and Accuphase which are conventional drawer loading--or even possibly the transport in the DVP-9000ES).  Now I find out I can get almost the same thing in the 777ES, but all the players after that, including the current 5400ES, look cheaply built in comparison, lacking the heavy build and heavy transport.

(When a CD plays in a cheap front loading player, it may be vibrating like hell.  You wonder how the system works, but it works just up to a breaking point.  But this is further time variation at the beginning of the whole process, messing everything up downstream, no matter how much buffering, etc., there is a chain of causality and correlation is created.  And with higher speed media such as SACD, it's 10 times worse, or maybe 20 times worse, on top of the timing itself being 64x more critical.  Now the vibration may not always be so bad, I'm talking worst case here.  But you simply can't imagine this happening with a SACD clamped or weighted down onto a heavy metal platform.  So this is why I like the idea of a top loading player, because it makes sure you are going to have a flat spinning disc without too much vibration.)

So the kind of thing I'd like to get would be SCD-1, SCD-777ES, DVP-9000ES.  Also it looks like the Marantz units are especially good, and may honor the SACD/DSD signal better than Denon.  Something like an SA11.  I'm not sure whether the Esoteric DV-50, now available not too far out of my price range, would honor SACD as well but it could be far better with CD's, and looks to have a transport that may be among the best among these alternatives.

I actually don't see any reason why having the laser fixed as in the SCD-1 is a good idea.  The usual method of fixing the spindle sounds much easier, and possibly better.  Might as well have the rotating element fixed--it's certainly the harder thing to move.  A simpler top loading drive would be a good idea, for reasons I have explained, but neither Sony nor Esoteric nor Accuphase nor Marantz offer that. I do have the feeling now that of the mechanisms available, the top of the line Esoteric is the best.  But that's not something I can imagine affording soon.  At this point I can only imagine the DV50 and that is really way beyond my need for SACD, and I think it might not be the better choice for SACD among these options anyway, though it could make up for any inferiorities with a better mechanism too perhaps.

Timing is very very important for one bit formats.  In a way, all of the information is just timing.  So an especially good transport is a must.  Sadly many of the old classics like the CEC belt drive transport were made for CD not SACD.