Tuesday, December 4, 2012

Better than expected: L-1000t over sonos

I have been listening to Kenwood L-1000T tuner, which is physically located in the living room, in other rooms using the "line input" feature of my Sonos system.

Currently this is hooked up like this:

Kenwood fixed output->Behringer DEQ 2496 (fixes eq)->Sonos box
Sonos box->system

Thus it goes through two complete analog-to-digital and digital-to-analog conversions, one inside the Behringer DEQ, and other within the Sonos system.  The latter uses 44.1Khz sampling at 16 bits.  The Behringer uses very good 96/24 converters but has rather mediocre analog circuitry.

Anyway, it sounds nice in the bedroom, and very nice in the kitchen.  I was really enjoying listening to college radio on Monday night.  Even with all the intermediaries involved, it sounds even more lively (rhythm!) than the Marantz 2130 which is actually in the Kitchen.

So here's something which shouldn't be that good, but actually is.  Actually I think digital-to-analog and analog-to-digital conversions are relatively harmless for audio.  Experiments have put 100 such conversions back-to-back and still the differences are not large enough to show up in blind testing.

I could actually hook this up using the Lavry for conversion rather than the Behringer, and I hope to do that soon.

More thoughts on the mediocre standard definintion video

I'm absolutely sure that I have seen better Standard Definition (480i) video than my Mac is now producing through the Belkin adapter (to get HDMI) and the Monoprice adapter (to get analog component).  It's very soft looking, and if I get up close, I can see weird artifacts.

480i done correctly can be a beautiful format.  It ways all most people ever knew in video until about the year 2000.  For 10 years I was the proud owner of a $3299 list price Sony TV made in 1997, a 32XBR100.  This was probably the best NTSC-only TV ever made.   It did not support any extended format features.  It did not do progressive scanning even.  But it did a perfect job of decoding NTSC from either composite (!) or S-Video inputs.  The composite inputs were decoded by one of the best Digital 3D Comb Filters ever made.  (I think the one in my later 34XBR960 is also very good.)  The 3D comb filter eliminated interlace artifacts.  In 2008, when I got a very nice 550 series Samsung 42" LCD to replace it, I was extremely disappointed that it could not eliminate interlace artifacts (from component video inputs) as well as the 32XBR100 had.  I then bought an ancient Faroudja de-interlacer (which originally sold for $15,000) and a DVDO scaler to get back what I once had.  But neither of those were as good as the Sony was either.  Neither of those expensive converters actually has a 3D comb filter.  But the DVDO is a nice unit and I still use it today to digitize analog sources onto my digital TV network.

And don't get me started on LCD vs CRT.  LCD has lagged for years the dynamic range, bright-to-dark, of old CRT sets by a country mile.  LCD has no problem with bright, but it has a problem with near-black, the so-called "shadow detail."  With fancy LED lighting schemes, LCD may be finally catching up.  I don't buy TV's often, so I'm not quite sure how good they are now.  People I talk to generally don't get that LCD is not the same as high definition.  It's just that they both came on the scene at about the same time.  And almost nobody has seen CRT TV's as good as the "XBR squared" models I have had, the 32XBR100 and the 32XBR960.

But now that we have High Definition TV, few if any manufacturers do a decent job with Standard Definition anymore.  I think that's basically the problem here.  They just can't be bothered to do it well anymore.  And they might say that nobody demands it anymore.

The 480i component video I now get is not nearly as sharp as the 480i S-Video I had been getting from my Titanium Macbook Pro, made in 2003, which had an S-Video jack right on the side.  That was also going through the DVDO adapter I am still using now.

 So where is the problem now?  I doubt that anything bad is done by the Belkin adapter which converts mini DisplayPort to HDMI.  It looks to me like this is not a conversion at all; the display port is simply carrying essentially the same lines as an HDMI cable.

It could be that there is a bandwidth limitation in the Monoprice adapter which converts HDMI to Composite Video.  But since this adapter is capable of 1080p, you would think it would have no problem with 480i.  And the box says it has 10 bit converters, that should be good too.  Many early DVD players, even the most excellent ones (like my $1500 Sony DVD-7000), had only 8 bit converters.

I have a suspicion a lot of loss is occurring in the Mac itself, via a very lossy 480i codec.  Actually, I just read this website explaining video codecs, and 480i is not a codec.  But 480x720i is a codec, and that is the one being used.  Video codecs are usually at least a little lossy.  I suspect one of two things (or both)

1) Apple didn't much bother to make a best-possible 480x720i codec.  After all, who uses that anymore?  They can't be that critical if they are still using such an old (the original) format.

2) Apple didn't want to make a good 480x720i codec.  Standard Definition video is the one video source that can be copied by all VCR's and most other video copying devices.  My Sony RDR-HX900, one of the last consumer video recorders Sony ever made, only accepts interlaced inputs in Standard Definition.  While not all electronic manufactures have interests aligned with the movie industry, none of them want to offend the movie industry either.  And one way they do this is by not making it easy, in fact making it increasingly hard, over time, to copy video, any kind of video, even when there is not active copy restriction system like HDCP in effect.  Manufacturers remember how Sony was sued by the movie industry (and Sony now *is* the movie industry, or at least one of the biggest players) for making the Betamax which could be used to record broadcast TV and movies.

3) Apple softened the 480x720i codec specifically so it would not look as bad on standard definition displays that have lousy comb filters.  Actually, only "composite video" in standard definition even needs a comb filter.  Neither S-Video nor Component Video require a comb filter.  But just in case someone might be using composite video, after all what does anyone do with 480i anymore, the codec is softened to reduce artifacts if viewed through a composite video connection.

If indeed the problem is the lossy codec that Apple uses in the Mac, I'm not sure what I can do about that.  Basically nothing unless I can find a better replacement version, which is unlikely, I am afraid.  Now in theory I could have the Mac output 1080p, and have some other device downscale to 480i.  But guess what...nobody makes scalers that downscale to 480i !!!  Or at least I have not found one.  It seems like converter makers also follow the written and unwritten rules to make 480i less and less available.  My DVDO will produce 480p (even from a 1080p source) but will not produce 480i.

But it's also possible the main limitations are in the Monoprice HDMI to composite adapter.  And in that case, I can simply use another adapter.  I will do that very soon.

Monday, December 3, 2012

Trouble and success with mini DisplayPort

On Saturday and Sunday I continued watching video through the mini DisplayPort using the 8 foot Belkin HDMI adapter.  It worked OK, but the images looked very blurry, up close you could see obvious jagged-edge type artifacts.  It seemed like I could adjust UP the sharpness control on my Sony XBR-960 TV and Samsung LCD to make it better, similar to what has been claimed on web.

This is curious because what what sharpness controls do is actually distort the picture by boosting high video frequencies, similar to the use of the Treble control on old hifi equipment.  This doesn't actually increase true resolution, it lowers it actually, but might have an objectively beneficial effect if the source has excessive high video frequency rolloff.  Has Apple somehow pre-compensated for old analog sets when it makes connections at 480i. since such sets were frequently set with high "sharpness" control settings?  Or did they just use an especially lousy 480i video codec?

But another question was why, in this setup, I was being restricted to 480i.  There were no copying devices hooked up to the system.  HDMI goes first to a 5 way switch which is about 2 years old.  Then it goes to a 4 way splitter that is about 5 years old.  All of this handles 1080i perfectly, in fact that's what it often does.  In fact it even handles 1080p, except my 2005 CRT TV does not.

Somehow, when DisplayPort sees this HDMI switch, it refuses to engage any resolution higher than 480i.  No other devices have had that problem.  I tried re-hooking, different inputs, and powering up and powering down, and fiddling with the Display preferences, but DisplayPort has decided that you have a 480i device, you only have NTSC and PAL resolutions to choose from.

I disconnected the computer, keyboard, display, mouse, and cables and took them to the bedroom and hooked directly to my 1080p Samsung TV.  THEN the display port had no problem doing 1080i or 1080p, directly to my TV.  I tried both the Belkin and Rocketfish adapters, and they worked identically in this setup.  I normally use the Rocketfish Mini DisplayPort to HDMI adapter in the bedroom with my bedroom macbook pro.

So I brought the computer and stuff back to the living room, and tried using the Rocketfish adapter.  Once again I could only get 480i.  Since the two adapters behaved identically, I think the defective "intelligence" is actually in the DisplayPort itself.  After going back to the Belden adapter, and after lots more fiddling, I was stuck with no visible output just as I had been on Thursday night.  In the worst cases, the Display preferences don't even show a second display connected.

One of my theories is that mini DisplayPort is paranoid.  It agressively downrezes to 480i if it sees anything "fishy" on the output as part of it's copy-prevention protocol which goes above and beyond HDCP.  Even just an HDMI switch can engage this feature.  Apple does says that you can use the DisplayPort output with one adapter, and no more.  A switch is not an adapter, but still enough to give DisplayPort fits.  (This theory is a bit inconsistent with my later successes, read on.  Perhaps the DisplayPort is paranoid about the wrong things.)

It's also possible that something on my video network is reporting back it's capabilities incorrectly.  But since all my other 1080i devices on the switch work fine in 1080i, I think I can fairly say that the mini DisplayPort is not acting as switch (or splitter) friendly as true HDMI components.  Thus I am not surprised at all that Apple doesn't make an actual HDMI adapter.  They may know their interface is bugged, and it may be bugged deliberately.

So this was not looking well for connecting miniDispayPort to my Sony RDR-HX900 video recorder.  That connection through the Sony was the way I used to view the computer output, as it also conveniently switches in some other 480i components, with all of them, including video stored on the Sony itself, getting converted to 1080i with my HDHO adapter on the output.

But in fact, I hooked the mini DisplayPort to a miniDisplayPort to Component Video adapter (interestingly no longer advertised on the Monoprice website, but I found it searching on Amazon) and it worked fine.  I got clear 480i direct into my Sony.  I could select 480p, but then the Sony output went dark.  I checked the Sony manual and found that while the Sony allows 480p output, it only allows 480i input.  So this is the best I could do with any adapter.  Actually, the display preferences in this case let me select up to 1080p...the Monoprice adapter works with 1080p even if my old Sony does not.  I was also able to play back videos I have downloaded from commercial erotic websites also, with no problem.  I did not try playing DVD...I have little doubt that would not work.

And most strangely, the video even looked better this way.  The jagged edges were gone.  It's possible the image doesn't have any more resolution, in fact it might have less, but I think it looks better somehow (no side by side comparison possible now).  Possibly it's because the Sony decodes 480i better than most things.  Then the Sony output goes through an Anchor Bay DVDO to generate DVI, which gets adapted to 1080i into my HDMI switch.

So after this weekend, I cannot claim not to be a happy camper.  For years I resisted upgrading my Mac fearing that I would loose my old video setup.  Now I have my old video setup back, working fine*, and it looks about as good as before if not better, driven by a computer that doesn't strain (and often crash) under the load of YouTube video like my old one did.  Technically, my old Powerbook setup used S-Video and this new one uses Component, so it could be slightly better even, and I think it does look better now, despite the earlier lousy looking 480i on HDMI.

(*The hard drive in the Sony RDR-HX900 needs replacing.  The old one keeps old recordings, but won't keep new ones.  I bought a replacement harddrive a few months ago, didn't replace it when it seemed like the old harddrive was working again, but then I found it would not keep new recordings.)

It would still be good to have a direct Mac connection to my video system through HDMI at a higher resolution than 480i, then I could watch web videos at higher resolutions than 480i.  I never had that capability before, but I can see it would be nice.  Though I fear the limitation may be with the Mac DisplayPort, my positive experince with a component video adapter bodes well that a possibility still exists.  Perhaps there is some kind of communication problem with my video network that the Mac is sensitive to, but could be fixed with a gadget like the one sold by Geffen which forces a particular description of display capabilities onto the HDMI line.


Friday, November 30, 2012

Mac Mini Setup, Phase 2

Over in my other blog, Brick Pool House, I described setting up my new Mac Mini starting on Black Friday.  It went smoothly.  But I did not hook it up to my video system because I needed an appropriate Mini DisplayPort adapter(s).

One reason I had not bought a Mini earlier, say 2-3 years ago, was because I was worried about connecting to my video system as easily as I had the PowerBook which had S-Video output.

On Wednesday and Thursday I bought various parts at Radio Shack and Best Buy.

On Thursday night I hooked up a MiniDisplayPort to HDMI adapter "cable" from Belkin, which I bought at Best Buy.  What Belkin has done is package a short cabled adapter with a 7 foot HDMI cable for $44.  You could buy the separate parts but they would end up costing more.  Plus I figured these pieces were made to go together (they are, and the inline HDMI connection fits snugly).  I only worried that the actual "converter" circuitry might not be as good as the more expensive separate options.  But I figured it was probably about the same, and this looked neat.

Well at first I plugged in the display port adapter and plugged the HDMI into my 5 way HDMI switch (which feeds a HDMI splitter which goes to TV's in 3 different rooms) it did not work.  I fiddled with it on Thursday night for more than an hour and could not get it working.  I unplugged and replugged the HDMI cable.  I turned off the kitchen TV (an older model which has 1080i, but not 1080p) and tried the Bedroom TV (a Samsung from 2008) instead.  I rebooted the Mac.  Frustratingly, the Display Preferences showed only one device, the DVI monitor, and not anything else.   However, the status light on the HDMI switch did light up.  I changed the refresh rate for the (only one shown) display to 60Hz.  I also tried changing the display preferences down to 1024x768 (very similar to 720p) and even 640x480.

I did not re-plug the Mini DisplayPort plug itself, because that was tricky.  By the end of the night, I had removed the Mini DisplayPort plug, but been unable to plug it in in the dim light, and beginning to wonder if the Thunderbolt indication meant this wasn't really a Mini DisplayPort.

All night long I was dreading the possibility that this newfangled DisplayPort thing would not work a video switch.  Apple does indeed say you should not plug any other adapters into a Mini DisplayPort adapter.  They say you should ONLY plug an approved monitor into the adapter.  This would go way beyond the normal HDCP copy restriction if you couldn't even use HDMI switches and splitters.  But maybe that's what I was not stuck with.  Perhaps I could get the old PowerBook going again with a new Hard Drive.  This was the kind of thing I was thinking, and dreading.

In the morning I checked online, and in fact the Thunderbolt plug can work like a Mini DisplayPort plug if a Mini DisplayPort adapter is plugged into it.  Looking at one set of troubleshooting instructions from Mac, I noticed that as their last step, they had you remove and reinsert the Mini DisplayPort plug after shutdown and then restart.  The instructions were a bit ambiguous as if to suggest you should try re-inserting the plug several times even.

This time I was able to re-insert the plug, and it still didn't work right off, but after a bit more fiddling, it started working, and I got good images on both kitchen and bedroom TV's at once.  The second monitor now does show up in Display Preferences and I adjusted them for side-by-side.  I set the main monitor for "best display."  For some reason, the video system only gets 640x480.  I can only choose that.  I shut off the kitchen TV again, and on my Bedroom TV I could select either 640x480 or PAL, but no HDTV like 1080p.

It must be that my switch and splitter are sending some kind of least-common-denominator display information back up the line.  All of my TV's are capable of 720p and 1080i, but my Kitchen TV only does 1080i and not 1080p.  Perhaps the DisplayPort can't do 1080i (update: I now know that it can do 1080i from the adjustments with the Monoprice DisplayPort->Component adapter) and can't do 720p either but only 480p or 1080p.  That seems very limited, but it would explain what I am now seeing.  I have turned off the kitchen TV but maybe I need to disconnect it from the HDMI splitter to get a higher resolution.  Anyway, I'm actually glad it does support 480p, which is more appropriate for some things.  But what I'd like to do is be able to switch among these resolutions (and even 1080i, if that is possible, to get best image on my kitchen TV).



Wednesday, November 28, 2012

More fun with Kenwood L-1000T

Just a few weeks ago I hooked up my Kenwood L-1000T (aka Kenwood in this post) to my whole house Sonos audio system using a Behringer DEQ 2496 digital equalizer to correct the European 50uS deemphasis to the USA 75uS standard.  In the digital domain I can do the conversion quite well, even with the limited choice of cutoff frequencies.  I use a 6dB per octave shelving at 2212Hz.  Right now I can't remember the dB of adjustment but I think it was between 2 and 3dB (calculated in an earlier post).

Well of course I couldn't even enjoy the Kenwood over Sonos without this change (or something having a similar effect, like actually changing the parts in the Kenwood), so even though I had hooked up the Kenwood to Sonos back in July, I hadn't really used it much for the Kenwood.

What I mostly use this for is listening to radio in the bedroom.  The bedroom currently does not have any tuners hooked up (though, ironically, I have the stack of second best tuners that the Kenwood defeated now resting in the bedroom because the computer room has been overstuffed with junk).

When I used the Sonos system to listen to FM, which wasn't that often, I usually listened to the Marantz 2130 in the kitchen as it has the correct EQ and actually sounds very nice.  Sonos lets me pipe a line-input signal from any room to any other room, it goes through a moderate quality 44.1Khz 16 bit uncompressed codec with digital level adjustment so you can optimize the dynamic range.

This was a revelation.  The Kenwood always sounded great, but now I could actually stand listening to it for hours, and using my KT-6040 remote control, I spent one evening scanning radio stations.

On Tuesday night I found how the Kenwood L-1000T with correct EQ really blows away the Marantz 2130 over Sonos.  The Marantz sounds veiled and muddy by comparison.  (It doesn't sound that way at all in the kitchen, possibly because of different room acoustics and near field listening, but also possibly this test is unfair, I have fully optimized the Sonos level for the Kenwood a few days ago, currently max tuner output gets to -3dB digital maximum, but the Marantz level in the Kitchen has not been optimized, and was about 20dB lower, causing huge loss of digital resolution (though I raised the volume level to compensate, it can't restore the resolution lost over 16bit depth conversion and transmission).  Possibly the Marantz level actually depends on the volume level I set on the amplifier in the kitchen, actually a Yahama receiver.

But I also came to notice on Tuesday night this week that the signal from San Antonio City College was mono.  I noticed this because I happened to pipe the Kenwood output to the kitchen system, and look at the stereo separation on the L-R scope mode of the Marantz.

So I took a careful look at the display of the Kenwood tuner.  It was showing only one (tiny) bar of signal strength, yet the RF selection was Direct.  Obviously this was causing a weak signal and limiting stereo separation.

For some time now, I had been convinced that the 6040 remote doesn't control the station control settings on the Kenwood.  But somehow I had pre-programmed Preset 2 for Direct mode.  Either I had actually set the Direct mode somehow, or at some earlier time the signal strength may have been stronger when I was setting the presets.

I was able to un-set the Direct mode by this procedure:

a) Disable setup mode using small button to the right of tuning knob.
b) Change the tuning by the minimum amount in either direction.
c) Change the tuning back to the correct center tune.

This forces the Kenwood to determine the best settings for this station, and when I do this now, it correctly choses High Sensitivity mode.

Now the fact that the presets had been programmed with direct mode suggests that possibly I had been able to control the RF mode previously, and I had deliberately chosen direct thinking it would give the best sound quality.  Or, more likely, I had set direct mode for KPAC, a much stronger station, and had failed to unset it for the remaining stations that I programmed.

Taking the remote in hand again, I struggled and with much fiddling with angle and direction was able to get the Kenwood to change RF mode once.  I think the capability is actually there, I just lost it when I stuffed the Kenwood into the corner it now occupies, which gives no good way to aim the remote at it (the Kenwood is immediately behind the transformer of my Acoustat speaker).  I can try to control it from the side that I have open and it sometimes works.  I can also use the Remote Extender system which I use to control the preset station selection from the bedroom.  That also has a receiver over the living room mantel so I can point the remote at that rather than at the tuner.  It works, mostly, for setting presets, but may not have enough IR resolution for the advanced settings like the RF mode.  The remote extender has a transmitter I place just to the side of the L-1000T and it works, at least it works well enough to change presets.

It may also be the batteries in the 6040 remote have gotten weak.

I need to experiment with this more, it was already well past my bedtime when I made the above discoveries, and I decided to stop because I know these kinds of explorations can last all night and typically end on some frustrating note.  But I will be back at it soon.

In the meantime, I used my mis-tuning method to get the Kenwood back to receiving the city college station in High Sensitivity mode.  But if I change the preset, this gets messed up, so I really have to find some way to fix it.  I could also memorize the preset with the High Sensitivity mode.  But I also forgot how to program presets, I alway find this confusing and counter-intuitive on Kenwood digital tuners and I need to read the instructions again.

But another flaw is that I can't, or at least was unable, set the IF bandwidth.  When I change the RF mode back to High Sensitivity using the method above, it also resets the IF bandwidth to Narrow.  It really doesn't need to do that I think, as Wide works fine on Direct mode, it should also work OK on Narrow.  But as yet I haven't figured out a way to change that.  Perhaps the remote will do this, and perhaps it won't.

Here's a discussion of HDMI/HDCP handshaking.

There are endless blogs of people describing issues and frustrations with Apple's Mini DisplayPort.  Many people have suffered with the disappointment that they cannot use their cherished display with their cherished Mac.  And for many of those people, the problem did not go away the next day.

After you look at the discussion of HDMI/HDCP handshaking, it's not surprising that this technology is so finnicky.  HDMI/HDCP want to make sure you're not doing anything that isn't allowed (recording!).  And it seems, even a slight seeming irregularity will shut them down.  Also, all HDMI/HDCP units have an internal state, which may need to be reset by powering down the unit for 10 seconds.  You try powering down everything, making all the connections, then powering up switches, then displays, then sources.  If that doesn't work, try powering down everything and then powering up switches, sources, and displays.  Some configurations work better with powering source first, others with powering display first.

Oh Boy.

Thursday, November 1, 2012

Playing with the Kurzweil

A month or so ago I pulled out my mint (barely used) Kurzweil K2661.  Over in the corner where it has had a nice custom made table to sit on for the last 4 years, it has mostly just sat, because it's just no fun to stand in that corner and play.  So I pulled it out right in front of the Queen Anne chair at the back of the living room.  That makes for a great place to play.  It is lined up with the L-R of the speakers.  Obviously one does not get the incredible image one gets up front.  But one does get a nice distant image that I find good enough, and the back of the room, and the Queen Anne chair, is much more suited to playing than in front.  And the beauty of this arrangement, with playing chair in the back and listening chair up front, is that both are independent and always available to be their best.  I can leave the Kurzweil out for the whole month until my end-of-the-month party, when I can temporarily put it back on the custom made table in the corner.  The rest of the time, it can be out in the room.

That's exactly what I did for the party in October, I put the Kurzweil away on the morning of the party and back after the party, so it was unavailable for the minimum time.  And when I set it up this time, I skipped all the wiring mistakes I made the first time, and got the wires entirely out-of-the-way instead of taking-up-the-whole-room.  There is one passage, around to the couch in back, that has become a bit tricky mainly because of the Kurzweil itself.  But now I make the front path to the couch around the listening chair entirely clear of wires.

Since I purchased the music workstation in 2006, I suspect I've used it less than 400 hours, mostly just random playing, barely learning how to program or do anything (though I know it's all there...it can do anything, well almost, play all parts you've recorded at once, just like a full band, with accurate (to varying degrees) renditions of every kind of instrument or synthesizer, and every aspect of every Program (instrument) can be edited, or new ones can be created from factory samples or new loaded samples.  The Kurzweil gives you a nice collection of samples and raw sounds and an all-inclusive (just about) set of all the possible transforming operations that could be done with them, and then you can hookup as many of one to the other and to controllers in as many ways you can imagine in fairly long channels.  Thus, it makes you the instrument designer, and you can make it do anything anyhow.  It's a kind of soft instrument made of user programmable DSPs, which uses actual DSP hardware to realize how it is programmed.  A true analog instrument with as many capabilities as this would fill a building.  (DSP = Digital Signal Processors)

Last month I finally figured out Record Mode, or at least I recorded myself a few times, and it actually worked.  I've been watching the video tutorial that I downloaded from Kurzweil or somewhere when I bought my unit.  It's good, but it doesn't start with creating Programs and so even though I've now watched half of it I still haven't gotten to the programming part.  I watched him record a sequence, and after that I got it to work.

Here is one of the better tutorials I've seen on creating a Kurzweil Program.

http://kurzweil.com/knowledgebase/k2600r/program_mode/88/

Monday, July 16, 2012

Two Steps Forwards, One Backwards

After getting back home from a long Saturday (trip to nursury, dinner, concert) I thought I'd catch up on a few audio issues in the master bedroom.

Ever since I set up the Linn Sondek turntable system a few months back, I haven't had a 24 bit ADC to digitize the output of my Denon 3910 DVD-Audio/SACD player.  I moved the Behringer DEQ 2496 over next to the turntable to keep the analog lines short.  So I had to plug the 3910 straight into the Tact RCS 2.0 analog inputs, which are notoriously 16 bit (or at least 16 bit performance).  To add insult to injury, I also had to attenuate the DVD player output with a 6dB attenuator to be sure it did not overload the maximum 1.5V input of the Tact.  Actually, 3dB would have been sufficient, but when I set this up I had run out of 3dB attenuators.

To fix this, a few weeks back I have moved the MSB PAD-1 into the bedroom, but hadn't hooked it up.

Here's a list of things I ended up doing:


1) Removed Acurus L-10 preamp, now possibly not working (or at least LED not lighted).

2) Removed Yahama T-85 from underneath Tact.  The T-85 has issues and I haven't used it in several years.  It was finally convenient to remove the T-85 after I removed all the stuff on top of the Tact.

3) Vacuumed, vacuumed, vacuumed (top of Tact, MSB, Aragon and rack)

4) Hooked up the MSB, including its power adapter, and hook its AES/EBU output to the Tact (#5).

3) Moved the Aragon 28K preamp on top of the MSB.  It had been over near the phonograph system, but was not being used.  I had tried using it instead of the tube preamp for the Panasonic strain gauge cartridges, but it didn't work well in that application, nevertheless it had stayed there.

4) Hooked up the 28K to the analog output of the Denon.  Only the Denon is now hooked up.

5) Removed old analog line from TV to Acurus.  Apparently I had set up this line because the digital link from TV to Tact was once not working well.  I figured out why also (see below) and fixed it.  This line used a long interconnect, two 3dB adapters, and a Radio Shack isolation transformer.

6) Moved 30 foot Toslink connection from TV to Behringer used for phono system.

7) Extracted M-Audio CO2 from living room and connected to Tact with coax (finally using fancy radio shack coax, one from BJC was too stiff).  This adapter converts toslink to coax digital so I can use one of the 3 coax digital inputs on the Tact.

8) Tried BJC toslink from TV to CO2.  Very intermittent, usually not working unless I wiggled the cable at the input to CO2.  Now I remembered I had this problem before.

9) Extracted a 2nd 30ft toslink cable from behind the sofa in living room.  That second cable has been ambushed there by a snarl for several years.  Using that cable, the CO2 worked fine, so now the digital connection between TV and audio system works fine, and also allows remote switching to the digital connection between phonograph and audio system.  Previously I had to manually switch the one working 30 foot toslink cable I had between TV and phono system, which didn't encourage me to play more records.

10) Adjusted gain on 28K so that Denon would not clip MSB.  My first test was playing a Chesky jazz disc 'Havana' over and over and noting the peak level.  That was a very time consuming test, but the disc was already in the player.  Later I used the Stereophile test disc 2 on track 17 and noted the "average level".  Finally I used the 19+20K distortion test, turning off the DCX so as not to play through speakers.  With that test playing at 0dB, I had average level about -3.5dB with volume control at about 2:30.  Peak level was just above -20dB, but I don't think that is a problem.  I need to make a better test disc for this purpose.

11) Finding that I couldn't see the Denon on my TV, I reconnected the S-Video cable that goes through Isomax transformer.

12) I played a multichannel SACD and was finding that despite setting SACD control to stereo, the indicator still showed multichannel output.

13) Fiddling with the Denon setup menu, I found it was necessary to turn the Denon-link off in order to adjust the audio from multichannel to stereo.

14) I listened to several discs, notably Hanson conducts Hanson, as background music as I was working on stuff.

15) Once I got the TV working over the 2nd toslink cable, I ran that for several hours to make sure it was working without cutouts.  It was playing a Nova special on string theory.

16) Tested phono system which I haven't used for a couple months.  The Linn appears not to start.  The pushbutton light goes out quickly after the start button is pressed.

****  So I went to a lot of work to make it possible to switch digital inputs from TV to Turntable and back, and then guess what, the turntable stops working !!!

I may fiddle with the Linn a bit more.  Also this might be a good time to check out the Sony turntable.  I never actually inspected the Sony circuitry, I just disconnected it at the first sight of bad operation.

It's sad that my phono system isn't working again.  But it seems I like to play DVD-Audio and SACD discs more anyway.