Nowadays I'm keeping my room more and more in "movie" configuration, with no chair in the "hot spot." The closest thing is the loveseat in back. But along the back wall, the hot seat EQ is very boomy. So I created a second EQ for the back, which is the Movie EQ.
Well it's becoming clear that the Movie EQ might well be better for most background listening, which is what I do most of the time. So it looks really like the Movie EQ should be the default, and the Hot Seat EQ should be the 'Special.' Well, that's exactly how I did things in my previous generation of less-well-tuned EQ's, when I had "Normal" (now Movie) and "Boost" (now Hot Seat).
But the Movie EQ was a giant hack which I did, after months of tuning the hot seat EQ, I simply added a graphic EQ overlay to dampen the excess bass along the back wall. I realized then I should re-do the Movie EQ from scratch, or at least so it isn't an EQ on top of an EQ, but the original EQ simply tailored for that position.
That was about the time I discovered the polarity problem with my DEQ, which made it complicated to do the in-position adjusting my method requires. Then it turned out I could buy a brand new DEQ, and I did, and I now have that. But then many other urgent situations arose: needed were new dishwasther, new computer, new phone, new security system, ceiling repair, foundation repair, under slab drain repair, and ultimately a new car, which I just drove home last week. It's been a busy year, and that's just part of it.
But for a week, it seemed I had some time (which is now evaporating) and just did some measurements of the current state. The adjustments are the same, but the hot seat has been moved to the side so the room is in movie viewing configuration but without the screen set up, which is pretty much the norm except when I'm doing Serious Listening, maybe once a week or so.
I'm using the iPhone 8 I used for previous measurements again.
First I measured the background noise:
 |
| Background Noise |
Then, the response at the old "hot seat" location, but with the actual chair moved to the side:
 |
| Hot Seat Location Without Chair |
There's a notable dip at 31 Hz, otherwise pretty smooth to 1k then rolled off as intended. I don't remember that dip from the earlier measurements. Anyway this is "invalid" without the chair at that position anyway, I just wanted to take a look. Actually it looks like it may need some analyzing. Perhaps something is wrong or changed. It was nearly flat 20-1000 Hz.
And while I was doing this looking, I decided to try turning off the Bag End E-Trap, which is currently in the corner of the hallway connected to the living room, where there is normally a HUGE bass boom. The trap clearly reduces the boom in the hallway and the first bedroom, but what effect does it have on the living room response??? It was supposed to help that by cancelling the boom which gets reflected back to the living room.
 |
| Above, but no E-Trap |
Well, strangely enought, the no E-Trap version perhaps looks better, though the depression IS extended higher up, it doesn't go as deep. Actually, it's not clear which is better, because the greater depression at 31 Hz probably isn't as audible as the broader depression going up to about 45 Hz with no E-Trap. I decided to leave the E-Trap on for now, because at least it removes the boom in the hallway, and reflected bass from the hallway probably isn't great even if it does make the RTA response look better.
I repeated these measurements (made with my iPhone stand adapter, same as last year's adjustments) and got identical results. It wasn't just random variation, the effect of the e-Trap on the RTA response is fully confirmed, it produces a deeper but less wide bass depression.
Either way, it looks like some fixing may already be required in the hot seat response, though it is still quite good.
Back at the loveseat, but using the hot seat EQ, things are much worse.
 |
| Back Wall, Hot Seat EQ |
Let's see how well my Movie EQ fixes this:
 |
| Back Wall, Movie EQ |
