Monday, February 3, 2020

Woofer Highpass Offset

One of the factors that must be considered in crossing over multiway speakers is the Woofer Highpass Offset.  I discovered this recently reading Linkwitz.

But I was also thinking about it wrong, or not as Linkwitz does.

I was thinking what needs to be compensated for is the 180 degrees of phase lead at the lowest frequencies near the lowpass of the woofer.

That's a huge amount of delay!!!  32 feet at 16 Hz for example.

Alternatively, I had thought of 180 degrees remaining constant to the crossover frequency, where it becomes a mere 5.5 ms.

Linkwitz looks at the change in delay with frequency (it is not constant).  For his example woofer, it drops to 23 degrees at 100 Hz, so we're down to about 1ms of delay (right in my typical adjustment range even not knowing about this source of delay).

So time alignment has to be done by audio measurement, not physical measurement or intuition.  (I wouldn't recommend listening at first either.  The "correct" value should be first be determined by valid measurements, and then fine tuned by ear.

I knew this was true, but thought the problem stemmed from different crossovers (it still may, if the crossovers are optimized for EQ).  Instead, the fundamental delay problem comes from drivers.  They have internal phase shifts.

Still, I wonder,  is the crossover frequency necessarily where the optimization needs be done?  If the woofer really were "leading" the tweeter, it seems that one might want to optimize the leading edge, the first contribution, the envelope delay to the leading edge of an impulse.

Contrarywise, the crossover is where the drivers have to be in phase, etc, for the crossover to work as desired, otherwise it will have various issues.

Now, it seems like the woofer can't actually lead the tweeter by as much as we've described in real time.  This phase lead must be slightly bogus somehow.  I'm thinking the phase "lead" is relative to the woofer's own high frequency response.

So what this means is that with any woofer, when set to optimize the crossover, there is going to be a leading low frequency pre-ring, representing the woofer's frequency differential phase.

I think I've seen that.  If aligned to the low frequency phase, there may be a  hole in the midbass.
I think I've seen that also.


Wednesday, January 29, 2020

eTrap working

Last year I moved the BagEnd eTrap from the living room to a hallway corner near the second bedroom.  In fact, I had originally purchased the eTrap for that corner, thinking a passive absorber would be unwieldly there, whereas I could use a passive absorber in the living room.  One thing was I wanted to reduce the incredible bass transmission into the second bedroom.  I've been trying to make the second bedroom liveable, and when I first got subwoofers, the bass level in the second bedroom might well be 20dB higher than at the listening position because of household resonances and couplings.  And with the hallway wall rattling also.  I then spent about $3000 rebuilding the hallway wall (it's now 5 layers thick, with the outer three layers "suspended") and $2500 on a sound resistant door.   I didn't realize this direct approach was going to cost so much, I had previously planned just to buy the $1599 eTrap.  Finding that even all the above didn't help, I bought an eTrap anyway, just for this corner, but I had originally deployed it to deal with issues in the living room itself which now seem lesser anyway, perhaps because of better EQ adjustments.

A few months ago I had just moved the eTrap to the corner where I had intended to put it all along, but didn't have time to adjust until I got home from vacation in December.  I've tried various things since then (trying to deal with a 100 Hz resonance for awhile, but that proved problematic).

But mainly I've had one (of two) electronic traps set basically as low as possible, with as high feedback as possible, on the grounds that it's hard to absorb low stuff, so the lower the better.

But I was noticing tonight that in the second bedroom, a decent amount of 63 Hz was getting through when I was playing Briza.  I kept playing that track and testing different settings.  Just a tiny bit higher seemed not only to suppress the 63 Hz much better, but make it almost impossible to follow the bass line in the second bedroom, whereas before it had been quite easy to follow the bass line even with the door closed.

Strangely I had only moved the control up just past the "34 Hz" setting.  Previously it had been turned much below that setting, as far down it would go (not marked).

It was also easy to see how much attenuation was occurring right in front of the eTrap using my RTA, and that it seemed to extend to 63 Hz with the current adjustment, whereas 63 Hz was not being attenuated with the previous adjustment.

This seems to suit the purpose intended now, though perhaps more precise optimization would be better, but it's far better at suppressing bass in the second bedroom than it was before, because that leakage bass is mostly in the 39-70 Hz range.

Also showing that the thing actually works.


Tuesday, January 28, 2020

PB13 Ultra Port Tuning

When I restarted the left sub last month, I wasn't sure whether to set the Port Tune to 16 Hz or 20 Hz. So, to be conservative, I chose 20 Hz.  I believed I had one port open.

After reading the manual online, I realized there are only three approved options:

1) Sealed (choose "Sealed" tuning)
2) Two ports open (choose 16 Hz)
3) All ports open (choose 20 Hz)

One port only causes chuffing, which I thought I heard a few days ago when sweeping the oscillator down low.

So, I took off the metal grill today, and discovered I DID have two ports open.  But I had chosen the now incorrect 20 Hz tuning, so I reset to that to the 16 Hz tuning.

That resulted in essentially flat response from 30 Hz to 20 Hz on my RTA, instead of a slight rolloff at  20 Hz when I was using the 20 Hz tuning.  I saw no other differences.

The speaker works flawlessly this way, but the room shakes badly if the level is loud enough.  The 20 Hz tuning might not be a bad idea anyway, and I might have chosen it before for that reason (to suppress room resonances around 20 Hz) but for now I'm going to try the flatter response, especially as I have now leveled the bass to the midrange level.

There seemed little difference in the stereo correlated response.

Bass candy recordings like Grouse and Bass Mechanic sounded better than ever.

LR4 in-polarity

I was obsessing over this last week.  It seemed to be then, and up until a few minutes ago, that while the Linkwitz-Riley LR4 crossover has both drivers in phase at the crossover frequency, because each has 180 degrees shift from opposite directions, as you move away from the crossover frequency, the phase would unwind in different directions, so they would not always be in-phase at every frequency.

This is wrong, I finally figured tonight.  First of all, Linkwitz says specifically that both drivers are always in phase for LR4.  At every frequency.  (And I should believe him, of course.)

Second of all, it is true, the driver phase either wind up more (as you attenuate) or unwind back to zero (as you increase to max).  However, when you are moving UP from the crossover frequency, this means the HP is "unwinding" and the LP is "more-winding", and the HP winds toward leading, and the LP winds toward lagging, so when one is winding and the other is unwinding they are actually moving in the same direction because they wind in different directions.

I used to think the polarity reversal on one side of an LR2 was the magic that made the in-phase-at-every-frequency work.  Because of that polarity reversal, I reasoned wrongly, the phases move in the same direction as you move away from the crossover point in either direction.  But that's just a compensation for the crossover frequency itself, and it doesn't change the way the phases on each driver change as you move away from the crossover point.

Along with all this, I believed there were "in-phase" connections of LR4 and "out-of-phase" connection of LR4 that would work even better because less group delay.  I read that somewhere about some crossover, but it was clearly not about LR4.  I believe another JAES author (Bullock?) wrote about a series of all pass crossovers.  Linkwitz himself stumbled upon another one (the Dueland) which might actually be better than LR4 because more gradual phase changes.

Somewhere I think I read about delaying the LR4 Highpass by "360 degrees" presumably at the crossover frequency, to account for the fact the leading vs lagging of the two drivers.  Now I can't seem to find that suggestion.  I didn't try that much seriously before (I tried going in that direction a bit, and results were weird enough to make me think about doing a more serious investigation).

Well if that works for LR4, what about doing LR2 using 180 degrees of delay, rather than an actual reversed polarity?

Sunday, January 26, 2020

Another Day, Too Many More Adjustments, Maybe

As I'm starting to write about the last measurement/adjustement/measurement/etc extravaganza I found myself locked into last week, I'm actually enjoying William Orbit, Strange Cargo II, largely helped by the dramatic increase in bass "dynamic range" because of the most recent set of adjustments, and other ones recently.

More and more I'm getting away from the "Room Curve" fudge, although I still leave some chocolate in places.

Exaggerated low frequencies are actually very problematical, for everyone!  The problem is, almost inevitably, regardless of much fretting to the contrary, the limit in how loud you can play is going to be in the bass.  That's where it gets distorted the fastest as you start cranking it up.  And with exaggerated bass, you can't even listen to the rest of the signal at a normal level, you have to turn everything down to accommodate the loud bass.  I've noticed that even recently on my bass torture test recordings like Bass Erotica.

Now, I did once use Rogers LS 3/5A, with a T27 tweeter, which can be blown, without too much effort.  That's when I went off the ranch and got a pair (and, in my dreams two dozen) Dynaudio D21AF tweeters, with 600W power handling capability and response to 40kHz.  I now use those as my living room supertweeters, along with the rest of the LS 3/5A box and unused Bextrene woofer, because building some other box will take a lot of time and effort.  I know they're good to 22kHz or so my phone shows me that, then apparently cuts off because of it's 48kHz sampling rate.  Those Dyanaudios haven't been made in decades and are hard to come by.  Newer Dynaudios, even the $1300 ones, aren't as flat at the super top end, I think mostly or entirely because they've scrapped the 21mm form and now make 28mm only.  Technical improvements may extend the 28mm tweeters to 40kHz but usually only 30kHz or so, and not as flat.

But in many if not most cases now, the practical limited of bassy recordings is in the bass, and hence the bass tuning, which I've recently lowered again (in a serious of adjustments, along with a slight rise in the right channel, which had itself been the subject of a forgotten experiment, as I think I may have written about a few installments ago).

Anyway, the new adjustments are sounding great.  I'm sure they could be better, I just had to stop somewhere.  I was losing track of how many different things I was doing, and thereby illustrating one of my own key weaknesses.  I may explore a lot of things, but in the end they may all get jumbled up, and with no rhyme or reason I may end up just cancelling the whole mess and starting over.  Or, nowadays, I can roll back to a previous set of settings, which is especially made more certain by taking pictures of them.  (I can save them too, but in my experience, I'd take a picture first, because going through the "saving" process and making one mistake can overwrite your settings, leaving  the latest discoveries lost to mind and history.)

I first started with strong wish to verify the goodness of the notch in the midrange at 119 Hz.  This seemed to curious raise the response in the right channel, by removing some cancellation effect I suppose.  On the left channel, it seemed to have no effect.  I needed to verify both of these claims to feel happy with a 119 Hz notch.

Sweeping was how I set the 119 Hz notch in the first place--that's how it sounds the smoothest and flattest (best of all at -15dB notch actually, but I waffled that down to -8dB originally).  In the right channel, listening with or without the subs.  Switching the notch in and out seemed to make no audible difference in the left channel, as if the panels were contributing nothing due to overdamping (however, I do not remember if I swept the left panels by themselves to test that).  This all fits my theory that the damping pad support is broken in the right speaker.  As a result, it generates a strong out-of-polarity resonance at 119 Hz from the damping pad vibrating backwards.  The right speaker may have a different problem, overdamping at 119 Hz.

And, perhaps even truer explanation, but my guess has been merely a coincidental effect, has been the room mode circa 119 Hz which causes maximum cancellation in the center of the room where the listening position is, and a slight augmentation at the backwall.

So I'm getting some loss at 119Hz at the listening position from multiple mechanisms, but both overall and in the right channel by itself, the 1/6 octave response is flatter with the 119 Hz notch.  (In the left channel by itself, it curiously makes no difference.)

I "proved" that, though what I've actually done is transfered the interpretation to the visual domain, rather than eliminate interpretation altogether.  Which is why I must show the graphs (even for myself--and I know I'm not trying to lie to myself--because I could have interpreted wrongly).

I've also proven that with sweeping, though I can't show that, it's just a memory, already becoming more uncertainly.  I believe I veried the "both channels at once" part (because I now always use the Y adapter with the oscillator so it drives both channels), I just switch the channels by changing their relative levels in the Tact "Level" menu.  I set the unwanted channel to -99.0dB.  But I'm not 100% sure, much like sometimes when I take my bedtime medicine without the daily pill box.

So that's the advantage with things like FFT.  Measurement tools that work over time and capture the result to a permanent form.  That used to mean paper but now electronic is preferred.   They can be checked and rechecked ad infinitum, with no disadvantage  in the future from when it happened, except that when it was happening you could have run a different measurement in some way, either to fix something or verify something else.

But that should not be confused with intrinsic accuracy, the radical accuracy of getting to the root of the resonant phenomenon, and cancelling it out with exactly the right Q and frequency response.

This is NOT AT ALL like adjusting the knobs in a graphic EQ to get flat response.  First of all it never works, and second of all it always makes some things worse (I conjecture, however I have only limited experience with such things myself).  What is bad is well corrected, and what was good is now awful.

In principle, the oscillator method and parametric EQ method I use is no different from what a program like REW does.  It does that thing of matching IIR filters to the most important anomalies in sequence, for as many parametric EQ's as your system supports.  What could be wrong with that?

What IS wrong with that, and in principle must be wrong with a system like that, is that a finite signal must be used.  With an oscillator, a virtually infinite signal is used.  This gets to the root of the resonance.

Well not so, one might argue, one isn't actually sweeping THAT slowly.  One may (and often does) hold a particular frequency for many seconds if not minutes...that is still not infinite.

Well many seconds at some particular frequency is Far and Away different from what any FFT system (that I am aware of) does.  The typical chirps, even 10 second scans, are nothing compared to holding one particular frequency for seconds.

And that's why system that can't seek can't get to the root of things.  It's not to say, exactly, that this couldn't be automated.  But FFT does not particularly help in some ways...it's by definition a finite system...

The human with an oscillator can sweep around looking for problems.  Problems are not usually hard to find when sweeping.  Usually, the first sweep shows how incredibly horrible things are, it's then just a matter of deciding which thing is worse (that is, of course, a subjective decision) and then correcting it with a parametric filter that cancels the problem a much as possible, and then deciding which is the next worse thing (another subjective decision).

The correcting part may involve VERY SLOW sweeping, and often sustained tones where deep resonances are found.  This is only feasible if someone or some thing has made the decision about what the anomalies are and which is the most important one FIRST.  THEN, it can be done, but with virtually infinite stimuli.

But still, you must rely on memory, of which I have little, and judgement, which is always in doubt, and it's nice to have pictures too.

Here's the picture of the correlated pink noise response without the notch.  Notice there is a severe depression around 120 Hz.  That depression is significantly larger than the depression around 55 Hz.  

Correlated response, No notch  added

With EQ, there is usually nothing I can do about depressions caused by model suckouts.  Those are only responsive to radical changes in listening position (say, from the middle of the room to the back wall) or sometimes other room alterations...dampening and absorbers to reduce standing waves at the modal frequency can sometimes curiously raise center-room response.  (Absorbing sound to prevent reflective cancellation which causes reduced sound elsewhere.)  Some of the depression around 110 Hz (actually, around 119 Hz) is caused by a modal suckout, which somehow applies especially strongly to the panels, less to the subs, the reverse of the usual thing.

Now curiously, while the response at the listening position is sucked out at 119 Hz, the sound between the panels and the subs is incredibly loud.  This is partly due to room position, but I began to suspect something different, and discovered that turning the panels off caused the response at 119 Hz to rise!

So, what if I could just cancel out the 119 Hz panel output in such a way as to reduce whatever is causing the panel operation to cancel the subs?  Of course I can with a notch filter, and I tuned a notch filter to flatten the output around 119 Hz when sweeping with an oscillator.  This was almost, but not quite, as narrow as I could make it.  (I first described this discovery in the last post, but I didn't have pictures yet):

Correlated response, -8dB notch added at 119 Hz

The depression around 110 Hz is visibly flattened, so now it is significantly less than the depression around 55 Hz.  I could have also shown (or at least recorded, as I didn't bother, but proves that non-graphic methods are possible if you record a boatload of data, as I never do) how the SPL response in the listening chair rose as the notch was increased to the full -15dB I have available.  However, the above is with a "compromise" conservative notch value of -8dB.  Without any notch, the response of the phone/spl meter in the listening position was at background level 24dB lower without any notch!  I felt this brought response to within 3dB of what was available at -15dB, without going all the way and suffering side effects that the steeper notch might have.  But if I had been optimizing the measurements, including the graph, I would have gone for the full -15dB notch.

Now, one could argue, this was just a random chance, that the notch performance looked different.  So I did a second measurement, which has the same visible characteristics regarding the 119 Hz depression.  It is less than without the notch.

Correlated response with -8dB notch, repeated

This visibly proving the curious effect that a notch (in the panel output only) is increasing output.

Now it was clear to me that the response in the notched channel itself was much better with the notch, so I didn't graph that.  But what about the response in the alternate channel.  Would that now get much worse with a notch it didn't need?

The answer was, as I reported in the last post, the response with and without the notch in the other channel was identical.  In either case, the response is sucked out around 110 Hz.  The notch appears to change the already suckout at "110 Hz" (actually 119 Hz) in this channel by a mere 0.1dB.  As if all the significant output of the left channel at 110 Hz is coming from the sub anyway, so the notch essentially has no effect here, while it is extremely beneficial in the other channel.

Left Channel, with -8dB Notch
Left Channel, No added 119 Hz notch
Sweeping didn't reveal any finer detail than this, both just seemed to have an identical suckout around 119 Hz.

With the previous days labors now verified by graphical means, I proceeded to make some more changes, that also looked and swept good.  First of all, emboldened by the null effect of the -8dB notch at 119 Hz, I went ahead and increased it to a -12dB notch, which continued to flatten the right and combined responses with no effect on the right channel, it appeared.

To the left channel, I tried to suppres the circa 80 Hz peak better, as well and flatten the curve around 32 Hz.  I added an 80 Hz notch (or did I do that last time) and made tiny changes to the existing notches and then ultimately added a low Q 28 Hz notch which was not so much a tuning of the existing resonance as a tuning of the ultimate desired response, sounding nice all the way down to 16 Hz.  Otherwise, the left sub might need some port retuning, I need to look into that.

This is the resulting left channel response afte the latest adjustments:

Left Channel, after latest adjustments

Notice the short but slightly tilted window all the response falls within, including the bulge around 32 Hz, and the narrow depression around 110 Hz.

The stereo corelated response also looked a bit better, now with a similar short window of response.


Here are the latest adjustments which accomplish this visible and sonic magic














Wednesday, January 22, 2020

Subtracting to Add

I happened to come across an RCA Y adapter laying on top of the living room power conditioner as I was cleaning the right subwoofer and environs on Tuesday.  I was carefully vacuuming cobwebs and dust bunnies from between the woofer and the metal subwoofer grille, then I used a dry microfiber cloth to lightly brush off the remaining dust from the SVS woofer cone which appears to be covered in a felt-like substance (I think it might be a metal cone also).  I'm not sure if water could be used for this cleaning or not, or even if microfiber is all that safe, but I hoped it would be ok for a light dusting.  I was puzzling the 120 Hz "notch" which actually seemed to have a strong buzzing quality, even more like a strong modal resonance in the alcove between the back of the right Acoustat 2+2 and the right SVS PB13 Ultra.  I was also neatening the junk on top of the power conditioner in that area.  My cleaning did seem to help the buzzing, actually, but not eliminate it, and I think I'm going to have to remove the now heavily damped metal fireplace and rebuild the front wall to fix it, something I've been thinking about doing for years (but where to move the stereo in the meantime???  The organ and junk had to be removed from the Gym, to permit the Gym to be used as temporary holding space for the living room stereo.  The old organ and junk were finally removed last year, after 6 years of procrastination.)

I must have put that Y adapter there precisely for use with the oscillator, for stereo sweeping, which I had not done yet.  Ahah, one more kind of sweeping I can do!  I figured right away that as soon as I started stereo sweeping I'd identify issues that required mono sweeping again.  I was right.

Immediately I was back examining the 120 Hz suckout in the right channel.  It was quite noticeable in stereo (as in the stereo correlated pink noise response).  But then I also noticed that the bass was seeming quite light.  Had the subwoofers died?  Ooops, I had the subwoofer EQ turned to a different input, which is my tricky way of turning the subs off for testing the panels by themselves, which I must have been doing the day before.  But since then I'd spent a day or so listening to Marie-Claire Allain play the Complete Bach Organ Works, in background mostly, and marveling how good it sounded.  With no subwoofer and the panels rolled off at 100 Hz.  We audiophiles make these mistakes all the time, and in my case I'm all for pointing it out how unreliable our hearing is that major issues can go unnoticed for days (weeks, years, or even decades, I can show in my own amazing audiophile history), while we nit pick over small stuff that may be essentially impossible to hear.

With the subwoofers back on, it was now clear that the subs didn't suck out as much as the panels.  Something weird seems to be going on in and in back of the right panel at 119 Hz.  It's buzzy and loud, and apparently phase reversed from the subs.  If the subs are on without the panels, and then I turn the panels on, the level of 120 Hz at the listening position goes down to nothing, over 20dB down.  Maybe 30dB.  Now that's cancellation!

I could (and did try) to fix the problem by boosting the subs at 119 Hz.  But that didn't go so far, and made nodal resonances at other points in the room, such as in the doorway to the kitchen (where 119 Hz gets VERY loud) even louder, by the same amount as the boost (or seemingly more).

But what actually seemed MORE effective, was notching out the panels at 119 Hz.  And curiously the more I notched out 119 Hz in the panels the louder it became at the listening position, apparently because of reducing the cancellation of the more effective subwoofer drive.  It also seemed to reduce the buzzing, as if I was suppressing an anti-phase resonance in the panels (that's not my theory, exactly, but there may be some issue like that involved).

Dialing in the full -15dB available in a 1/10 octave notch at 119 Hz reduced the 30dB of cancellation to a mere 3dB of cancellation.  And it didn't seem noticeable when sweeping the speaker.  Weird stuff goes on at 119 Hz in any case, but with the -15dB notch it sounded only better than at lesser levels, not worse.

Still, I'm disinclined to apply such radical EQ.  I looked for the level where I'd get "most of the benefit" without having to go all the way.  And I found I could get within 3dB of the best available performance (at -15dB) with a mere -8dB, so I decided to go with that.

This is very strange.  I'm fixing a suckout at 119 Hz in the right channel by appling a notch of -8dB at 119 Hz to the right channel panels.  Strange but it seems to work and I get even better elimination of the notch with -15dB.

There is obviously something (or many somethings) very weird going on here, possibly including the acoustic crossover not matching Linkwitz-Riley LR4 alignment very well because of driver resonances AND other EQ corrections!  Also imperfect time alignment.

LR4 itself is a little weird.  It's not as "perfect" as LR2 perhaps, though it doesn't require polarity inversion on one side.  LR4 is strange because you can use it either with or without polarity inversion.  I think I like it better without the inversion, and it's one of the reasons I like LR4 (no polarity inversion required).  But Linkwitz liked it better WITH the polarity inversion, because it has less group delay that way.  Hmmn.  I have always wondered if no-inversion LR4 has regions where the drivers are not always in-polarity as they are with LR2 at ALL Frequencies.  At distant extremes, the drivers are in polarity, but near the crossover the relative phase twists around in opposite directions for each driver, further complicated by non-coincidence and non-uniformity-of-radiation.

These issues are worthy of serious investigation!  However, for now, I'm using the -8dB notch on the panels, which increases the near total suckout at 119 Hz at the listening position to a fluctuation.

Sadly, I do not believe I can add this -8dB notch merely to the right panels in my current configuration, which is stereo-linked for the panels.  I'm not sure I need to do stereo-linked anyway, but it has always seemed convenient for adjusting the panel issues, which aren't as position dependant.  There had not appeared to be a serious suckout in the left channel at 119 Hz that I remembered.  For now, I swept the left channel with the -8dB notch in place and surprisingly it sounded fine.  Perhaps the notch makes it better too.  Obviously I should re-check this also.

And I should remember I'm applying such a hack and re-check if it continues to help after future changes and adjustments.

I ought to try LR4 with polarity inversion.  I don't recall even trying it, I just didn't like the idea of polarity inversion.  But it seems to me now that only LR4 with polarity inversion yields the central benefit as LR2 which must have a polarity inverted...both sides remain in polarity at all times.  Without that critical inversion, the relative phases must be twisting around, and frankly right now I can't even fathom how it's even supposed to add up to flat response.

Perhaps much of the last 10 years of fiddling with EQ's around 100 Hz is largely to compensate for using a defective crossover alignment...

Using the Y adapter is nice, because I can switch channels using the remote (through the Tact Level Menu, reducing alternate channels to -99.9db) and compare channels.  It was clear the right channel was somewhat lacking around 32 Hz, as I remembered.  All the boost shown in the stereo response graphs was from the left channel response nearly exploding around 32 Hz and down to below 20 Hz, and not sounding all that good either.  I dialed in a -4dB 3/4 octave valley around 28 Hz to tamp this down.  It could be tamped down more.  This allowed me to reduce the notch at 40 Hz to -5dB.

More issues in this channel as well.  Is the subwoofer tuning EQ correct for the current one-port-open?  Is one-port-open a good idea in this channel?  I already went to sealed in the other channel, but I sorta liked the combination of the two in different channels.  I thought I liked the left channel often filling in extra whoomph otherwise unavailable from the sealed configuration.  Was I mistaken about the effect of that overall?

I'm noticing a lot more whoomp in recordings like Grouse We want to be loved.  How much this is due to the very last change, the 119 Hz notch which seems to boost overall response, I don't actually know, but it made me decide to increase that notch to -12dB (I know it continues to measure better, in the right channel at least, all the way out to -15dB, and that gives the flattest listening position response to 119 Hz, only about 3dB below baseline, which is what you get cancelling out one part of the signal--the panels--and leave the remainder).

In addition to a curious property of the in-polarity LR4 connection, another concern is the damping in the back of the Acoutstat panels, which sometimes becomes loose with age.  That could be the very element which begins to vibrate out-of-polarity at 119 Hz because of a resonance at precisely that frequency in the panels themselves.  Chalk this up as one prototype theory in which a panel notch at 120 Hz improves the response greatly at that frequency, at least in the right channel.

It may in fact be that resonance at 119 Hz and/or others is partly reponsible for the rattling/grating side I hear mostly in the back of the panel on certain pieces of music, notably a track from Grouse.  I can eliminate that rattling with a wide notch of 1 octave centered at 250 Hz, or better yet with -15dB sliders from 120Hz to 630Hz, possibly with some middle sliders back at zero.  The rattling is inconsistent and history dependent, making it hard to figure exactly.  But some reduction at 120 Hz always seems necessary, and I'm now already reducing the panel response by -12dB by default, which may reduct the rattling somewhat by default.

Sadly oscillator sweeping has not yet revealed a single frequency for the rattling, which sounds like the rattling of stator wires, possibly because an attachment has come loose.







Monday, January 20, 2020

Back to Square One

I couldn't let it go.  I got back to sweeping the oscillator, which now makes it clear that the 120 Hz depression is still there (despite my having eliminated the nearly useless 140 Hz notch in the subwoofer drive).  I may have made it better but it's still almost as noticeable when sweeping.

Curiously, the 120 Hz depression appears in both the subwoofer response AND the panel response, and it exists only or primarily at the center of the room where the listening position is.  So it's a modal depression that's stimulated by a tall dipole as well as a floor hugging monopole.  Dipoles manage to avoid or at least mitigate most room modes, but curiously not this one, it seems just as bad in either response.  I think, however, it might be coincidental that the dipole-backwall cancellation happens at the same frequency as a room mode.  So it's possible there are different causes for the 120 Hz depression in the dipole response from the subwoofer response.  But the fact that a depression happens in both means I can't boost either one to correct the other.  This problem is NOT correctible by EQ.  Fortunately it doesn't actually seem that large.  It's very localized around 120 Hz and unless I'm sweeping slowly I might not notice it at all (which is why, on the first night, I didn't notice it at times in either panel or sub responses, but actually it's in both).

The "1 kHz suckout" that appears in the right channel  RTA graph seems non-existant in oscillator sweeping.  Response seems audible flat from 250-2.5kHz, and on up through 15kHz where my hearing cuts off.  My system response (as measured by phone) seems to cut off about 22kHz.  That possibly shows the phone is sampling at 48kHz.

I also cancelled the first 100 Hz notch filter in the right subwoofer drive.  I appear to have had broad and narrow notches at 100 Hz, with the broad 1/2 octave notch intended to smooth the broad area around 100 Hz, but that makes the 120 Hz depression worse also.  I do in fact need a deep narrow notch just at 100 Hz but not much higher.

System response may now be about as decent as I can get it with sweeping and a handful of parametric EQ's.  It's probably time to move on to time alignment tests.

One exception is I might see what happens if I eliminate the 32 Hz bulge.  I didn't have that "problem" with the 1+1 speakers, even though in both cases the panels are crossed over at 100 Hz.  It may partly be because I've gotten more agressive with resonances in the 70-100 Hz region.  I used to excuse those as "room curve" but then it seemed like the bass got much cleaner if I eliminated the resonances underneath that curve.  In effect, I've whittled my way back to the bottom of the frequency response curve making it flat, where superficially the added boost remaining may seem helpful but may not be helpful with all music.

It sounded just fine playing the complete organ works of JS Bach played by Marie-Claire Allain today.