Sunday, May 14, 2017

How I learned to stop worrying and love digital gain

Sometimes, digital sources need to have their volume raised.  This may be less true if you simply have a transport sending digital to a DAC.  But once you have fancy multi-way and multiroom systems combining equipment from many rooms, and analog sampling locked and now unlocked formats from classic drives (I don't know why, but resampling the analog outputs to 24/96 always sounds better than taking the digital stream off the device, even though it goes into a digital connection either way), you often need to do a little boosting, sometimes just to restore original recorded levels, or in the case of home made recordings from analog sources especially, to exceed them a little bit.

But once I begin cranking the digital volume control above unit gain, 0dB, which on the Tact is 93.9, I get a little worried that digital clipping might occur.  This would occur if the digital signal sent from the Tact onward to the DSP processors reaches the clipping point, which is 0dB.  Beyond that point, I didn't know what was going to happen.  Perhaps dropouts from a validity bit being set.  These dropouts could be far more annoying than typical analog clipping, even on a solid state amplifier (and the "sound" of solid state clipping has been rarely heard or correctly described...in a well designed Class AB amplifier it will not be spitting or overly harsh...just a growing soft harshness.  Anyway, not knowing the effect of digital clipping, it might even be some terrible out of band spiking, for example, of the kind that nearly fried my ribbon tweeters when connected to a 250 Amp (that was actually using the 10V RMS analog outputs of a DCX crossover, but the reason why it was outputting so much in the first place I don't remember and feared was in the digital domain).

But anyway, I didn't really know, because I had never tested it well.  And I had another related issue.  Some months ago I discovered Sonos was boosting volume levels so that "max" now had +8dB digital gain, causing premature clipping.  Perhaps this would not affect people using the analog outputs or something, I don't know, but it seemed a misfeature to me.  I took the precaution thenceforth from keeping all Sonos level at -8dB, which seemed to be the new unity gain.  Even fixed output setting seemed to have boost.  Well some time ago I wasn't sure it was still like this...volume levels were seeming softer than before.  I needed to retest.

I'm happy to say that as of today, my Sonos system passes closest to unity gain turned all-the-way up, and on the fixed setting.  It doesn't add extra boost, just the real deal...well almost.  It seems, according to my test, that a 0dB SPL signal is reduced to -1.3dB.  I'm not sure why that is, but 1.3dB of loss of dynamic range is not a huge concern, ,just a minor gripe really, but if I could have my pony I'd have full bit transparency, which I thought Sonos used to have back in the day.  I could be wrong but multiple tests showed the -1.3dB loss with Sonos "fixed" setting (I've set several back to fixed now, no need to keep fiddling to find the most transparent point) on my Behringer DEQ meter, ,and I needed to crank the Tact up to 1.3dB to reach the highest unclipped point, with clipping starting at +1.4dB but barely visible, and so on, at the output of my DAC, which I believe to be faithfully reproducing what it receives from the DEQ, and comparing that with the Triumph analysis of the WAV file.

Anyway, boosted back to normal and fixed, Sonos is now sounding good again.  That's at least two major advances in the past few days since my return from vacation, the first being un-attenuating the Sony 9000ES.

Cranking up the Tact beyond the transposed clipping point at +1.3dB, it simply clipped the voltage rise at that point, flat, pretty much like a transistor amp, with no artifacts at all.  And that continued as I drove it into "hard" clipping, it just made the wave slopes steeper, meeting a flat top at the same point, as I had speculated earlier, boosting the RMS voltage but not actually raising the peak voltage.

Through any of my DEQ units, the clipping would show the effect of the EQ on the waveform as it clipped, looking a it more curvey for example, but still not too bad at all.

Now, sending an unclipped signal at 0dB into a DEQ unit, and then attempting to clip it within the DSP program had a different effect.  Clipping through the DEQ resulted in a compressed output that showed no sign of clipping, just no increase in size.  I'm a bit worried about this, perhaps on real music it would cause peculiar effects more annoying than the slight harshness of peak clipping.  Or perhaps not.  But either way it didn't look any more scary and probably less scary than analog clipping.

So while you can argue that cranking up the digital volume should not be much necessary, better to have the source material reaching peak 0dB or close to it to preserve resolution.  But when you need to crank up the volume, doing so with digital gain isn't any more dangerous than doing it in the analog domain, and probably safer, with regards to level changes that may later cause clipping.

This adds to the case for mapping the output of a DAC driving the amplfier to have exactly the output required to drive that amplifier to clipping, or slightly more, rather than 6dB more or so.  The added affects of digital and analog clipping around the same point should not be bad, if very rarely reached. As I have previously argued, this preserves the dynamic range and resolution better at every level.

Similarly, I've now concluded that adding boost in the DEQ's, all of the DEQ's, not just to compensate but to create more digital gain, is not a good idea, as it shortens the actual digital mapping space just like having a DAC with too much output.  The best gain setting on any digital device is 0dB or as close to it as possible, to preserve dynamic range and resolution.

Pictures later.



Saturday, May 13, 2017

Playing Loud Enough: The DAC story

Immersed in an overwhelming sea of auditory information, I spin tales about my "force of nature" audio system, then whip out my phone to measure it, and it's showing only 65dB. What???  "Loud" should be 100dB, or at least 90.

Firstly, I must always remember to set meter for "C" weighting when measuring loud.  When the level is cranked up, we don't need the audibility curves of the "A" weighting.  When set to C weighting, my measurement goes up to 75dB.  OK, when the ambient noise is as low (around 10dBA) as it gets at my house at night, 75dB average music power can be enveloping.

Second, I can easily crank the level up to 85dBC peaks.  Beyond that, I sometimes have to use the digital gain of my digital preamp, which increases the digital signal above what the preamp is given (just by multiplying the numbers by some factor and dithering...).

Because I fear digital clipping worse than analog clipping, which I probably shouldn't, I have been scared to use digital gain (which might cause clipping later when the music gets louder) more than excess analog gain which many systems naturally have.

The way I stream (through Sonos, which has digital volume control, which has sometimes been turned down slightly) and digitally resample all other sources means that peak levels in the digital signals reaching my preamp are usually well below 0dB even at peak levels, so they can harmlessly be boosted back up, as long as it isn't done too far.

But also, hidden digital volume controls should generally be set to unity gain (which is often, but not always, maximum) and maybe I have to adjust my resampling.  I've been studying my resampling for the past few weeks.  It seems I can set the Lavry AD10 to maximum gain on all normal CD sources, played on the Denon DVD-9000, the Onkyo RDV-1, or the Sony 9000ES, without clipping the Lavry.  In fact it seems to leave about 4dB or so of additional headroom above the nominal 2V outputs (I haven't actually measured them, but digital sources described as "2V" typically put out 2.15 or even 2.2V).  When I'm playing HDCD's on the Denon, I need to make the Lavry less sensitive to allow for a 6dB higher level.  I've taken to the idea of adjusting the Lavry to max gain when that is permissible both to get the highest level and the best sampling (though some earlier ad hoc findings suggested it was better set to somewhat lower gain than needed for greater headroom but I now know all my players already allow about 4dB headroom at max gain when only playing CD's.  It was measuring CD output that I discovered the 9000ES was 10dB down, which couldn't be right, and then I discovered the Audio Menu in which the Audio Att had been turned on.  I wasted no time in turning it off (which is the recommended and supposedly default position).  This has radically changed my ideas about the 9000ES as a CD player: it's a wimp no more.

I also got to thinking about how playing through a DAC reduces my possible level.  My Audio GD Dac 19 puts out 2.5V, which is more than the usual 2V for a single ended DAC, but that still isn't high enough to drive the Krell FPB 300 to maximum power, even though the rated sensitivity of the Krell is 2.35V (for 300W output).

This week I finally sat down to figure out how much DAC output would be sufficient.  Basically you want to reach the "peak continuous" power of the amplifier, or in other words the peak power specified as if it were continuous (RMS).  Handily Krell specifies this for the FPB amplifiers as "RMS Output Voltage," which is 60V for the FPB 300.  That corresponds to an RMS power of 450W (60*60/8.0) into 8 ohms.  This has come up in reviews as the clipping power of the Krell, Martin Colloms measured 470W into 7.5 ohms (slightly higher because it's 7.5 ohms and not 8).

There are several reasons why the clipping power is greater than the rated power.  For one, the Krell specification is conservative, all new and older units should be able to reach the rated power with some margin.  For another, the rated power is at a specified low value of distortion, "clipping" is sometimes (e.g. Stereophile) defined as the onset of 1% THD.  And for another, the unit might not be able to sustain the clipping power for long because of thermal or power supply considerations.

In fact it is only because the Krell has a regulated power supply that the Peak Voltage and Clipping Power line up so nicely.  With unregulated power, the peak voltage might be considerably higher than even the continuous power for for than a cycle or two.  For unregulated designs you might not be able to measure the peak continuous power at all, you would measure the actual peak and divide by 1.41, or you might take the rail voltage and subtract minimum junction voltage drops.

Anyway, when a DAC or preamplifier is driving a power amplifier, if reaching maximum loudness is desired, you must provide the input necessary to reach the "RMS Output Voltage" and not merely the rated power.  This specification, which might be called maximum effective input voltage, can be computed in various ways, such as by the ratio of "rated power" and "peak continuous power" and the rated input sensitivity:

Sr(V) * sqrt ( Pcp(W) / Pr )

2.35 * sqrt ( 450 / 300 )

2.87 V

So *that* is the voltage the preamp must produce to drive the power amplifier to it's actual maximum.  Anything less is robbing me of potential peak power, the ultimate peaks which are the stuff of music.

The 2.5 Volt output of my Audio GD Dac 19 comes close, but not quite.

Meanwhile, there is also too much of this driving voltage thing.  Especially with a DAC, if the DAC voltage ranges from 0-5V and the amplifier rnages from 0-3V, the last 2V, which represents 40% of the coding or mapping space, is lost to technically useless headroom.  So the resolution in the lower 60% is now diluted by exactly that much.  Another way of looking at this is in the dynamic range.  If the top 4dB is wasted, that means the relative ultimate noise level is now increased by 4dB.  But this doesn't only matter if you're playing at such a low level, the resolution is lost at every volume and appears as added noise (so low it's never noticed directly).

You could argue this dilution always occurs, even when you are simply digitally attenuating.  As it turns out, both analog and digital attenuators lose resolution, and about by the same degree.

Anyway, when the noise level is -120dB, and you're reducing it to -116, well you'd hardly notice.  Believe me I used resolution reducing (and noise increasing) digital attenuation destructive in my early years of digital EQ, causing far more loss than this, and didn't notice until I stopped to think about it.

I think most people with hybrid analog/digital don't think about it probably enough.  Surely I haven't at times.  Now you might say, I'm over obsessed about it.

Anyway, I though very much about it this week.  Thinking the desired voltage to be about 3V, my mere 2.5V was missing the mark by a crucial 1.5ddB, the difference between say, 340W and 450W, the ultimate peak power of the amplifier.  I pay big bucks for an an amplifier with all that peak power, the stuff of music, and then just throw a bunch of it away.

Got to fix this problem, I said.  I could get a quality preamp to follow the output of the Audio GD DAC 19, and boost it to 3V RMS.  I could get a used KRC, for example, and have it drive the Krell balanced from the single ended output of the DAC.  That's about the minimum quality of device I would consider.

Now this might be worth considering in a 1-way system.  Then I could use analog volume instead of digital volume.  Arguable analog volume is better, though digital volume has lower noise, typically -144dB since digital volume is done on 24bit number (using even higher bit math with dithering).

But in a multiway system like mine, the remote volume would be useless.  I would nearly set the preamp to the required gain of 1.5dB and leave it there.

It took barely a moments thought to feel how monsterous it would be to add all this complexity just to get 1.5 dB more output.  I'm not that big on simplicity, but this seemed monsterous.  Then, I could build a canonical OPA 211 based buffer, but the work is still unimaginable to me, making boards and doing the fine soldering, and it would all have to be to the highest standards to be good enough, including the separate power supply.

This crystallized with something else, and the next thing was I'd done something barely thinkable, I'd order a multi kilobuck DAC.

The other thing was I was testing the output levels of all my disc players through the Lavry.  The best way to make the measurement of output is by reading the "Peak" level meters of the downstream midrange DEQ reading input digital level.  I found one of the highest peak levels I'd ever seen playing the Reference Recordings disc RR-82, with Mephisto and other, on the Denon DVD-9000 with HDCD.  Track 9 has the highest level seen.  I had to set the level on the Lavry to -9dB (the level for CD's is the max gain level -13dB, which is 4dB more sensitive).  This ultimately left me with 0.3dB headroom, as determined by subtracting the -2.0 digital gain on the Tact (tact level 91.8) from the -2.3 dB peak reading in the Right channel (the other channel read -2.7dB).

Playing the disc on the Onkyo, which has no HDCD decoding, yielded -7.1dB and -6.9dB peaks, back to standard CD level and even that the Onkyo plays about a dB lower than the Denon.

In further testing, the un-attenuated Sony 9000ES appears to have the identical output levels, within 0.1dB, on regular CD's as the Denon.  The Onkyo has about 1dB less output.

In playing several CD tracks on all players in a row for doing peak level tests, I quickly had a favorite: the Denon DVD-9000.  In its new un-attenuated form, the Sony 9000ES is #2, and the Onkyo--my heretofore standard on all the things it plays--ranked 3rd.  Of course I made no attempt to equalize the 1dB lack of volume from the Onkyo, so this "finding" is as suspect as anything, let alone the fact that most listening was done from the floor as I was reading the peak levels.

Anyway, I concluded, and combined with previous knowledge, that differential 1704's are far better than single ended 1704's for digital conversion.  The Denon has differential 1704's, and that may help make for the smoother sound, silky smooth, compared to the fine stainless steel granularity of the Onkyo.  I know that the Burr Brown PCM 1704's are not perfect, though they are the best ever implementation of 24 bits of R2R non-feedback PCM conversion.  They are not the most glitch free, the never ending popularity of the original digital chips, the Phillips 1571A, stems in large part from their relative absense of glitches.  Anyway the 1704's shine in differential and dual differential implementation where the glitching mostly cancels out.  That is seen in all the big league units, not just my rarity DVD-9000 but in the best Levinsons like the 360S, the 30.6, and so on.  I looked at those briefly, the more common 30.5 uses the earlier 1702 chips which some preferred but are only 20 bit chips.  I'd consider those.

Well this brought me back to how much I would prefer to have the top Audio GD DAC, the Master 7.  It has the ultimately perfected dual differential 1704 implementation.

Designer Kingwa of Audio GD is one of the great audio designers, up there with Curl and Pass.  Sure, he's a self promoter, a cult of personality, a huckster, but they all are.  Like the good ones, though, he seems to do the hard work.  He uses good stuff, and puts it together to achieve the very best results, with maniacal attention to details and the perfection of each part of the circuitry as well as how they all work together.

Because of how he attends to the details of how well his circuits actually work, rather than just slopping something together that barely works (such products used to be legion) he gets to the maximum linearity achievable, so so latest Master 7 DAC is rated as 0.00005% distortion and he shows the spectrum.  At first I was put off by the obvious -110dB peaks.  But -110dB is 0.000003%, more than 10 times less than the 0.00005% specification.  And he does this with no feedback, no capacitors, direct coupled discrete fets and possibly more regulated power supplies than Levinson, at a somewhat attainable (gasp) cost.

By comparison, the PS Audio DirectStream DAC (which might have some merit...I currently hold the idea that true one bit conversion, highly oversampled, has better sonics than delta sigma) is only specified as 0.03% distortion.  Sad to say, that looks like lazy engineering (though it could also be very conservative specsmanship, in the day an age when subjectophiles believe the higher the distortion the better).  And we're up to the big bucks, paupers need not apply, if not even close to the swiss or german prices.

The actual only other possible choice to me was the Schitt Yggdragasil, which uses modern PCM DAC's in a proprietary "closed loop" solution--ultimate performance though advance calculation rather than sigma delta feedback.  That has always appealed to me, and may be actually better or worse, I don't know, but Stereophile something that looked like digital-related distortion and was unwilling to specify the "effective bits", and the AD chips *are* only 21 bits, not the 24 bits of the legendary 1704.  There's a long argument here, but I believe if the "bit loss" is merely thermal, or sufficiently random, or whatever, it doesn't count as badly as not trying to approximate the bits at all.  This is related to my view of noise and resolution as being somewhat different things, ultimately.  So it counts to go after the 24 bit resolution even if you don't achieve it.  So I've had a strong leaning toward the actual 1704 products like the historic Levinson DACs.

But putting all these considerations together, the solution was clear for once.  I should finally order the Master 7, which I'd long desired, and have it modified for a 0-3V range instead of the 0-5 normal production.  If I can even still get a Master 7.  It has almost seemed every year Kingwa says there will be no more, and I believed him years ago.

This had become a much more important track to future progress than buying a mega expensive preamp, which had been one of my hopes for this year, something like a Levinson 326S, or a 32, or, just for starters, a Krell KRC 3, to boost the DAC output, or boost the CD player inputs (this seemed more crucial before I turned off the attenuator on the 9000ES).  I'd be getting the much improved dual differential 1704 configureation, and true balanced outputs which work best with my Krell FPB which has true balanced circuitry throughout and benefits circuit-wise from balanced connection above and beyond the benefits of balance on lower random noise induction and AC chassis ground differences--a not inconsiderably consideration since the Krell is plugged straight into the wall whereas the DAC is plugged into a special strip plugged into the power conditioner.  Balanced connection means the ground differences virtually don't matter.  It's a wonder things have been working so well unbalanced!  I shoulda swung for balanced in the first place (though, for what it matters when I got the Audio GD DAC 19 I was using the Aragon amp, which doesn't have a true balanced input only a virtual balanced adapter to a single input.  That doesn't really gain an advantage from balanced input in any way.

I checked the website, and saw it's now the new Master 7 Singularity, which Kingwa mightily emphasizes is the ultimate end of the 1704's, the last 100 units can be made and that is it.  It's supposed to be even better than all the previous Master 7's, especially in the new digital, but I'm not sure when or if I'm ever going to be able to use I2S and likewise even USB.  An AES connection, my first choice requirement (I was using an AES to coax converter with my DAC 19) is $15 extra.

I sent of the email, requesting my desired output voltage.  I doubted this was possible, thinking the Master 7's already all made by now if not spoken for, there might not be any such choice, and the options page didn't suggest any such thing.  I was thinking to myself, I really set myself up, if the reply is they will do this I will go ahead, this being my last chance most likely to get DAC with the correct custom output voltage range, and dual differential 1704's as well, and top performing in every way.

It didn't take long, and it doesn't even seem like I'm paying anything for the voltage change.

Well this was a lot of money to swing, for me the guy who not just a few years ago was saying DAC's don't matter much.  So I've had a lot to chew on, for the day before making the order I was in a near panic trying to ensure my custom voltage range idea was actually a good idea.  And I was worried sick for several days after that it wasn't, or perhaps I should have specified 3.3V or 4V and so on.  (4V was the balanced output of the historic Levinson DAC's I've lusted for, PS Audio offers 3.15V and 5.3V.  The loudest DACs will almost certainly in many cases be judged the best, so everyone makes theirs a tad louder than the previous crop, not for the best reasons perhaps.)

The "wasted" extra headroom of a DAC isn't entirely wasted if it allows the user to get additional useful gain they otherwise wouldn't get.  But I am not such a person, I have at least 6.1dB of available digital gain through my Tact digital preamp.  I also have also been ignoring the up to 15 dB of digital gain available through my Behringer DEQ units used as crossovers and shapers.  Though I've actually already been using some of that, +7dB in the supertweeter unit, so there is actually "only" 8dB of additional digital gain available.

I've only been fearful of using too much digital gain.  When that hits, I worry about digital harmonics being generated, huge horrible clipping noises and so on, the native clipping might be tiddlywinks in comparison.  I don't know...and that's still exactly the problem!  I should find out exactly how bad digital clipping is, anyway, since it's so easily attainable (and attenuate the levels so as not to produce amplifier clipping...which is more frightening for doing tests on, particularly when you have an amp rated for 1600W of power delivery).

My first brush is that it may not be bad at all.  It was, after all, way overvoltages (the 10V output of the DCX driving a 250W amplifier driving the Elacs) that nearly fried my ribbons.  It was not, I don't think, digital clipping as such.

Anyway, I also needed to be sure, right away, that 2.5V was a true RMS voltage.  It was, in fact my measurement was that it was putting out 2.67V RMS for a 0dB signal...ah yes the slight boost over 2.5V "nominal" it always seems to go that way, and to be fair when they say 2.5V that's a value they intend to reach even under cold temperature, etc.).

But then that raises multiple questions about a simple "3V output" specification...and the very first being...why buy a new DAC at all!!!  With 2.67 I was already getting very close to the 2.87 I calculated I might actually need.  When I was putting the issue as "2.5 vs 3.0" it was 1.56dB difference, not inconsiderable.  But the difference of 2.67 to 2.87 is a mere 0.62dB.  Is that worth paying thousands of dollars for?

But: the balanced outputs I needed from the beginning, the dual differential 1704's are needed, the balanced AES input nice too.  This is, as I said, getting late in the game to get a machine like this new from the manufacturer to custom spec.

OK, then, if one really needed a boost so much, it must have been more than needing the last 0.62dB. It must have been the lazy analog gain of driving the amp with higher output, as I was doing with the old 10V RMS output DCX units before I started using 1704 based DAC's.  That makes it easy to get high output, it requires lots and lots of attenuation, like running the Tact it the "70s" range, to get normal levels.  I used to do that, throwing resolution to the wind.

But 5V is long around the 4V, or 3.5V or whatever I figured would be optimum.  I never before did the actual calculation.  And honestly the calculation might be wrong...but it could be wrong either way.  But say I could use more output to raise the voltage somewhat if with, say, less than 10% distortion?  Should I do that?

It's a tough call.  I do wonder if I might do better with 3.3V or 3.2V than the 3V I asked for.  Though it now looks like I'll probably get around 3.2V measured due to the nominal thing I discussed before. It's almost certainly not going to be less than 3V under any circumstances.  Distortion is at least audibly going to be kicking in about then.

I was actually going to ask for 3.2V...though figuring I'd get about that anyway.  But then, at the last minute, seeing the 3V nicely printed up on the invoice, I decided to just go with that.  I think I'm right up there with the peak output of the amp, might be some benefit from being able to go a little further to 10% distortion perhaps, and not much resolution wasted to worry about.  It's often said that it's the onset of analog distortion that makes people think things are too loud, or maybe even just "loud enough."  That's what I strongly believed when a friend of mine kept wanting me to crank up "White Wedding" louder and louder.

I've given up the lazy extra gain of 5V that I think many audiophiles just use, straight into their power amps, without thinking what it does that way.  It's a convenient way to get more volume without fancy DSP devices.  Anyway, I've given up that easy road for an idea, that using digital gain to push low level inputs is better than wasted headroom.  One thing about the lazy gain is that you end up hitting analog clipping, which might be sort-of OK, happens all the time, while the digital clipping that results from using lots of digital gain when the peaks are higher than anticipated, might be destructive.  I suspect now, that it's the other way around.

A funny thing happened when I started cranking up the digital sine wave above 0dB.  I could only tell that I was at 0dB looking at the reading on the peak level indicator for the digital input to the DEQ.  I got to 0.1 peak level, then advanced -0.1dB, and it stayed at -0.1.  I kept advancing and it continued to just stay at -0.1.  So obviously 0.1 was the highest level I can read, or virtually 0dB.  Perhaps the -0.1dB I get after already getting -0.1dB would include distortion, so I was using the first 0.1dB as the real thing, so to speak.

Well that showed 2.65V (with lots more digits) on my Keithley meter.  But as I kept increasing the input (which continued to show 0.1dB) something very curious was happening.  The RMS reading kept getting higher and higher.

This is something I don't understand, but it suggests that the digital is not as peak limited as I had thought, which once again brings up the question, did I need to buy anything at all?

I'm thinking there might be some overflow region just above 0dB--as if you can have slightly higher values an 0dB.  Or, it might be that the higher amplitude getting digitally clipped just produces a higher RMS value and the non-clipped portion gets wider.  In the latter, now somewhat more plausible case, it would show that digital clipping is at least no worse than analog clipping.  Whenever you turn up the level, digitally or in the analog domain, you risk clipping later when the music gets louder.  If digital clipping is no worse than analog clipping, digital gain is no more risky than analog gain, including the lazy kind that comes from a DAC having maximum voltage higher than necessary to clip the amplifier.

Updates: I've discovered that there's no mystery as to why the level kept increasing.  The output is clipped exactly at 0dB, but as the input level increases, the sides get straighter, essentially the peak portion of the output gets larger, hence a larger RMS value even though the actual peak value at clipping is unchanged.  I've written about this in a later post.

My idea of having everything "clip" at the same level is nothing new, it's what Home Theater people call "gain structure," and it is The Correct way to do things.  If you haven't tuned the gain structure properly, you are losing resolution or dynamic range.  For my FPB 300 amplifier, the driver should have 3V RMS output, as the DAC I special ordered has.  Here's a very good discussion of Gain Structure.








Wednesday, May 10, 2017

High Output Speakers

A friend recently offered to sell me a somewhat broken (but highly repairable using the endlessly available preowned and not yet worn out parts on eBay) pair of some famous and popular rock n roll speakers, Pioneer HPM 100, for a very low price.  Though this speaker wasn't on the top of my list for future high output experiments, it's a contender, and for the price I'm paying it can also work as a garage speaker, which I need for my keyboard setup.  Even needing repair, you can tell these speakers have a punchy sound.

HPM 100 will flap out some pretty high output levels, though I haven't been able to find any exacting specifications like I can find now for the likes of JBL 4425, which are specifically rated to 114dB SPL (we could assume that's "flat" rating since it's program material and not noise--for which dBA is intended) with a graph showing the specific MOL for each frequency (114dB is only for a narrow region in the bass, the MOL at higher frequencies is somewhat lower).

Here's a list of vintage JBL speakers from which I identified the 4425 as being of interest.  Also worth looking at are 4411, 4412, 4430, and 4435.  You can tell from their parts that they are designed for high output: big woofer(s), big midrange or horns.  The maximum output of the 4411 isn't described in one number (looks to be above 105dB from the graphs shown, so I'd guestimate around 110dB) but the 4430 and 4435 are rated at 119dB and 122dB respectively and for continuous sound output (!!!).  That's what horns and big woofers can do!

Paul Klipsch (and many others) basically speak in code when they describe the need for "efficiency." In his famous speech, Klipsch says you don't need high efficiency anymore to get high output, you can simply use a high power amplifier.  But then he says with high efficiency your amplifier will distort less and therefore sound better.

It seems to me that if you have a suitably high quality amplifier, one that maintains low distortion levels even at high power output, and there are many such amplifiers today, Klipsch's second argument (that your amplifier will distort less) is as useless as the first.  Neither argument actually justifies high efficiency speakers.  In fact, quality high power amplifiers will generally have less S+N at high output than below 1 watt.  It was only 20 years ago that Nelson Pass praised the First Watt as being the most important, as for the previous decades it was seeming like the first watt was virtually ignored except by those demanding Class A or Class AB+.

But Klipsch (and the current legions of flea amp cultists) are missing one key point.  It is much easier to make a high efficiency speaker play louder than a low efficiency speaker.  Not only does a low efficiency speaker require more power input, it must also dissipate a large fraction of that power as heat, usually in very limited areas such as voice coils.  And there are serious limits in most cases as to what can be dissipated there, except in hugely costly designs.

And it's well known by fair minded people that Klipschorn K's, and the many Altec and JBL high efficiency speakers will play much more loudly than less-than-megabuck audiophile low efficiency sealed boxes.

So when Paul Klipsch brags about efficiency, what he's really doing is giving you an excuse to tote those high _output_ speakers into your living room.  Because output levels up to at least 100 dB are essential to completely accurate reproduction.





Monday, May 8, 2017

The HDCD Boost

I now have clear test evidence that my Denon DVD-9000 (which is, btw, an incredible sounding machine, might even overtake my current king Onkyo RDV-1) implements the (in)famous HDCD +6dB boost.  I haven't checked the menu, perhaps there's a way to disable this (not that I'd necessarily want to though) but I don't think many other later machines even offer such a choice.

When the Denon plays back an HDCD with the 6dB boost, it will output up to 6dB higher voltage on the output, which I believe means about 4v RMS.  I didn't measure the voltage as such, I'm reading dB on digital meters downstream, with the analog to digital sampling done by my Lavry AD10 set to reference level -9dB (which is 4dB higher than the maximum gain, -13dB, which is suited for 2V, but I sorta knew and sometimes remembered was insufficient for HDCD's and perhaps DVD-Audio's, well now I now for sure that -9dB is the highest level setting on the Lavry when playing HDCD's on the Denon).

I recall a friend of mine thought that if 6dB higher level was such a good idea, that should be incorporated into normal CD playback.  It's certainly a potentially divisive competitive issue.  I could imagine HDCD standards recommending a 6dB boost over conventional CD playback on the grounds that it's really only "uncompressing" peaks that the producer might otherwise choose to compress.  But on the other hand competing standard groups insisting this boost is unfair if they don't have it also.

In my own mind I'm still undecided on this...now that it's a pretty moot point anyway, at least for some people interested only in selling new things and services.  I have lots of HDCD's and cherish them and cherish the HDCD playback on my Denon 9000.

One of the very valid criticisms of HDCD is that it is not truly "compatible" if the boost feature is used.  The CD playback will not have those boosts, and will therefore have inferior dynamic range to what it could have if truly compatible.  HDCD got a scathing review in Audio Magazine, my cherished resource of the time, and when I read that it was enough for me.  No HDCD I decided (not that I cared much then anyway...I was in poverty then and cherishing my aged and irreplaceable Sony 507ES player).  Only a year or so a non-audiophile friend of mine was raving about how wonderful HDCD was, and I believed him, and endless HDCD listening later, I still think HDCD is great, probably better overall than SACD and close to MQA.

Anyway, in a system like mine I must know the exact level settings required for every source, for which the numbers below are a first pass:

HDCD, Denon DVD-9000: -9
CD, all players: -13 (maximum gain, I'd go to -15 perhaps if that were available)

The Onkyo RDV-1 doesn't do HDCD.  Notably Denon uses an Apogee clock, Apogee was a sort of competitor of Pacific Microsonics.

I measured the two players using HDCD and non-HDCD disk seeming to have maximum loudness (digital peak levels, measured on Behringer DEQ):

Reference Recordings RR-82CD, Track 9
Denon DVD-9000
Lavry set to -9dB
Tact set to -2.0dB
L -2.7
R -2.3

Onkyo RDV-1 (everything else the same)
L -9.1
R -8.9

The Denon is putting out 6.4dB higher level in the Left channel, 6.6dB higher level in the Right.  Most of this seems to be HDCD boost.  To be sure, I tested a non-HDCD disk, William Orbit Strange Cargo III, track 2:

DVD-9000
L -10.5
R -9.1

RDV-1
L -11
R -10.7

Now, the difference is a mere 0.5dB in the left channel, but a surprising (not impossible given analog sampling) 1.6dB difference in the right channel.

Do I need a preamp to boost levels to the Lavry?  Not really, I can just toggle the Lavry switches (though that does, quickly, become a pain, I may be getting better at it).

At the -9dB setting HDCD's have very little wasted headroom, though at -13 CD's have about 2dB wasted headroom, that's not the biggest deal.

I need to test the 9000ES though.

A word about the sound.  After returning home from vacation where I had a chance to listen to another system...there is no comparison in the lifelike scale and information density.  My system playing the RRCD 82 at levels above approaches very closely the awesomeness of being front row center in symphony hall (though I suspect my reproduction levels are somewhat lower, the noise level is lower too, perhaps there's still some residual modal response boosting the bass, somehow it works to sound real).  Most other audiophile systems I have heard sound like toy victrolas by comparison.  There are few systems I have ever heard that are about as good or better.  One is the super MBL system I heard in 2014 playing low generation tapes on a UHA machine.  It had the biggest omni midrange/tweeter system MBL makes stacked on top of itself in mirror image with equally outrageous electronics.  Like mine, that system is a force of nature.

UPDATE:  BIG NEWS ABOUT THE Sony DVD-9000ES

I measured the output level, and it was about 10dB too low from the output of the Sony 9000ES on Strange Cargo III, a non-HDCD CD.

This couldn't be right, I realized, not right at all.  So I hooked up the video monitor.  The remote control seems to have no "Setup" control.  Buy my programmed Harmony remote does, and from that I entered the Audio Menu.

Right on the top, there AUDIO ATT: and it was set to ON.  I changed that and immediately the level was restored to more or less the "correct" level (I am now using max gain for CD's so the numbers above aren't applicable).

and of course WOW DOES THIS MAKE A DIFFERENCE!!!  The formerly wimpy Sony CD sound is wimpy no more.  I was all wrong, this is a balsy sounding player not unlike the Denon DVD-9000.

I checked the manual the default and recommended setting is for AUDIO ATT to be OFF.   This is particularly strange in that the previous owner seemed to know a lot about this machine.

Now the CD levels of all my players are about the same, within 1-2dB or so anyway.  Previously the Sony was way off, and I had never realized how much.  I though I needed some nice preamp to boost the level.










Tuesday, April 25, 2017

Sony 9000ES

I still love the sound of my Sony 9000ES playing SACD's.  They are smooth sounding but plenty passionate dynamics as well.  CD's don't fare as well, they are rendered a bit too smooth generally.

[Update: I later discovered that since I bought it last year the 9000ES had the Audio Attenuator turned ON in the setup menu.  After changing that to OFF the output is now 10dB louder and precisely the same within 0.1dB as my Denon DVD-9000.  The Sony is now competitive on CD's with the Denon which is my current favorite, but the Sony still sounds slightly ethereal compared with the palpable and shake-the-earth DVD-9000.  I think in general I may prefer the Sony to the Onkyo RDV-1 on CD's, but the Onkyo output level is about 1dB lower and until I control for that any comparison will be unfair.  In any case, this change has hugely improved the 9000ES and now it seems I will not have to buy an expensive preamp to equalize the levels for nearly optimal playing if not scientific comparisons.  So I might put my money into a better main DAC instead.]

It remains my belief that the first 3 SACD players from Sony (SCD-1, SCD-777ES, and 9000ES) were extra special because they have the real 1-bit DAC (the so called Current Pulse DAC).  That was the end of the line for Sony DAC's, afterwards Sony decided simply to buy off-the-shelf DAC's from the likes of Burr Brown.

But these Current Pulse DAC's are special in that they represent the 1-bit format itself, unlike multibit Sigma Delta DACs which 'simulate' it.  I think this is what gives these early players a very important sense of dynamic realism which I've never heard from multibit Sigma Delta DACs.  Though 'feedback' remains part of even a 1-bit system, I think it has less to do and over a more limited space, a mere point inside the chip deals with the 1-bit realization of music, and using much more oversampling than sigma delta feedback.

But I may have erred in getting the 9000ES.  Back last year I figured the 9000ES would be more reliable, having a 'more conventional' drive.  But now I've discovered that it is the 9000ES, also having a unique disc spinner, that has more reliability issues, and nobody seems to have solved them.

As is now commonly known, simply replacing the laser on a 9000ES won't bring back the ability to read all SACD's.  And whatever functionality it does restore may not last for long.  Many blame the now 3rd party Chinese lasers (Sony no longer sells factory replacements...haven't for a long time actually).  But looking back in the reviews, people were having trouble and more trouble specifically with the 9000ES back to the beginning.

Another issues was that the 9000ES came out before there were any multichannel SACDS, or any multichannel hybrid SACD's.  When they did come out, many immediately found they would not play on 9000ES.  Or, as in my experience, that they would sometimes play and sometimes not.

I've been able to determine that my unit will play most hybrid multichannel discs WHEN warmed up.  And the best way to warm it up is to play a CD (or non-multichannel SACD) first.

I've tried other tricks too, such as leaving the drawer open after playing the last disc.  That works in keeping the unit "warm" for awhile, but not until the next day.  Similarly you can just leave the disc in the unit without turning anything off, and that will help keep it warm for about a day.  If you turn the unit fully off, it won't be long until it won't read another multichannel hybrid SACD off the bat, and you have to warm it up by playing a CD first.

Reading the hype about the "special" mechanism unique to this player, it seems that the disc enters the mechanism and then descends to a spindle which is lower than the SACD drawer.  This is all in the interest of making a more stable disc platform, with less vibration, which is also the goal of the "moving spindle" mechanism used in the SCD-1 and SCD-777ES.

Subsequently, in later generations of players, they both didn't seem to have so much trouble reading discs, despite far less complexity or intensity of design of the mechanism.

Was this just learning curve?  Did Sony figure out how to achieve the same goals (and even do better) with lighter simpler mechanisms?

I have a pet theory which I have no other evidence for than what I've just described.  Nobody else talks about this at all, but I have a idea.  Much of the original motivation for SACD was to make it impossible to make bit perfect copies that would play.  To that end, the SACD design includes "pit width modulation."  A conforming SACD player must detect the pit modulation, and if the pit modulation isn't correct, it will shut down playing as a "copyright violation."

My theory is that Sony lightened up on the pit modulation DRM after the first generation of players.  Later players aren't quite as picky about how the modulation is.  I wonder if they even examine it at all, though Sony has never said they stopped doing the pit modulation thing, considering all the gazillion mechanisms now made that read SACD's, I think they must have at least made it much easier.

So these first 3 players tried to do the pit modulation copyright thing to the max, and can barely be kept at a sufficient level of performance to keep on doing it.  But the outrageously costly moving spindle mechanism used in the SCD-1 may be able to do it just a tad better than the also specially engineered mechanism in the 9000ES.  So it's quite possible that SCD-1 is in the long run the more maintainable machine.  I shouldn't be telling you this, perhaps, because I still want one myself.

SCD-1's were notorious, in the beginning, for burning out lasers, but once that issue appeared to have been solved, they seem to have been more reliable than the 9000ES's.

It's perhaps not surprising that the PS Audio 1 bit DAC was inspired by the DAC in the 9000ES (and the other original players).  Just like them, it is a 10x oversampled 1-bit converter (operating at 640fS where fS is 44.1kHz).

Now I'm wondering if any other early generation machines used similar 1-bit converters, because sigma delta converters took over everything no much later.  Actually quite a few high end early players used 1704's in dual differential form.  Sony never licensed SACD on the Denon DVD 9000 which had dual differential 1704's, but they did license dual differential 1704's in the Esoteric UX-1, a few years later, and I suspect a number of other machines.  In those cases the 1-bit MUST be converted to PCM around 700kHz, because the 1704's max out around 768khz.

The Phillips SACD 1000 might have used a 1 bit converter like Sony's, but that mechanism was the most notoriously unreliable of all.  Phillips had a couple of downscaled models at that time, the 962 and 963 which might be worth investigating.  I haven't yet looked at the first SACD players from Pioneer.


Music Review Sites

Here's one I didn't know of about one of my favorite genres of music: Progressive Music Review.

I stumbled on that looking for reviews of the Tangerine Dream Bootleg Series, of which I've now bought the 2nd box set and loving it.  I could just add ALL of Tangerine Dream to my collection...but there is a LOT of Tangerine Dream out there.  I had no idea, I had one Tangerine Dream CD and figured there wasn't much more.

And to find out more about one of my favorite "dead" formats, DVD-Audio, there's DVD-A.net.  (Not updated every month, in fact a little annoying because they don't give the Year of each post, but the most recent posts look less than a year old, and who cares how old if I can still get the DVD-A's I missed first time around.)

Looking at DVD-A.net one could almost be reading Progressive Music Review, since it seems the Progressive's are at the top of the DVD-A list.  I see lots of Gentle Giant and Jethro Tull and Yes looking interesting.  I've already grabbed most of the DVD-A 'standards' including some now quite collectible.

Now I'm also aware that Esoteric (Teac) not only makes incredible disc players (I'm still lusting for a UX-1, the universal player using differential PCM 1704's, the ultimate VRDS mechanism, and playing DVD-Audio as well as SACD) but also SACD's, many many titles still available on eBay among other places, though in limited editions.



Thursday, April 13, 2017

Denon Turntables

I've got the 'ultimate' collection of turntables already (though, not 'ultimate' by the Giga Audiophile standards of today, ultimate by the standards of about 1985, which was in the heyday of vinyl after all):

1) An SP 10 MkIII, with the SP 10 MkII 'Obsidian' base and the Technics ruby bearing arm.

[Every part of this, which I paid a lot for, needs repair or extensive refurbishing, and I still have no dust cover and got no refund for that.  This was my single most catastrophic eBay purchase, a long story, which I may have described here.  Nowadays I'd lean on eBay Buyer Protection to set things right, but I let an old guy who knew far more than he let on rip me off, possibly from his jail cell.

And I don't actually know I got a MkIII.  That's what the ad said.  To confirm the motor is a MkIII I'd have to take it apart.  If it really *is* a MkIII I wouldn't feel so bad, but the seller was such a crook I have strong doubts.  Everything visible on the base says MkII and the logo was removed from top of the mechanism itself.  He was crooked, but it wasn't as if he wouldn't know the difference, he had worked in equipment supply business, and like an expert pool player, didn't let on what he knew until the end when he was trying to sell me up.]

2) A Linn Sondek LP Valhalla with Ittok Arm.

[Need Valhalla power supply repair and cart replacement.  I been too busy to make the needed contacts to get it fixed.]

3) A minty (except broken arm) Lenco, A custom heavy base, and an industry standard long arm.

[Needs full setup.  An open Saturday would be enough, maybe.]

4) A Sony PS-X800 linear tracker.

[Needs repair and possibly some refurb.]

That's my ultimate collection of tables, none working at the moment.  Meanwhile, I have a pretty good working table:

4) Mitsubishi LT-30 linear tracker, with massified and dampened arm, and Dynavector 17D3.

[Finally, after enough tweaking, it's working OK, almost as good as the PSX-800 a few years ago.]

and in my junk pile, one more of those is also working, and then I have a couple of Benjamin Miracords I bought cheap which need refurb or junking.

Anyways, I lust for a few other things, but often for a Denon in 1980's vintage.  I knew the DP 6000 was an excellent drive, bettered somewhat by the DP80 and maybe DP75.  Meanwhile, there's a list of Denons of impeccable performance including DP 59, DP 62, DP 67, DP 72.

Here's a discussion of the merits of different Denon turntables.

Here's a discussion of newer high end turntables in the Giga Audiophile class, like Rockport Sirius III.  The Torque-is-King attitude vs Belts-Are-Still-Better-Usually.  My collection was designed to demonstrate both versions, though not quite at the What's-Best level.