Saturday, March 5, 2011

New capacitor will be tight fit in acoustat interface



The picture above shows the inside of my Acoustat Red Medallion C interface with the new Solen 47uF capacitor in front.  It looks like the new capacitor (bottom) will fit either in front of the circuit board on right side, or above big transformer in back. There's more space in back, but nothing convenient to support the capacitor with and a long lead would be required, and there's high voltage back there.  I'm leaning toward front installation.

In front, the capacitor could rise straight from where the fuseholder is, or lie flat above the fuse and two speaker terminals.  Either way space is very tight, and one concern is that the capacitor would be very close to the 50K power resistor.  If the resistor gets hot it could damage the capacitor, and there is high voltage on that resistor too.  I might be able to give it "just enough" space, it looks like I could give it about 5mm space.   Opportunities for support are also limited, but it would be somewhat self-supporting from it's own lead, so doesn't need that much additional support.  If it falls "down" in operation it simply hits the wood base of the speaker. where the interace is installed.

I could possibly bend the power resistor out of the way, bit by bit using one or two sets of longnose pliers.  The danger is that I could break it off it's solder pads, or, even worse, crack the old circuit board.

Another thought crosses my mind too.  I could connect the capacitor BEFORE the fuse, so the capacitor effectively bypasses the fuse for the high frequencies.  The speaker would still be protected from DC and low frequencies, which is likely where any problem would be.  The fuse doesn't really do a great job of protection anyway from sustained loud music, sustained loud music can burn the transformer without melting the fuse.  The fuse mainly protects against amplifier failure, and also provides nuisance warnings that you are playing too loud.

I could also have the capacitor outside, either as an independent entity (with new input terminal) allowing easy changes, but clumsy and space consuming, or strapped to the case with twist tie (requires new holes in case, not easy) or glued (ugly).

Friday, March 4, 2011

Open Links

Thread I started at Gearslutz about converting absorption factor to Sabins

Nobody has answered my question directly, though it appears the correct thing is only to include front face (not even side faces) based on standard measurement procedure.  It's intended to be equivalent to an "open window".

I'm now trending away from acoustics for the moment, to focus on this weekends plan to modify Acoustats by replacing old electrolytic capacitor with Solen film.  Though perhaps I shoulda got bigger capacitor to replace whole bank of capacitors instead (I debated with myself about that ad infinitum 2 years ago).

Apparently the existing bank is 57.01 uF, consisting of one 47uF cap (the old terrible electrolytic), a 10uF film, and a 0.01 uF film (the latter two were used in original MK-121-A design in combination with a 220uF electrolytic, then the last Medallion "C" modification, which I have, changed the electrolytic to 47uF.)

Here is an Audio Asylum thread on Acoustat interface mod (starting with non-Medallion.

There's also a discussion about "tired film", something that has been worrying me.

http://www.audioasylum.com/forums/MUG/messages/15/152322.html

Here's a fairly new thread (started Feb 2010) on DIYAudio with Andy Szabo from the Hafler period of Acoustat production.  The AcoustatAnswerMan !!!

http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/planars-exotics/183168-acoustat-answer-man-here.html

Gotta replace speaker caps this weekend...

I've just decided to take a big plunge (for me).  I've decided I'm going to replace the biggest capacitor inside the Acoustat interface, part of the low pass network that drives the HF transformer (it's a bypass transformer system, with two transformers to get around bandwidth and saturation problems).

That's a 47uF 35V nonpolar electrolytic, now 20-25 years old.  I bought the replacements almost 2 years ago, 600V Solen.

There just seems to be a grundginess I can't get rid of, no matter how I angle the speakers or apply EQ.  Up close, it becomes more annoying, and it's especially bothering me now.  The speakers sound OK on solo voice, etc., but on massed orchestral...it doesn't work anymore, especially up close.

If I were typical DIYAudiophile, I'd have done this 2 years ago.  But it takes me a long time to do soldering especially because I'm klutz and perfectionist and master at procrastination.

But this weekend looks like I will have enough time, and no more excuses.  And I'm very motivated now.   I unplugged the bias before leaving for work.  I've got the manual at hand which gives discharge instructions.

(Also planned to do it when I got back from San Diego in January, left speakers unplugged during my vacation, but lacked motivation when I got back, was really focused on bass problems after hearing my brother-in-law George's system which does have decent sounding bass despite everything.)

Now the original design also has 11uF in 2 polyester film bypasses (10 and 1uF, IIRC).  For the moment, I'm leaving those alone.  Eventually, the tiny one will be teflon, and I'm not sure about the middle one.  These are said by all Acoustat modders to be very critical to the sound, highly subjective, etc.

So for the time being, I'm not messing with the films, they're probably more or less OK, and materially comparable to the Solen I'm adding.  But that pile of dried out aluminum oxide has to go.  It's probably seen more than it's rated voltage many times (especially when I was using the Krell).

George is always saying that bypass capacitor systems are wrong, you should just have one good capacitor.  He's tried all sorts of botique caps, including monsterous teflon, nowadays pretty much uses Solen in all speakers.

I couldn't decide for a few months in 1988, then just decided to take the simplest possible first step.

Tests with speaker toed away from listener

[Message sent to audio friend on Thursday]


Very good (not quite WOW yet, needs more fine tuning)!  

I tried angling out speakers last night.  Didn't try to do it perfectly, just for a quick test (around 2am).

Test didn't end up being quite so quick.

I angled speakers away from listening position by about 5-10 degrees (I can't estimate these things well), no measurements, just by eye.

Big difference in sound.  Much smoother, less crinkling plastic wrap highs, much more like real music.

Then I noticed that instead of having the image collapse as I moved closer (as usually happens) the image got even better.  So I moved chair even further up, far as I could without the image collapsing.

That seems to be some kind of new optimum.  I think it's like you said long ago (last year?) the electrostats seem to do best JUST before the highs go away totally.  If you go for max highs at axis, they sound awful.  I'm guessing that some high frequency like 10Khz is now 6dB down or thereabouts.  Which it needed to be.

Center image is solid on pop music, on classical there are slight problems now (imbalance) that needs correcting (minute readjustments).

Now I'm about 60" from speakers, and the speakers are about 72" wide.  I've never even done equalateral before, I've been using long triangles,  so this is a big jump.

If I move and lean 6" forward in chair, highs just disappear.  OK, so don't lean forward.  But if I lean back into recliner, surprise, sound remains pretty good.  The increasing highs as you approach axial compensate for the cave-like effect of the chair.  (I want to have chair back cut down, but that's another story.)  I can even recline back and it still sounds pretty good. Amazing!

This is obviously the way to go and surprising it took so long for me to get to it.

Until you get to this angle away from listening position, the sound seems rough, then all of a sudden it gets nice, then the highs go away if you go too far.  It's very non-linear.  You might think being right on speaker axis is better than being not far enough away from it, until the speakers are angled far enough away.

Wednesday, March 2, 2011

Now I think I need to angle speaker differently

Last night I surprised myself by discovering that last years listening position was 33% from back wall, and new closer position is 38.4% from back wall.  (I had thought it was actually in the front side of room!).  The TV and stereo stuff in the front actually extends out almost 5 ft max (though behind the speakers is 3 ft min because of angling).


I tend to like frequency balance in old position better, but imaging greatly improves with new position.

I've been so preoccupied with room response that I overlooked the obvious.  What I need to do is change the speaker toe for the new position.  The too-bright frequency balance is probably being caused by being very close to axial now.  Before I may have been a few degrees off axial, enough to make about 3dB difference in the highs above 5K or so according to freestanding measurement I did this morning.

It's so obvious now that Jim Strickland designed the speakers to be best slightly off axis.  He personally recommended slight toe in from listening axis, toe out might work as well.  And most likely speaker was designed this way (1) greater flexibility and (2) to compensate for HF beaming and retain highs in ambient response (a typical speaker design tradeoff).  The membrane is physically flat, has no tweeter, 9 inches wide, serious beaming is inevitable starting at something like 2khz.

Alternatively, I could turn down HF balance control.  Both speakers seem to have identical balance, despite one having NOS interface replacement two years ago.  So HF balance control(s) (inside interface and not easy to change) must be at factory setting.

My needs are so specialized in this tightly packed room I may indeed end up having to make stuff.  I'm wondering if bookcases could be re-designed to turn them into absorbers.  The backs are some kind of cardboard-like material usually.

Most manufacturers don't say what membranes they use, but one says they use 1lb/sqft barium loaded plastic.  Then behind that is typically 3lb/sqft fiberglass with some sort of air gap on either side.

WRT the higher resonances, like 215/217, since those could be affected somewhat by positioning.  They have midroom peaks as well as midroom troughs.  Though, within working range I am now, perhaps not much difference is available.

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Interesting tests and discussions wrt acoustics

I've been reading a bunch of blogs on acoustics for DIY.  Here are some interesting ones (this thread will be updated to include additional ones).  For tests of actual products, see earlier blog entry.

Tests with rigid fiberglass by Ethan Winer show that it's better to have more panels covering entire room than thicker panels covering less of room.

Another interesting thing here is  determination by Wes Lachot that dividing room 38% front-to-back and 38% floor to ceiling gives flattest response.

Wide ranging DIY trap discussion.

Wide ranging bass trap discussion at Audioholics (includes velocity vs pressure).

Bag End E-Trap system (active room mode cancellation)

Alternative room acoustic ideas

I sent the following reply to friend who sent comment on my blog entry yesterday:


Indeed, the beam does go athwart length.  The peaking is fairly shallow, though, 14 inches or so rise over 8 feet.  I've seen pictures of how trap installers straddle flat traps over the center.  But that may not address the issue you're describing, does it?  How does that work exactly?  I'm also still thinking of suspending something hanging down 10 inches or so as we discussed earlier, to catch the velocity wave.

Your argument is interesting...  Possibly true with correct design.  Funny about the old phony argument that you need big rooms to allow the bass waves to appear.  That's totally false, of course, and Ethan Winer does good job discrediting it at Real Traps site.*  Often control rooms, etc., are fairly small.  Sometimes people with tons of money create small virtual studios with 4 walls all made up of tube traps.

*But I believe big rooms are much easier to deal with for most audio fools.  I have really come to envy my brother in law.  His 3400 sq ft home has a huge living room, could be something like 45x30.  I don't think he appreciates how much other people struggle with modes.  He hears bad bass and automatically dishes out conclusions about amplifier damping factor or the need for one of his tweaks.  He also always suggest people need one of his amps, a 1960's era Sony 3200F, which he always uses with current limiter control set to 25 watts, to get the proper bass control with the acoustic suspension speaker piles he uses (one 10" woofer and one 6" woofer, corner loaded). And he always says all acoustical treatments or room dampening are undesireable, especially tube traps.  So big rooms tend to make it easy, you can be a complete fool and still get reasonable bass.  My last visit in December was a wake-up call.

With sufficiently large room, you can get modes spaced so closely (like 10Hz or so) that they don't make much difference.  In auditoriums, it's usually a non-issue (though you have lots of other issues).  That's why 1/3 octave analyzers are still useful, for auditorium work.  For home use, you need 1/48 or better resolution to see the modes and other reflection effects.

I myself have a couple of unusual arguments.  One is that backwall listening position (which I still use in bedroom) actually helps the bass.  You get all the peaks and no nulls.  Given that situation, EQ works pretty well, and that's exactly what I do (though only with manually set EQ's, the automated version always does too much).  Also, the rest of the room doesn't vibrate that much after the EQ is applied.  Downside is, of course, there is sucked out bass in the middle of the room.  So what?

Given a planar speaker with little bass output, you could put sit on the back (or even corner!) with the speakers as close to you as needed.  Result: greatly augmented bass.

I'm also wondering about subwoofer positioning.  Been looking at Home Theater Shack and one of their newer gurus consistently advises against corner sub placement ("almost never works out best").  I wonder why that's supposed to be so bad. Of course, you easily get more bass output that way.  Two of my systems have corner sub placement (the living room only nearly so because each sub angles out from the corner by length, and they are 4 feet long, and the other corner has no wall because it's entry way) and I'd never thought to question that part.   Not that modes are everything, but they are one of the most important things for bass, and the modes are their regardless of where you place the subs.

Now that I've mentioned the entry way, I actually think now *it* might be causing the cancellation in one channel sub.  The entryway (which connects to hall on other side) acts as a kind of tube.  The point at which the hallway on the other side bends might also be a great spot for bass trapping.

Realtraps has a filtered pinknoise (bass only) you can use to find the low frequency hot spots where bass traps (membrane type) would be most useful.  I plan to try that this month.  But my room has little available space for big bass traps, so this is going to be a struggle.